4 Comments
User's avatar
PC's avatar

Was the paper just complete hogwash? I mean, even if "free energy" (whatever the hell that is) does not solve the problem, I wonder if it is a valid concept in terms of physics/mathematics?

A lot of these sort of statisticians drive funding, "theory" and culture for many psychology/brain departments at universities I feel (I'm doing research in one currently-I'm not brain zapping but largely pointless experimental psychology). The departments love to tout the idea of being open to new ideas but at the end of the day, the machines and funding the departments get so new papers with stylish graphs can be produced seem to always depend on the premise that this will help us unlock the secrets of the brain or something (even if not openly conveyed, the idea that brain is everything seems permanently ingrained), and usually the professor who knows the most maths is at the heart of it all.

A couple of FMRI (where voxel-based morphometry is used I think) findings have been interesting in vegetative state patients, but you're never going to see thoughts, feelings and emotions in a brain scan or statistical equation right?

Niall McLaren's avatar

Correct. The authors are touting this as an account of mind but it is manifestly only half the mind (the computational part for overt behaviour, not the experiential part or "hard problem"), and their approach starts half way up the sequence of events that needs to be explained, not at the bottom. Without a theory of information, they can't succeed. I've outlined my position in "Natural Dualism and Mental Disorder" (2021), when I get time, I'll go through his other stuff (there is an awful lot of it, he's been involved in this thermodynamics stuff for 30yrs) and show the failings. Again, won't win any friends but that's academia. Cheers.

Jenny Sanders Kowalczuk's avatar

Thanks Niall. Illuminating as always.