8 Comments
User's avatar
John Mills's avatar

Thanks for another great write and read Niall...i love reading your writing -i love the way-s you explain things.. Thank you.

Douglas Clifford's avatar

"Americans are asking, why do they hate us? They hate what we see right here in this chamber -- a democratically elected government. Their leaders are self-appointed. They hate our freedoms -- our freedom of religion, our freedom of speech, our freedom to vote and assemble and disagree with each other … How do I respond when I see that in some Islamic countries there is vitriolic hatred for America? I'll tell you how I respond: I'm amazed. I'm amazed that there's such misunderstanding of what our country is about that people would hate us. I am -- like most Americans, I just can't believe it because I know how good we are."

Isn't that what Jung would describe as projection of Shadow?

Niall McLaren's avatar

I would see it as projection of all America's "vitriolic hatred" of Arabs/all coloured races/everybody else on to the Arabs, leaving the US lily white and pure of heart and motive. Really primitive stuff but that's how they always think. It's always "They hate us," when the truth is "We hate them because they won't do what we want." Functioning at about 3yo level.

I'm afraid Jung helped turn me to philosophy of science.

Niall McLaren's avatar

There are still people around who revere Jung and treasure every word he wrote, who become very defensive at the slightest hint of criticism of their guru. Science doesn't have gurus. I've seen this with many others, eg Thomas Szasz. Once at a conference somebody said something which I thought required an enormous leap of faith, so I said so. Well, that didn't go down well. His devoted disciples leapt as one upon the infidel and started chewing. So how come some people get a cult-like following? How come I don't see swooning fans, as Derrida did? Crowds of people pressing around like Ronald Laing? Oh well, back to the drawing board.

Mrs Jennifer Jinkd's avatar

Dear Gentleman, would Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn be helpful here.

“if only it were so simple… and who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart? The Gulag Archipelago

Jung’s tree, individual

“No tree, it is said can grow to heaven unless it’s roots reach down to hell”

What of a forest then, a society of trees? What shadow does it cast?

Michael Kowalik's avatar

If there is such a thing as a universal moral law in the fabric of existence, and i argue that there is, then we need not do anything except not violate it ourselves; this is our only responsibility and ultimate interest. Those who violate it will face appropriate consequences for their transgressions, because a law is not a law if it entails no consequences. It would nevertheless be appropriate to articulate the law, explain how it works and what consequences it entails when we violate it. And if there is no such law then Mearsheimer is right and there is nothing to be done except fight to the death.

Niall McLaren's avatar

My feeling is that we cannot assume such a law exists as "those who violate it" will drag us all down before they face the consequences. The concept opens too many metaphysical doors for my comfort; my view is that we can agree to live in peace and all will be peaceful but we cannot have peace while people are constantly jostling to exert hegemony. If everybody stands on their toes, who can see better? If everybody carries a gun, are we safer? I don't believe so. There will be more on this topic over next few weeks. cheers, JMcL