Substack 23.02.14
(This has been a busy week, with a short paper submitted to one of the Australian journals on the failure of state governments to comply with the requirements of the UN Convention Against Torture, and with a much longer submission to the Royal Commission Into Defence and Veteran Suicides. I was involved in veteran and military psychiatry for most of my career and saw veterans of every military engagement involving this country from 1916 to the present. As a result, today's post will be a bit shorter).
So why should anybody bother with theories in psychiatry?
"Your battles over theories of mind are not my battles."
So said a senior and well-respected researcher in the field of critical psychiatry when I circulated some material for review. That was disappointing, partly because he is very good at what he does but also because it said that people are often too close to their topic to see the bigger picture. They are so busy trying to show that psychiatric drugs are dangerous, or that results have been suppressed, or that ECT is given to the wrong groups or for the wrong reasons, that they don't stop to ask: "How come? Why does this bad stuff keep happening?" The answer is because there is no theory dictating what must be done but, more importantly, what should not be done. In the absence of a governing theory, anything goes.
Now that's very scary because, unlike general medicine, in psychiatry you're dealing with people who generally have no say in what is done to them. That means the standards of practice should be higher, not lower, as is so often the case. If you read the press or watch TV, or go to a psychiatric convention, you will get the impression that psychiatry is on the verge of a massive breakthrough which will at last defeat the scourge of mental disorder and deliver humanity to the sunny uplands. What you won't be told is all the times this has been said before ("Psychiatry has a wondrous future, and always has had"), and all the disasters that have unfolded as a result of misplaced optimism. Over the next few weeks, we will look at a few of these disasters, to provide a sobering balance to the endless flow of one-sided material. And what better place to start than psychosurgery?
From time to time, archeologists find a skull that shows signs of having holes drilled during life, as the edges of the holes have started to heal. However, nobody knows why this was done so it's a curiosity. Modern psychosurgery started in the 1930s, pushed along by a Portuguese physician, Antonio Egas Moniz (1874-1955), an almost bizarre character who managed to combine a career as a neurologist and as Portugal's foreign minister. He graduated in medicine in 1899, then worked as a lecturer while also sitting as a member of parliament. He quickly moved up the ranks and led the delegation to the Versailles Peace Conference in 1919, but he had to leave politics after being involved in a duel with a political rival. Thereafter, he concentrated on neurology and radiology and, in the mid-1920s, developed the technique of cerebral angiography (injecting contrast dye into the carotid arteries to show the brain's circulation).
This was the first time anybody could see the outline of the brain in a living person, and should have guaranteed the fame he sought but he moved on. In the early 1930s, he attended a neurology conference where two researchers presented their results on amputating the frontal lobes of chimpanzees. Instead of being irritable and aggressive, as caged chimps are, they became placid and could easily be approached. Inspired, he went home and managed to convince a neurosurgeon to operate on psychiatric patients with chronic psychoses. The results were not good but Moniz was very enthusiastic and the idea was tried elsewhere, some in Italy but mostly in the US. There, a neurologist named Walter Freeman combined forces with a neurosurgeon, James Watts, to experiment with the new technique. Watts later gave up on it but Freeman spread the idea with the fanatical zeal of a revivalist preacher. By the end of the 1940s, there were as many as 5,000 operations a year being performed in the US alone. In 1939, when Moniz was aged 65, one of his patients shot him a number of times, leaving him paralysed. In 1949, his was jointly awarded the Nobel Prize for Physiology for his "pioneering work" in developing the operation.
Back in the US, Freeman was notoriously impatient and soon got tired of trying to convince neurosurgeons to use his operation. He realised the quickest and easiest way to cut brains was to do it himself, so he devised his own procedure. Armed with an instrument he called a leucotome (a tool like an ice-pick to cut the white matter), his operation consisted of quickly rendering the patients unconscious, either with a short anaesthetic or by giving them a seizure through ECT, then shoving the pick above the eye, through the thin bone of the orbit, and straight into the brain. A few quick wiggles with the tool and the operation was over. His goal was to be able to do this in any medical office in the country so he travelled around, from one hospital to the next, to publicise his procedure. He actually had his own van, which he called his lobotomobile, and drove himself around, often arriving unannounced at a mental hospital and convincing them to supply patients as a demonstration to the medical staff. What the patients thought of it is not recorded.
By the late-1950s, after psychiatric drugs became available, the procedure was gradually dropped but a proper assessment at any stage would have shown the results were poor to terrible. If this was ever done, the studies were quickly buried. In different places around the world, it limped along until the early 1990s, driven mostly by one or two devotees, mostly with strong connections to the academic/political axis. It is banned in Australia and in most countries around the world. As far as psychiatry goes, its long infatuation with "psychosurgery" has been dumped in a "memory hole," carefully ignored until one day, everybody forgets it ever happened. But what are the lessons?
The first lesson is this: Don't do anything to a vulnerable person until you know precisely what you are doing. At no stage in the entire 60 year saga did anybody sit down and write a model of mind, or of mental disorder, or anything, that justified hacking bits out of people's brains. Nobody had the faintest idea of what they were doing. Neurophysiology hardly existed, there was absolutely nothing written anywhere that amounted to a justification of the belief that mental trouble was caused by sick brains, and the people pushing it were zealots, not dispassionate researchers. The whole thing was hype, driven by personalities and by people making a lot of money out of it.
Occasionally, psychiatrists try to justify their foray into psychosurgery by saying "Well, people were desperate, there was nothing else. As fast as they built mental hospitals, they filled up so they had to do something." Er, did anybody ask whether it was the mental hospitals that were actually doing the damage, that treatment in those places was worse than the disease? No, they didn't, even though the idea that physicians can be a health hazard goes back to Greek times. The Hippocratic Oath actually says "Primum non nocere," First do no Harm. This has real significance today and we'll talk more about it.
The history of psychiatry is horrifying. Anybody who wants more detail can watch the PBS Frontline documentary on Walter Freeman, called The Lobotomist. This is very good, and very scary.
Two recent books are worth reading:
Harrington, Anne (2019). Mind Fixers: Psychiatry's troubled search for the biology of mental illness. This looks mainly at US history, and is readable but fairly lengthy (380 pages).
Scull, Andrew (2022). Desperate Remedies: Psychiatry and the mysteries of mental illness. A broader and longer (512 pages) history. Very readable, if you like being scared.
Some older books, mainly military in focus:
Dean, Eric (1997). Shook Over Hell: Post-traumatic stress, Vietnam and the Civil War. A scholarly and gripping study by a historian and lawyer, that shows there is nothing new under the sun.
Shepherd, Ben (2002). A War of Nerves: Soldiers and psychiatrists 1914-1994. Fairly long, nearly 500 pages, detailed study by a well-qualified historian.
Holden, Wendy (1998). Shell Shock: The psychological impact of war. Mainly looks at British experience, including Churchill's brutally dismissive comment about the potential value of psychiatrists in dealing with battle casualties, in which he also managed to dismiss the casualties.
Moore, William (1974). The Thin Yellow Line. The horrifying story of the use of the death penalty in armies, mainly Allied, and how it was used to keep terrified and mentally-shattered men in line.

Sounds similar to what they do now - giving teenagers hysterectomies and double mastectomies to affirm their gender and prevent suicide.
The lobotomobile!? Another case of truth stranger than fiction. Thank you for your efforts in keeping the facts in the light of day and advocating for those whose voices are muted.