I've had a couple of comments from readers who were not happy with my views on Thomas Szasz (Jan 9th 2024) so I will explain my position, because it brings up a critically important point.
Thomas Szasz (1920-2012), was a Hungarian-born psychiatrist who spent most of his career at Upstate University, Syracuse, NY. He was a prolific author, publishing some 35 books over about fifty years, including no less than seventeen books in the last twenty years of his long life, as well as hundreds of articles, papers, commentaries, lectures etc. He travelled extensively and must have given thousands of lectures and talks on his theme.
All of this has stimulated an enormous secondary literature of many thousands of books and papers but, since his death, his influence on psychiatry, never great during his lifetime, has almost entirely disappeared. The 1970s were "peak Szasz," e.g. in 1977, the Australasian Medical Students' Association flew him out for a national lecture tour. It must have cost them heaps even though students generally don't have much ready cash. This was a very strong political statement by the medical students which rocked the psychiatric establishment but, when last I asked a group of students, not one of them had heard of Thomas Szasz.
The bibliography of Szasz in Wikipedia does not include an autobiography. To my knowledge, the only such material is an introductory chapter in the book [1] edited by his long-time colleague, psychologist Jeffrey Schaler, Szasz Under Fire: the psychiatric abolitionist faces his critics (2003). The book consists of twelve chapters by critics with commentaries by Szasz. His 28 page introduction shows he was born into a secure, upper middle-class Jewish family in Budapest, shortly after Hungarian independence. His father, who had trained as a lawyer, was a successful businessman while his mother, whom he described as “beautiful” in every respect, was devoted to her family and home. He felt his parents had a warm marriage and his mother appeared to have doted on him, not least because he was the younger of her two sons and was “sickly” as a child. His uncle was a renowned mathematician who moved to the US and was later able to sponsor the family to migrate before the Second World War engulfed Hungary's large and intellectually influential Jewish community.
By 1933, the beginning of high school, and against his father's wishes, Szasz decided he wanted to study medicine, but for his own reasons: “I wanted to go to medical school not because I wanted to practice medicine but because I wanted to know medicine. If... I couldn't get into medical school, my second choice was to become a writer” [1, p9]. Later, he said he trained in psychiatry for the same reason. He arrived in the US in late 1938 and, after a few years, was able to study medicine. Subsequently, he began training in psychiatry in Chicago which, at the time, essentially meant psychoanalysis. There is no indication that he ever studied biology after he graduated from medical school in June, 1944, long before the era of molecular biology.
In the early 1950s, he served a “comfortable” two year term in the US Navy, based in USN Medical Center, Bethesda, Maryland. From there, he moved to Syracuse as he wanted a quiet, rural setting where he could read and write [1, p26]. Of his early education, he said:
I intensely disliked going to elementary school … I learned to malinger… I had a powerful motive to malinger … I learned not only how to lie about feeling ill, but how to cough, how to vomit, and how to have a fever, by surreptitiously placing the thermometer close to a lighted light bulb. I was well aware of the difference between being ill and occupying the sick role… [1, p4].
While in high school, he learned of the famous Hungarian obstetrician, Ignaz Semmelweiss (1818-1865), whose statue stood in a small park near his school. He must have walked past it many times in those years:
I was deeply moved by the story of Semmelweiss' tragic life. It taught me, at an early age, the lesson that it can be dangerous to be wrong, but to be right, when society regards the majority's falsehood as truth, could be fatal... Even as an adolescent, once I grasped the scientific concept of disease, it seemed to me self-evident that many persons categorised as mentally ill and incarcerated in mental hospitals are not sick; instead, they exhibit behaviors unwanted by others, who diagnose them as mad and lock them up; and that this is why, unlike medical patients, menatl patients insist they are not ill [1, p27].
In his book, The Myth of Psychotherapy, he repeatedly states a theme that echoes through all his work, that people who claim to be mentally ill or whose actions attract the label are acting fraudulently and with full conscious intent to deceive: “...Mesmer’s practice, like that of all psychotherapists before and since him, was devoted exclusively to persons who pretended to be ill” [2, p49]. There are dozens of points throughout this book where he explicitly states that patients are only pretending: “...their patients who pretend to be ill... persons with pretended illnesses...” [2, p55]; “...both had hysterical – that is, pretended – illnesses...” “What was wrong with these ‘nervous patients’? ...the patients pretended they were ill, because they malingered or faked illness” [2, p96]. “I have described elsewhere the pretences of neurotics and psychotics claiming to be patients...” [2, p196]. “...patients with ...most so-called mental illnesses do not make ‘appropriate efforts’ to get well. Indeed, they usually make no such efforts at all, and try, instead, to be authenticated as ‘sick’...” [2, p197]. He repeats this claim hundreds of times in his other works. There is, however, no empirical evidence to support his claim: it is wholly an unsupported opinion.
Similarly, he said, psychiatrists who diagnose or treat people as mentally ill are party to a conspiracy to defraud. There are so many supportive references that one can almost open any of his books at any page and find comments to this effect. For example: “All this (psychiatry) is fakery and pretence whose purpose is to ‘medicalise’ certain aspects of the study and control of human behaviour” [3, p4]. Except for a very restricted form of psychotherapy, all psychiatric treatment is either a money-grubbing sham or state-sanctioned brutalisation of society’s scapegoats: “…doctors have invented two different kinds of such non-existent diseases, bodily and mental… mythical disorders of the uterus and ovaries… mythical ailments of the liver… examples of the (mental) are all of the mental diseases… the various anxiety and stress disorders today… as the medical profession and the public have redefined the rules of the medical game, (telling the truth) has ceased to be an option altogether” [4, p36].
The theme of his life's work is this: “...mental illness is a non-existent or fictitious condition” [4, p107]. That is, there is no objective physical basis to the types of behaviours termed psychiatric diseases, so: “...mental illnesses are not bona fide diseases... they are personal problems in living... I simply prefer not to place deviance in the category of disease” [4, p162]. Apart from brain disorders to be treated by neurologists, all of what is now called mental illness, disease or disorder is simply problems of living compounded by frank deceit and should be dealt with accordingly. Crime must not be attributed to or excused by mental disorder because that is the worst form of dishonesty. Soldiers with “so-called war neuroses” are simply acting crazy or sick to escape their duty [2, p90-91].
****
At age twelve, while still in primary school, I read a biography of Ignaz Semmelweiss and the virulent hostility he faced when he said that puerperal fever ("childbed fever," a fatal beta-haemolytic strepotoccal infection of the vagina and uterus following delivery) was transmitted by the dirty hands of the obstetricians who delivered the women. Eventually, it killed him. I found his story immensely moving and inspirational. During my career as a psychiatrist, I saw far more patients, including military and refugees, from much more diverse backgrounds than Thomas Szasz ever did. I do not believe that the overwhelming majority of mentally-troubled people are pretending. It's actually very rare: you can't pretend to be having a panic attack. I think Szasz got that completely wrong, and his childhood indicates why. As for psychiatrists, I think he was right, there is a great deal of fraud going on but he got the wrong fraud: psychiatrists proudly tell everybody they understand the nature of mental disorder when, as a matter of demonstrated fact, they don't [5]. But nor did Szasz.
Next question: Does this matter? I believe it does. It's a small step from saying:
“...mental illness is a non-existent or fictitious condition” [4, p107], to:
"Rape/bushfires/war etc cannot cause mental disorder, we know it's genetic," to:
"Your claim for treatment/compensation/pension is fraudulent," to:
"By lodging this claim, you are guilty of a crime and you will be punished."
Does this happen? Most assuredly it does. In Germany, after World War I, there were millions of mentally-disturbed veterans. The most influential psychiatrist in the country, Julius Wagner-Jauregg, who gained fame and the Nobel Prize for developing malaria pyrotherapy treatment for tertiary syphilis, was convinced war could not cause mental disorder (he had no military experience himself). He believed, and convinced many other powerful people, that it was all a sham, a dishonest attempt to escape duty or cheat the government of pensions and benefits. He developed a machine to shock the men out of their silly beliefs that they were "mental." This delivered painful electric shocks that could be increased until the men "gave up" their symptoms but, in fact, many of them were killed by the "treatment" (see his entry in Wikipedia; also in Andrew Scull's excellent history, Desperate Remedies). This became a national scandal and Wagner-Jauregg was investigated prior to prosecution, but Sigmund Freud managed to save his bacon.
Even today, in this country, there's a sizeable cottage industry of psychiatrists who, for a suitable fee, will say that people claiming compensation for mental injuries are putting it on, that there's nothing wrong with them or they're over it or it was caused by something else. So it matters to say, as Thomas Szasz did, that all mental disorder is pretence, that people with mental symptoms are making it up (see [6], p100). Just as a further reminder, in the current "anti-abortion" hysteria in the US, a woman who miscarried at home was charged criminally, even though she had been to hospital and was told the pregnancy was non-viable. Yes, the charges were dismissed but investigating and charging her would have been immensely distressing, especially after losing the pregnancy. There were actually two miscarriages: the baby, and justice.
Moving on, what do psychiatrists mean when they say "We understand the nature of mental disorder"? It's the difference between saying "That car is very fast," and "That car has a turbocharged, DOHC V6 driving through a six-speed semi-automated sequential gearbox with paddle shifters." The first statement is descriptive only, it tells you that the car is fast, while the second (provided you know all the jargon) is explanatory, it tells you why it's fast. There's a world of difference between those two statements which the majority of psychiatrists don't get. Well, if their DSM system is anything to go on, they don't, because it's purely descriptive.
A descriptive statement simply describes something as it exists at that moment. It doesn't tell you how it got there, why it remains there or what will happen to it, all it can ever tell you is that it's there. I can say: "There's a scratch on the car, I'll get it repaired." That's pure description, it says nothing about how the scratch got there. I get it fixed but, when I check a few days later, there's another scratch in much the same place. Obviously, it would have been better to have said: "There's a scratch on the car. How did it get there?" I walk up the drive and find a loose wire poking out of the fence where a branch fell in a storm. Silly me: always follow the same process. Step 1: Identify that something is the case. Step 2: find an explanation of why it is the case.
In general medicine, this is elementary. Your first patient for the day, old Mr Smith, says "I have swelling of my ankles." You check and sure enough, he has pitting oedema to his knees. You have two jobs: first to do something about it, so you prescribe diuretics and tell him to lay off the salted chips, and second is to explain it. The diagnosis is descriptive only, not explanatory, so your second task is to find why his feet are swollen and to deal with it. You order blood tests, chest Xray, ECG, and he totters out, another happy customer of the theory of reductive biomedicine.
The next patient is young Mr Jones, who says: "I feel sad and miserable all the time, no energy, no interest, no sex life. I feel I'm a burden and everybody would be better off if I disappeared."
Quickly, you pull out your trusty DSM-5 and skim through the headings. "Aha," you announce, "I can tell you're depressed."
"No shit, Sherlock," he says, "I knew that. I need something for it but more important, I need to know why."
"Some people," you mutter as you struggle to recall your psychiatry classes so long ago. "OK, depression = antidepressants. Here you are, come back in a month."
"That's it?" he says. "Don't we need to talk about why?"
"No no, the diagnosis says it all. You're depressed means take antidepressants. See you in a month."
He's persistent: "So there's no explanation?"
You give him your indulgent smile: "Of course there is, but it's all biological. It's too complicated so you don't need to worry about that. Trust me, I'm a doctor."
He goes out uncertainly and rebooks for a month. However, you're busy so you don't notice that he hasn't appeared until months later, you get a request from the Coroner's office for a copy of your notes. Mr Jones, it appears, is no longer with us. Oh dear, so sad, you did your best but obviously he had a very bad attack and nature won.
This is what happens when your diagnosis is descriptive only, with no explanatory value. All modern psychiatric diagnoses are descriptive only, with no explanatory value, as psychiatry believes it's all biological so no further explanation is needed. This is unproven.
Does biology say it all? There are certainly plenty of people around who firmly believe it does, and not just psychiatrists. Eminent philosopher Daniel Dennett, of Tufts University in Boston, is one. Biology is everything, the rest is airy-fairy nonsense, fit only for poets and dreamers [7]. Religious historian and part-time philosopher, Richard Carrier, is perfectly explicit:
... in every case I have examined, I have been able to reduce an abstraction to some repeating or repeatable pattern of matter-energy in space-time ...more and more it appears that all of sociology can be reduced to psychology, all of psychology can be reduced to biology, all of biology can be reduced to chemistry, and all chemistry to physics, which is the study of matter and energy in space-time. Therefore, everything is matter-energy in space-time [8, S.III.5.4.2].
It's so neat, no loose ends to mess up the theory ... Who could possibly disagree? All that's missing is an explanation of how minds reduce to brains. Trouble is, for all the talk of how psychiatry is on the cusp of huge progress, and for all the money spent (the NIMH spent US$20billion during the 13yr tenure of its former director, Thomas Insel), and for all the drugs (one Australian adult in six takes anti-depressants), there is no explanation. There is no "biomedical model" for psychiatry, they forgot to write it. There is certainly no integrative model of body and mind (a "biopsychosocial" model), that's a mirage (but watch this space). Psychoanalysis is dead and buried, behaviorism went nowhere ... it's all looking a bit grim. But wait, psychiatry to the rescue. The latest edition of the RANZCP's main journal has just what the doctor ordered, a brilliant and entirely novel theory. In a five page editorial, a Melbourne psychiatrist has given his account of how we should understand the mind as an exercise in thermodynamics. You read that correctly. This is fairly complicated so we'll talk about it next week but I don't think anybody should rush out to buy a brain thermometer just yet.
References:
1. Schaler, JA (2004) Szasz Under Fire: The Psychiatric Abolitionist Faces His Critics. Chicago: Open Court.
2. Szasz, T.S. (1979), The Myth of Psychotherapy. New York: Anchor Press/Doubleday.
3. Szasz, T.S. (1961). The Myth of Mental Illness: Foundations of a Theory of Personal Conduct. Revised Edition. New York: Harper and Row (Perennial Library). Page numbers refer to the revised edition (1974).
4. Szasz, T.S. (1987). Insanity: the Idea and its Consequences. New York: Wiley.
5. McLaren N (2023). The Biopsychosocial Model and Scientific Deception. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry, 25: 106-118. DOI: 10.1891/EHPP-2023-0008.
6. McLaren N (2018). Anxiety: The Inside Story. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
7. Dennett DC (2017). From Bacteria to Bach and Back: the evolution of minds. London: Allen Lane.
8. Carrier R (2005). Sense and Goodness Without a God: a defence of metaphysical naturalism. Bloomington, IN: AuthorHouse (my copy is on Kindle so it doesn't have page numbers but it's easy to track).
Additional material on Thomas Szasz: Chaps 12 and 13 of McLaren N (2012). The Mind-Body Problem Explained: The Biocognitive Model for Psychiatry. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press. Some of the above material will appear in my forthcoming revision of my early books, due out in about July this year.
****
This material is copyright but can be copied or quoted on condition the author is acknowledged.
****
Abbreviations:
OPCAT: Optional Protocol to the UN Convention Against Torture
NIMH: National Institute for Mental Health, Bethesda, Maryland, USA.
RANZCP: Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists
RCPsych: Royal College of Psychiatry (UK).
UNCAG: UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.
UNCAT: UN Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.
UNCRPD, or just CRPD: UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
WHO: World Health Organisation.

Dr McLaren, I had no idea of the position of Szasz that mental illness were faked by the sufferers! Was this position maintained in later years of his life? My understanding of Dr Szasz was that he was against psychiatric drugs and compare them to the street drugs. Thanks 🙂
To be fair, Szasz never denied the fact of human suffering and he was not without compassion to others. Part of the problem in many of the critical psychiatry movement is that it wishes to displace victimhood for victimhood and saviour for saviour. Where mainstream psychiatry wishes people to be a victim of their brain disorder and psychiatry the expert class to over come it (often by force), many critics see the patient as a victim of trauma, the DSM and big bad pharma. That or theirs is a socialist project in which the patient is a victim of capital with pharma a manifestation. Apart from the horrors of coercive psychiatry, what Szasz made clear was how often patients are perversely incentivised to create and/or amplify their own illness. There are countless undeniable examples of this. Responsibility goes hand in hand with liberty. It would be meanspirited to imply he was forgotten because he had nothing valuable to say. The establishment made enormous efforts to have him forgotten and the critical psychiatry movement rejected him on the basis of its leftist politics contra Szasz extreme libertarianism. I have written an homage to Szasz myself. Psychiatry would be the better if to remember Szasz IMHO