I've had a couple of comments from readers who were not happy with my views on Thomas Szasz (Jan 9th 2024) so I will explain my position, because it brings up a critically important point.
Dr McLaren, I had no idea of the position of Szasz that mental illness were faked by the sufferers! Was this position maintained in later years of his life? My understanding of Dr Szasz was that he was against psychiatric drugs and compare them to the street drugs. Thanks 🙂
He didn't budge in his position except to become more extreme as he got older. Need to remember that he knew no neurobiology at all. He read voraciously but only topics that interested him, meaning only those topics that agreed with his views. His knowledge of history was superficial and of philosophy was patchy, essentially the German classics. I don't recall that he knew any analytic philosophy at all. He was a very forceful speaker and radiated a sublime confidence that appealed to a lot of people, esp. anybody who didn't like psychiatry. In my view, he attempted to elevate his rather peculiar personality to the level of a general philosophy for all humans, which is never a good idea. What this meant was that the good bits in his message were flooded by the bad bits, so psychiatrists fixate on those and discard everything he wrote. A pity, but that says a lot about them, too. The hostility that psychiatrists direct toward critics is a direct measure of their intellectual (and emotional) insecurity.
To be fair, Szasz never denied the fact of human suffering and he was not without compassion to others. Part of the problem in many of the critical psychiatry movement is that it wishes to displace victimhood for victimhood and saviour for saviour. Where mainstream psychiatry wishes people to be a victim of their brain disorder and psychiatry the expert class to over come it (often by force), many critics see the patient as a victim of trauma, the DSM and big bad pharma. That or theirs is a socialist project in which the patient is a victim of capital with pharma a manifestation. Apart from the horrors of coercive psychiatry, what Szasz made clear was how often patients are perversely incentivised to create and/or amplify their own illness. There are countless undeniable examples of this. Responsibility goes hand in hand with liberty. It would be meanspirited to imply he was forgotten because he had nothing valuable to say. The establishment made enormous efforts to have him forgotten and the critical psychiatry movement rejected him on the basis of its leftist politics contra Szasz extreme libertarianism. I have written an homage to Szasz myself. Psychiatry would be the better if to remember Szasz IMHO
Dr McLaren, I had no idea of the position of Szasz that mental illness were faked by the sufferers! Was this position maintained in later years of his life? My understanding of Dr Szasz was that he was against psychiatric drugs and compare them to the street drugs. Thanks 🙂
He didn't budge in his position except to become more extreme as he got older. Need to remember that he knew no neurobiology at all. He read voraciously but only topics that interested him, meaning only those topics that agreed with his views. His knowledge of history was superficial and of philosophy was patchy, essentially the German classics. I don't recall that he knew any analytic philosophy at all. He was a very forceful speaker and radiated a sublime confidence that appealed to a lot of people, esp. anybody who didn't like psychiatry. In my view, he attempted to elevate his rather peculiar personality to the level of a general philosophy for all humans, which is never a good idea. What this meant was that the good bits in his message were flooded by the bad bits, so psychiatrists fixate on those and discard everything he wrote. A pity, but that says a lot about them, too. The hostility that psychiatrists direct toward critics is a direct measure of their intellectual (and emotional) insecurity.
To be fair, Szasz never denied the fact of human suffering and he was not without compassion to others. Part of the problem in many of the critical psychiatry movement is that it wishes to displace victimhood for victimhood and saviour for saviour. Where mainstream psychiatry wishes people to be a victim of their brain disorder and psychiatry the expert class to over come it (often by force), many critics see the patient as a victim of trauma, the DSM and big bad pharma. That or theirs is a socialist project in which the patient is a victim of capital with pharma a manifestation. Apart from the horrors of coercive psychiatry, what Szasz made clear was how often patients are perversely incentivised to create and/or amplify their own illness. There are countless undeniable examples of this. Responsibility goes hand in hand with liberty. It would be meanspirited to imply he was forgotten because he had nothing valuable to say. The establishment made enormous efforts to have him forgotten and the critical psychiatry movement rejected him on the basis of its leftist politics contra Szasz extreme libertarianism. I have written an homage to Szasz myself. Psychiatry would be the better if to remember Szasz IMHO
Always enjoy your thoughts Niall. Thanks deb
My pleasure. Feel free to spread it around, the more readers, the more support we get.