Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tim Wilson's avatar

Dear Niall,

For me this post is one of the most important things you have written in recent times. It resulted in a number of pieces of my life jigsaw puzzle falling into place.

I was previously aware of your claim that anxiety was the root cause of most mental health problems. I have observed this tendency both in myself and others that I have attempted to support in recent years.

I started life with what could be described as an anxious, easily excitable personality. If anything is genetic about mental health it may be the degree of "sensitivity" a person has in much the same way as a small percentage of the population have red hair. On the other hand, according to my mother, my arrival in this world was a precarious one. Apparently her umbilical cord got wound around my neck and they thought they had lost me. Maybe that was the cause of a life time of difficulties. Who knows and does it really matter?

In my late teens I started noticing unusual experiences which developed into prominent audible voices and other unusual experiences. In my early 20's I was involuntarily hospitalised. In those days anyone hearing voices was inevitably diagnosed as schizophrenic.

According to a friend who I shared a house with at the time I went into the psychiatric hospital somewhat confused and disoriented but still a functional human being. I was released several months later a complete nut case. Coping with that hospital experience and the many that followed together with the embarrassment, shame and stigma of this ongoing affliction has been a life long challenge.

I still hear voices to varying degrees but they don't trouble me these days. I am involved with the Intervoice International Hearing Voices Movement. It is interesting that only a small percentage of people who routinely hear voices, perhaps 10% to 20%, finish up in the hands of the mental health authorities. They are invariably the ones who experience significant distress as a result of these phenomena and go seeking help or explanations from main stream mental health authorities.

In my own case unmanageable anxiety is probably the underlying cause of psychosis. At a certain point the pot simply boils over and rational thought and control are partly or completely lost for anything from a few minutes up to many hours. This phenomena is known as amygdala hijacking. The return to normality can be significantly facilitated by a safe and supportive environment. Unfortunately the opposite can also happen. The psychotic person's distress can easily trigger angry, hostile or isolating dismissive behaviour from others and this can cause an already problematic situation to escalate.

All this typically gets compounded by conflicting beliefs and values which appear to play a part in the escalating stress and anxiety. Boundary issues also often play a significant part. People with a tendency to psychosis become easy victims and this sense of vulnerability, no doubt often fuelled by imagination, reduces the triggering threshold for psychosis.

One of the things I often notice in the prodromal phase of psychosis is a feeling of confusion. In the post psychotic phase, sometimes referred to as post psychotic depression I frequently find myself trying to sort out or make sense of the relevant conflict. This is where voices can be helpful. For me they are often the forerunner of writing down some of these experiences.

I hope this information is of some interest to you or help to somebody. The information commonly available about schizophrenia and related psychotic experiences appears to me to be a minefield of ignorance and often sheer stupidity.

Regards

Tim Wilson

website https://PinkPantherActivists.au

PC's avatar

Why is it the only recursive emotion? I understand the logic as to why you state it is recursive but what about anger for example.

Animals are clearly conscious and have mental experiences, although I would say that each animal including humans has a unique informational space which means we don’t share certain experiences and neither do they (wondering what the sun is for example).

Incidentally, came across an article detailing a psychiatrist getting a Nobel Prize for optogenetics to “switch on and off neural circuits….for neurological and psychiatric disorders". Although they clearly haven’t been used for that and not sure how they ever could be.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5ev3ypmzly8o

18 more comments...

Ready for more?