20 Comments
User's avatar
Tim Wilson's avatar

Dear Niall,

For me this post is one of the most important things you have written in recent times. It resulted in a number of pieces of my life jigsaw puzzle falling into place.

I was previously aware of your claim that anxiety was the root cause of most mental health problems. I have observed this tendency both in myself and others that I have attempted to support in recent years.

I started life with what could be described as an anxious, easily excitable personality. If anything is genetic about mental health it may be the degree of "sensitivity" a person has in much the same way as a small percentage of the population have red hair. On the other hand, according to my mother, my arrival in this world was a precarious one. Apparently her umbilical cord got wound around my neck and they thought they had lost me. Maybe that was the cause of a life time of difficulties. Who knows and does it really matter?

In my late teens I started noticing unusual experiences which developed into prominent audible voices and other unusual experiences. In my early 20's I was involuntarily hospitalised. In those days anyone hearing voices was inevitably diagnosed as schizophrenic.

According to a friend who I shared a house with at the time I went into the psychiatric hospital somewhat confused and disoriented but still a functional human being. I was released several months later a complete nut case. Coping with that hospital experience and the many that followed together with the embarrassment, shame and stigma of this ongoing affliction has been a life long challenge.

I still hear voices to varying degrees but they don't trouble me these days. I am involved with the Intervoice International Hearing Voices Movement. It is interesting that only a small percentage of people who routinely hear voices, perhaps 10% to 20%, finish up in the hands of the mental health authorities. They are invariably the ones who experience significant distress as a result of these phenomena and go seeking help or explanations from main stream mental health authorities.

In my own case unmanageable anxiety is probably the underlying cause of psychosis. At a certain point the pot simply boils over and rational thought and control are partly or completely lost for anything from a few minutes up to many hours. This phenomena is known as amygdala hijacking. The return to normality can be significantly facilitated by a safe and supportive environment. Unfortunately the opposite can also happen. The psychotic person's distress can easily trigger angry, hostile or isolating dismissive behaviour from others and this can cause an already problematic situation to escalate.

All this typically gets compounded by conflicting beliefs and values which appear to play a part in the escalating stress and anxiety. Boundary issues also often play a significant part. People with a tendency to psychosis become easy victims and this sense of vulnerability, no doubt often fuelled by imagination, reduces the triggering threshold for psychosis.

One of the things I often notice in the prodromal phase of psychosis is a feeling of confusion. In the post psychotic phase, sometimes referred to as post psychotic depression I frequently find myself trying to sort out or make sense of the relevant conflict. This is where voices can be helpful. For me they are often the forerunner of writing down some of these experiences.

I hope this information is of some interest to you or help to somebody. The information commonly available about schizophrenia and related psychotic experiences appears to me to be a minefield of ignorance and often sheer stupidity.

Regards

Tim Wilson

website https://PinkPantherActivists.au

Niall McLaren's avatar

Thanks for your very thoughtful comment.

PC's avatar

Why is it the only recursive emotion? I understand the logic as to why you state it is recursive but what about anger for example.

Animals are clearly conscious and have mental experiences, although I would say that each animal including humans has a unique informational space which means we don’t share certain experiences and neither do they (wondering what the sun is for example).

Incidentally, came across an article detailing a psychiatrist getting a Nobel Prize for optogenetics to “switch on and off neural circuits….for neurological and psychiatric disorders". Although they clearly haven’t been used for that and not sure how they ever could be.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5ev3ypmzly8o

Niall McLaren's avatar

The presence of the symptoms constitutes a new threat which amplifies the fear response, which serves in turn to generate new symptoms to panic over. It is genuinely recursive in the formal sense that the outcome of each iteration of the function forms the starting point of the next iteration. This is vitally important in many fields as the basis of non-linear mathematics but psychiatry persists in thinking in linear terms.

I agree about the privacy of each emergent mental state, there simply are no connections for informational transfer apart from speech. Imagine if there were no privacy, no secrecy. Life would be very different, somebody must have written a science fiction book on just this subject.

Interesting that Diesseroth worked in the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, which was Erik Kandel's stamping ground. Kandel trained in psychiatry but failed his finals as he spent all his time working in laboratories including studying melatonin in goldfish hypothalami; he bore the institution of psychiatry a lifelong animosity for their impertinance in failing him.

As for optogenetics aiding psychiatry, that's just propaganda. Of no value at all.

Gnuneo's avatar

"there simply are no connections for informational transfer apart from speech."

In terms of information transfer ie communication, even among humans with the same language and culture, speech generally is the smallest element of communication. Body language, intonation, the vast bulk of communication is non-verbal. It's hard for we intellectuals to really get this, as culturally, we tend to put high value on high concepts, which can really only be transferred by the word. But in terms of total communication bandwidth, the actual words don't take up a lot. How they look, posture, dom/sub attitudes, nervous tics, verbal tics, intone - all of this is taking up much more of our total awareness most of the time in conversation.

Why yes, I did grow up on F. Herbert's Bene Gesserit, how DID you guess, lol.

As I've mentioned to you before, I also don't rule out TP, due to considerable experiences. But there's no need to go into that territory.

If someone is terrified, would you only know when they TELL you they are terrified?

Nah, lol. Unless they are incredibly controlled individuals.

On top of which, I'd say there is "group-feel", as well as "group-think". Emotions can spread, and intoxicate. Tbf, spending a few months travelling among people who do not share a language with you, and you only have a dictionary to communicate with, and sometimes not even that, is one of the best ways to learn how much is communicated without a language. Especially in stressful or intense situations.

Niall McLaren's avatar

Agreed, as I said, anxiety is the most communicable of all emotions and 99% of it is non-linguistic. People, esp. males, try to conceal it, to pretend they're cool but anybody can tell they're not. Trump is quite seriously anxious, panics if he thinks people, esp. women, don't like him because inside, he knows he's nothing. They're the most dangerous because the need to control what people are thinking can drive them to extremes. eg when he says "annihilate Iran," a significant part of what passes for his mind is not joking. He doesn't joke, he has no sense of humour. Very dangerous, I prefer snakes.

Gnuneo's avatar

I know what you mean by that. Animals are generally rational. All animals. Humans get lost in too much conceptualising, as in Philip K Dick's novels.

Trump 2.0 is supremely dangerous, although if he'd stuck with his campaign promises not as much as now he's listened to Nuttyahoo and has gotten himself stuck in his own wars.

There again, I couldn't in any conscience have supported the demonrats either. Shame the "Leader of the Free World" has a deeply undemocratic gerrymandered duopoly uniparty to "choose between".

Jill would have been by far the better choice, and Bernie before her.

Gnuneo's avatar

You are too clever. The story of the snakes itself caused a panic reaction, as you well knew it would in non-Australians, lmao. And so readers can follow their own internal anxiety reaction from simply READING about a threat, and then watch it fade away as your calm story continues. :'D

QED, as the phrase goes.

You know, one of the things the "elites" would really love is ultra-loyal, completely unafraid soldiers who will walk into certain death calmly - and also commit atrocities without a blink.

[Yeah, we now have robotics on the way, I'm sure that will be fun for the 99.999% of humans who won't be in control of them.]

Drugs seemed like a reasonable choice to achieve this goal, considering the EXTENSIVE history of official drug use in warfare, on every side. And what the results of that were.

I just have this feeling that the "elites" don't actually care about how good the population is feeling, (As long as they can still be forced to work to make them more money), unless they see an angle for their own ends. They're certainly not going to throw billions away on research without that.

Hadn't really considered so deeply the depth of anxiety before, but you're 100% correct - well, that's what decades of intelligence, experience and study gives. I would have knee-jerk said that love was stronger - at least personally, having a loved one (Incl a pet) in severe danger overcomes the anxiety we feel ourselves in the dangerous situation.

The adrenaline come-down hits later.

But when the threat is in the 'future/past', ie in our thoughts, you're right it just feeds upon itself with no limits.

Gnuneo's avatar

Yeah... it wasn't just the Germans though. All the allied forces were high AF in various battles as well. Not something they mention in the Hollywood films, oddly enough.

Btw, do you recall the Falklands? That famous overnight "yomp" by the marines, coming upon the sleeping Argentinian recruits? They were totally off their tits. And they bayoneted not only sleeping conscripts, but also the ones that had surrendered. They were crazy.

Long ago I had a link to a great resource that listed many, though unlikely to be all, examples of drug (mainly speed-based, obviously... don't think shrooms would be much help, lmao) use in modern militaries over the past century plus. Massive eye-opener.

Niall McLaren's avatar

Can you send a link to that item on Falklands? I remember it well, Pommy jingoism as its worst.

Gnuneo's avatar

OK, I gave up, but then had the idea to ask deepseek with a cunning question.

"Hello DS. Decades ago, I found a report by some of the British soldiers who took part in the Falklands War, claiming that they had been given drugs, such as amphetamine, such as the famed overnight yomp by the marines.

But I can't find such an article again. Can you help?"

---

It sounds like you are remembering a specific report from around 2007, when the British Ministry of Defence (MoD) officially acknowledged the use of amphetamines by soldiers. While I couldn't find the exact article from "British soldiers" you mentioned, I found several news reports from that time that discuss the policy and its potential connection to the Falklands War.

### 📰 The 2007 Ministry of Defence Admission

In June 2007, multiple news outlets reported that the UK MoD had admitted for the first time to giving soldiers controversial stimulant drugs to keep them awake for up to 60 hours straight .

* **The Drug:** The primary drug mentioned was **Amphetamine Dexedrine** (a type of amphetamine) . The reports also noted that **Ephedrine** tablets were distributed, which have a milder effect .

* **The Context:** The MoD confirmed the use of these drugs but did not specify the purpose in the initial reports, though experts noted they are used to keep soldiers awake and alert during special operations .

### 🔗 The Falklands Connection

The link to the Falklands War (and specifically the "yomp") comes from the context of these drugs being used by **British commando units**, which includes the Royal Marines who conducted the famous yomp .

A 2006 linguistics forum post discussing military slang notes that "bennies" (Benzedrine tablets) were issued to and taken by British commando units . The same discussion mentions a vague memory of a news article during the Falklands War where soldiers were admonished for their slang, though that specific article does not appear in the search results.

### 🔍 How to Find Your Specific Article

The reports I found are from Chinese and international news agencies reporting on the MoD's admission. To find the specific British report you remember, you might try searching for terms like:

* `"MoD admits amphetamines Falklands"`

* `"British soldiers drugs Falklands yomp"`

* `"Benzedrine Falklands War"`

---

Annoyingly the links were dropped in the c/p, but essentially all it could find was that commandos and marines were commonly using slang such as "bennies", and that in 2007 the UK regime admitted to administering such to troops.

However, as London is quite famously the most "secretive country in the World" - and it is - one gets used to such informational disappearances.

So, all we have is the regime admitting they have issued them, an overnight escapade of extreme physical exertion (Takes me back to the 90s... <3 ), which ended in extreme, completely unjustified violence against unarmed or asleep conscripts.

And I have a memory of reading about it, sigh.

Gnuneo's avatar

00s... probably the site wouldn't even still exist even if I had the link.

I'll do a quick search though.

Niall McLaren's avatar

Interesting point about Aussie reaction to snakes vs everybody else. In classical conditioning theory, there can't be a phobia without exposure to the feared object yet I have met many people overseas who have never seen a snake who are absolutely terrified of them. Kiwis are the worst, I once had two large Maori painters working on my house. I heard a dreadful shriek from outside and saw them running to the fence. They had lifted up a box and a small brown tree snake (Boiga) popped out. It was about 50cm long and they're pretty harmless as their defence is to go straight up the nearest tree. Similarly, when my wife arrived in Australia, she had never seen a snake but was seriously phobic of them. On Saturday, she stayed inside and locked all the doors and windows, refused to see the snake when it was trapped. Her excuse was she was looking after the cat. Yeah, sure.

Gnuneo's avatar

I've met <10 snakes, the first was a touring school visit - I remember touching it, a large python, and marveling it felt dry.

About 20 years later I had work in a private Danish zoo, repainting the main cobra tank. They moved it to the reserve tank, and this thing wanted to rip my guts out so bad. It repeatedly struck the tank glass, especially when I had to pass by. Absolute molten hatred. Big one, too.

Then I met a students little snake, and I was sitting at the PC not really looking at it, while it was being carried by my classmate. It decided it wanted to see me closer, so it crawled down her arm to get closer - then I noticed, lol. Aaand... then it decided I could hold it instead, and leaped forward to a few cm from my face.

Yes, I screamed like a little girl and fell over the chair. To everyone else's obvious great enjoyment.

Then a decade later back in the UK I met a friend's little python, soooo cute, maybe 60-70cm long. He took it out of the tank, and I lie not, it started playing peekaboo with me. He had his arms out like a cross, and it would slide to a new position, and then suddenly peek out, until I said peekaboo!, and then it hid again and moved to another position, lmao. He was like "Wtf is it DOING?!?" lmao :'D

Those were my main interactions. I never saw one in Africa, or India, which I'm grateful for, not being Steve Irwin, lol.

Thing is, every non-Ozzy knows damned well that Oz wildlife is designed to kill you, and as painfully as possible. So just best not to take chances. :)

If I was in Oz, and saw a snake, I wouldn't be looking it up to see if its harmless, I'd be disappearing over the horizon, and considering calling the airline for an emergency flight if it was following me. :'D

Niall McLaren's avatar

Be careful, every now and then a snake sneaks on an international flight and causes havoc.

Look at it this way: you're not scared of snakes, you're scared of how you will feel if you go near one. That's very different. Start with pythons, they're friendly souls:

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/nhz_pLRQvWs

Gnuneo's avatar

When I KNOW it's a safe species, especially a friends pet, the scaredness turns into just controllable nervousness, that would wear off quickly. I love animals, and they generally notice me, usually for good.

When I haven't got a clue about it, you BETCHA I'm keeping my distance, lmao.

I'm not fond of spiders either, but I share my home with several rather large ones (It's the UK, remember), and I let them sit in the corners unmolested as long as they leave me alone. Live and let live. Catch me by surprise though - like waking up to a very large one on the edge of my sleeping bag while camping, and it has a gorramned SKULL on its back (Not making that up! The most poisonous spider in the UK, has an actual skull image on its back), 5cm or less from my face, and damn yes, I panic. Might feel ashamed later, but the (rational) reaction kicks in before the sober brain does.

Lol, I recall the Norgies saying that when a bunch of Danes turns up to go hiking in the mountains, they ALWAYS prepare to go rescue them, because they usually have to. Highest point of DK is about 180m above SL. They don't take oxygen, and they take foolish risks, because DK is so bloody SAFE. Norgies are aware of the dangers, and they are absolute nutters themselves, but they know the actual risks.

It comes down to what you experience in your normative years, to a large extent, I guess. I met one snake before I was ~30, and that was a placid, school-visiting python.

You make it sound like snakes just wander over the garden every week, lol.

And maybe they do! :o