In this thread, we will examine how the concepts outlined in Narcisso-Fascism apply to the world scene today. That book is based in the theory of mind known as the biocognitive model, which was originally intended as a model of mental disorder for psychiatry but which grew as the gaps were filled. This model puts the struggle for dominance (and its converse, the struggle to avoid being dominated) at the very centre of human relations. This is a biological drive, basic to our social and psychological lives. The principle that one of the most important and least appreciated forces in human affairs has a solid basis in biology has never been applied in politics. No previous account of international relations has anything like the breadth and depth of explanatory power of the biocognitive model.
I see our present international situation as verging on desperate. It will not be solved by “more of the same,” meaning more of the same tired, descriptive approaches to world affairs. This means that the material I will post on this site will be radical and therefore, for some, shocking. Good. If you feel shocked and astounded, you need to keep reading. There will be one post a week but, if too long, they may have to come as two emails, marked 1 and 2.
______________________________________________________________________________
In case anybody doesn’t know, I now qualify as old. I can remember hearing the announcement of the death of the late Queen Elizabeth’s father on the wireless (as it was called then) so, to me, events such as the Hungarian Revolution and the Suez Crisis still seem real. In 1956-57, I was very scared that we would all be wiped out in nuclear war, fears not helped by the radio dramatization of Nevil Shute’s novel, On the Beach, which kept me awake at night. Somehow, we survived but for the past six or seven years, I’ve been telling anybody who would listen (admittedly, not many) that the world is in by far the most dangerous state I can recall. I feel international politics today are more unstable, more dangerous even than the Cuban missile crisis (which was over in less than two weeks), and getting worse by the day. As far as I can see, we are teetering on the brink of massive damage to ourselves and to the biosphere, if not total extinction of every living thing. I think this needs to be explained, and very quickly.
There are different explanations on offer, the most common of which also requires the least intellectual effort, namely, that all trouble in the world is due to Them. As far back as I can remember, Them was the Soviet and Chinese communists whose only goal in life was the destruction of Our Wonderful Way Of Life. There had been a period before, vividly portrayed in the various boys’ books from England that filled the school library, when Them had been Germans and Japanese but they were vanquished in The War and would never trouble us again. The question then arises: Why do They want to destroy us? The answer is that, being inherently evil, that’s what They do. Like the scorpion stinging the frog, that’s their nature. As George Bush told Congress after the World Trade Centre attack:
Americans are asking, why do they hate us? They hate what we see right here in this chamber -- a democratically elected government. Their leaders are self-appointed. They hate our freedoms -- our freedom of religion, our freedom of speech, our freedom to vote and assemble and disagree with each other … How do I respond when I see that in some Islamic countries there is vitriolic hatred for America? I'll tell you how I respond: I'm amazed. I'm amazed that there's such misunderstanding of what our country is about that people would hate us. I am -- like most Americans, I just can't believe it because I know how good we are.
In 2007, he told a Veterans of Foreign Wars convention that the US military was “the greatest force for human liberation the world has ever known.” That is, We (nice, modest people) cannot understand Them as They are incapable of reason so even though We virtuous people can do no wrong, we have to be ever-alert, armed and ready to fight for our very existence as all those evil people hate us and want to do us in. In fact, as genuinely virtuous people, whatever we do is right because we do it, so we shouldn’t wait until they’re attacked but should get in first and if a few cities or nations are crushed in the process, well, they died for a good cause.
Following the demise of the USSR in December 1991 and China’s adoption of the capitalist road, there were people who thought the world would settle down to an era of peace and cooperation, where the wealthier and more advanced countries would help those left behind to build their economies and liberal polities. Who knows, people wondered, we may even get a Peace Dividend from not having to spend so much on weapons. Unfortunately, that hasn’t happened. Arms manufacturers found a different set of Them to hate which meant they could keep their factories humming and keep raking in the profits. Now, the four horsemen of the apocalypse are rampaging across the world and we are unable to say why or how to stop them. With its recent election, even the US seems “locked and ready” to tear itself apart.
Why or how can we stop this headlong rush to auto-annihilation? Normally, to answer such complex questions, we would turn to the experts, namely, scholars of International Relations (IR). However, despite their long and weighty deliberations, it seems none of them actually have any answers. At best, they can describe what is going on but when it comes to explaining why, they have precious little to say. Tellingly, have practically no impact on the relatively small numbers of people who are leading the world on its bolt to destruction. Compare their lack of effect with the medical response to the Covid pandemic: in no time, the virus had been identified, novel vaccines developed and massive immunisation programs were under way. Comparatively speaking, even after hundreds of years of study, IR appears to be stuck at the level of amulets and incantations.
As an outsider, unburdened by any training or experience in IR, the absence of any remotely convincing explanations suggests that somebody, somewhere has missed something very important. However, as Thomas Kuhn showed, outsiders sometimes see answers which, effectively blinded by their “training and experience,” the experts have walked past throughout their careers. For somebody trained in human behaviour, it seems glaringly obvious that there is a problem with the idea that we can account for group behaviour without first having an adequate science of individual human behaviour, aka psychology. At the risk of being completely wrong, I would suggest that students of IR must first be students of psychology, that the final explanation of all human relations lies within the field of psychology, firstly individual psychology and then collective, or sociology. First, some explanation.
Reductionism says that the behaviour and properties of a higher order entity are fully explained by the behaviour and properties of the lower order entities of which it is composed. If we take a crowd as the higher order entity, then its behaviour will be fully explained when we know what all its human elements are doing. Since most of the individual differences will cancel each other (one person likes coffee, next person likes tea), what we are left with is the fundamental motive forces driving the crowd (e.g. everybody wants to feel part of a group working toward a common goal). Having already published an explanatory model of human behaviour, known as the biocognitive model [1], I am interested to know whether it could start to fill the gaps in IR by showing how descriptions of mass human behaviour relate to the underlying individual model.
Science starts with observations. To make sense of the world as we observe it, we imagine an unseen mechanism that links the observations in a causal sense. Any proposed explanatory mechanism is called a theory, and in order to find out whether it’s correct, we test it. If it passes all tests, we conditionally accept it as “scientifically valid.” In the case of humans, the “proposed explanatory mechanism,” aka the mind, can never be seen, which creates real problems. Modern science has therefore tried to remove all mentalist explanations from human behaviour, on the basis they can never be proven. In science, a question such as “Why did that man walk across the road?” is not answered by “Because he wanted to.” We could ask him for his reason, but he could be lying. That is, a fully mentalist theory will never be reliable in explaining human behaviour. The biocognitive model avoids this dilemma by relating the core issue in international relations to a well-researched, non-mental mechanism. This way, we don’t have to take any notice of what people say of their motivations; all we do is observe their behaviour and relate the observations to the unseen but well-documented explanatory mechanism. I will argue that this gives genuine insight into what goes on in the world, an explanation where previously we have had only description.
International relations.
In talking of theories of IR, the is-ought dichotomy applies with force. On the one hand, based in the idea of a fair go for all, we could have a model of how humans ought to conduct their international relations: equality before law, freedom from want, freedom of association and belief, guaranteed health and education for all, and so on – all the nice things that appear in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other such high-minded and widely-ignored charters. There are various names for this approach, liberal, neoliberal, structuralist, etc., but they have in common the idea that we can build a system of rules and institutions that will govern international relations and restrain the sorts of excesses that regularly lead to wars.
The current system, initiated after World War II and laboriously constructed since, is usually known as the “rules-based international order,” but judging by all the wars since 1945, it doesn’t seem to have been very effective. Common criticisms are that the system was set up by the Western powers to favour the Western powers, and that the same group of states use it selectively to their benefit and to disadvantage their opponents. Putting aside the unthreatening examples of agencies such as WHO, FAO, UNESCO, IATA, etc., most international agencies are either wielded as weapons by the Western powers (IMF, World Bank, reserve currency, etc) or treated as potential enemies to be neutralised (US Hague Invasion Bill, directed at the ICC) or destroyed (UNRWA in Palestine). At present, the “rules-based international order” appears to be little more than a smoke screen for Western atrocities.
This leaves ample room for the realist school of IR, in its various forms. Wikipedia says:
Realism … views world politics as an enduring competition among self-interested states vying for power and positioning within an anarchic global system devoid of a centralized authority. It centres on states as rational primary actors navigating a system shaped by power politics, national interest, and a pursuit of security and self-preservation … realism argues that states operate in a realm devoid of inherent justice, where ethical norms may not apply … War is seen as an inevitability inherent in the anarchic conditions of world politics.
Probably the most influential realist today is John Mearsheimer, of University of Chicago, who has developed the school known as Offensive Realism. This is a very pessimistic approach as it makes some major assumptions that idealists find … well, offensive. At base, offensive realism sees humans as self-serving and competitive, such that cooperation is not a natural state and must be imposed by rules. States are seen as discrete entities acting in rational self-interest to ensure their survival. While systems of rules can be made to work within states, there is no universally accepted set of natural laws so relations between nations are inherently anarchic. Anarchy breeds uncertainty and instability, meaning each state must look out for itself, taking any necessary steps to ensure its survival. No state knows exactly what its neighbour is thinking, so each state therefore tries to accumulate power and establish local hegemony to safeguard its interests. This leads to arms races and arms races have only one end.
Mearsheimer is still very active and is all over the internet. A brief search on YouTube yields hundreds of videos featuring him, probably more so since the fighting in Ukraine and the Middle East erupted. He features on quite a lot of what would be called left wing channels, and part of his attraction would be that he feels free to point out where his theory says states are going wrong. For example, he does not believe that the fighting in Ukraine is due wholly to Russian revanchism, or that Israel’s genocidal onslaught against the Palestinians in Gaza and Lebanon can ensure peace in the region. However, while each of these countries is trying to exert hegemony over its neighbours, their reasons are different. For onlookers who might like to see the fighting stop, the correct move, he says, is not to provide one or other side with weapons, but to deal with the reasons, to resolve their perceived fears and grievances. That makes sense but it presumes one critical point: that the humans on both sides of the various conflicts can be trusted to act rationally.
Before he can assume that point, he needs to accept that states are no more than the sum total of their inhabitants, albeit biased toward the rich and powerful, so that understanding a country’s behaviour demands an understanding of the psychological state of each of its citizens. That is, a valid account of international relations relies on a prior theory of individual psychology – which, of course, Mearsheimer doesn’t have. The only integrative theory of human psychology available today, the biocognitive model, explicitly states that, in one crucial respect, groups of humans are not rational. Therefore, in the absence of any system of enforceable rules, international relations will never rise above the level of more or less brutal, self-interested chaos [2]. Mearsheimer’s pessimistic “offensive realism” says to everybody: “It’s a jungle out there, anything goes.” This is, of course, a self-fulfilling prophecy. By providing intellectual justification for the anarchy, he licenses pre-emptive action – essentially, “They’ll do you in sooner than look at you, so don’t give them the chance. Get in first. Strike early, strike hard, take no prisoners.”
In this, he echoes probably the most influential political writer of the twentieth century, who invoked:
...the inexorable law that it is the strongest and the best who must triumph and that they have the right to endure. He who would live must fight. He who does not wish to fight in this world, where permanent struggle is the law of life, has not the right to exist [3, 182].
This Darwinian approach, in which the rules of human life devolve to the law of the jungle, was the norm for the age in which he was writing. In practically every country in the world, the elites fervently believed this. Up to the time he wrote that and after, life for Adolf Hitler had indeed been a struggle but he persevered and finally reached the top. Once there, he was able to put into practice his doctrine that all must fight to survive. Ipso facto, those who don’t win don’t deserve to survive. In essence, offensive realism mimics and covertly justifies the core doctrine of the fascist ideal of the master race. I think we can do better that such a doctrine of despair, and I believe we desperately need to do better.
References:
1. McLaren N (2023): Narcisso-Fascism: The psychopathology of right wing extremism. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
2. McLaren N (2021): Natural Dualism and Mental Disorder: The biocognitive model for psychiatry. London, Routledge.
3. Hitler, Adolf (1925). Mein Kampf. Tr. James Murphy, 1939. Facsimile edition: Henley in Arden: Coda Books.

Thanks for another great write and read Niall...i love reading your writing -i love the way-s you explain things.. Thank you.
"Americans are asking, why do they hate us? They hate what we see right here in this chamber -- a democratically elected government. Their leaders are self-appointed. They hate our freedoms -- our freedom of religion, our freedom of speech, our freedom to vote and assemble and disagree with each other … How do I respond when I see that in some Islamic countries there is vitriolic hatred for America? I'll tell you how I respond: I'm amazed. I'm amazed that there's such misunderstanding of what our country is about that people would hate us. I am -- like most Americans, I just can't believe it because I know how good we are."
Isn't that what Jung would describe as projection of Shadow?