The team around Jon Jureidini and Melissa Raven at Adelaide University's Critical and Ethical Mental Health Research Group (CEMH, part of the Robinson Research Institute) regularly churn out high quality critiques of mainstream psychiatry. Their forte is the meticulous analysis of methodology and statistics of both epidemiological surveys and of drug trials which, of course, mainstream psychiatry regards as pillars of its scientific credibility. Two of their papers from last year deserve much wider attention, not just among psychiatrists and concerned parents but among the bureaucrats and politicians who are all too comfortable sitting back and letting the doctors set the pace. In this case, the pace is the rapidly accelerating rates of prescription of psychotropic drugs for children.
The first paper [1] examined dispensing patterns for psychotropic drugs for children and adolescents from 2013-2021, meaning before and during the pandemic. They concluded:
The dispensing of psychotropic medications to Australian children and adolescents doubled during 2013–2021, as did the prevalence of psychotropic polypharmacy. Dispensing rates for several psychotropic classes increased even more during the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly for adolescent girls ... Increased dispensing of psychotropic medications to children and adolescents is concerning, given the uncertain balance between benefits and harms of these agents for young people. The appropriateness of psychotropic prescribing should be further investigated (emphasis added).
The second paper [2] probed patterns of prescription of antipsychotic drugs for children and adolescents in general practices (primary care) from 2011 to 2017. The absolute numbers of young people prescribed these powerful and addictive drugs trebled during that time, with far more of them prescribed polypharmacy. Of most concern, however, was the changing rationale for prescription:
... most commonly associated with depression/anxiety diagnoses ... most prescribing was off‐label. The majority of patients were co‐prescribed other classes of psychotropics along with antipsychotics.
Their studies are of central importance in the battle against Imperial Psychiatry, showing how statistics are manipulated to yield the result the researchers want to see ("Torture the statistics until they tell us what we want to hear") (see the critical analysis of the notorious Study 329 [3]). That's one approach to critical psychiatry: show the faults in their scientific methodology. This work requires considerable resources and grit to slog through volumes of data finding the points at which the artful faults were carefully buried.
The other approach is to look at why they're doing it, which is my approach. Why has modern psychiatry taken the form where society accepts that a 200% increase in prescribing rates for young people within a few years is just dandy? This version of critical psychiatry examines the theory behind the methodology. It's one thing to ask why, for example, women get most ECT even though men have the highest suicide rate [4]. It's also important to ask why we are still using ECT when there are plenty of places in the world where it isn't available, and they get along just fine. The other thing about theoretical analysis, of course, is that it doesn't require much in way of resources. Long before the internet, I was able to publish some interesting work while I was stuck in the bush with no access to libraries.
For the past few weeks, I've been posting summaries of chapters in Theories in Psychiatry: Building a Post-Positivist Psychiatry, my forthcoming and, I hope, last word on the subject of theories in psychiatry. Somebody asked: "Why are you always going on about theories?" The answer is: Because theories count, they define the border between valid practice and charlatanry. For example, what was called the "theory of racial superiority" was widespread among the educated classes in Western countries for about fifty years until 1945, and is still very popular among the less-educated or more circumspect. It said that some races power ahead because successful races are innately superior while the rest are inferior. Their superiority was mainly mental, in the sense of intellect and morality, but also physical, even though Jesse Owens squelched that idea in Berlin in 1936.
This wasn't just competition between countries, it was also held to be true of the social structure: the governing class in their mansions were wealthy and powerful just because they were so clearly superior to the teeming hordes of poor people crammed in their slums. This led directly to the idea that if the poor and disabled were allowed to breed to their hearts' content, they would eventually drag the nation down just by weight of their dim-witted and gap-toothed numbers. It also applied to other races, in that if there were unrestricted racial mixing, the quality of the society would collapse, with dire results.
Out of this came the idea of eugenics, of selective or controlled breeding within the population to improve the stock. All the major countries had their eugenics societies, largely composed of intelligent, educated and well-placed people. They were able to influence governments behind the scenes, not that most governments needed much pressure to believe the governing class governed by dint of their innate superiority, and the rest should fall into line and keep quiet. Nobody today should think these ideas were extreme or outlandish at the time, they were normal. The eugenics movement was strong in the US, and many states enacted racial laws, making it illegal to marry across races. They also authorised sterilisation of physically or mentally disabled people, and the "irresponsible," largely meaning African-Americans. In fact, the Nuremberg Race Laws, passed by the Nazi Reichstag in September, 1935, were explicitly modelled on the Kentucky race laws already in force. Initially directed against Jewish people in Germany, within a few months, the laws were extended to include Romani (gypsies) and black people.
The British Eugenics Society (which still exists) exerted quiet pressure on governments as well as conducting public education programs, even though the English public, especially the upper classes, were never in doubt that they were inherently superior sorts. This idea drove colonialism, the idea of "Well, this country is occupied by coolies and savages, so we may as well move in and make something of it." Sure, the colonialists could always find evidence to support their claims of superiority but, when examined more closely, it was evidence of something else:
Haughty white imperialist: You people are obviously inferior, you can't even saddle a horse or serve tiffin properly, let along build and run a railroad.
Locals: Sure thing boss, but that's a matter of education, not brains. And we don't actually need railways, we use the river.
HWM: And how else, pray tell, are you going to export all the timber and minerals and livestock?
Locals: Now you mention it, boss, we're happy for our trees to stay upright and our cows to keep eating the grass, and we don't need minerals to build mud huts.
HWM: There you are, anybody happy to live in a mud hut is clearly inferior. Hand me my whip, I'll liven your ideas.
The idea of mental inferiority was a major part of the eugenics movement. For eugenecists, mental included the three categories of intellectual handicap, of acquired mental disorders such as schizophrenia, and of "moral inferiority," mainly meaning crime, gambling, addiction and promiscuity. Of the first five chapters of a book published by the English Eugenics Society in 1933 [5], four covered the inheritance of neurological disorders, intellectual handicap, epilepsy and mental disorders. Chapter IV, on mental disorder, was contributed by a Dr Aubrey Lewis, of the Maudsley Hospital, in London. Lewis was born in Adelaide and studied medicine, then went to the US and later to England, where he remained. He became director of the newly-established Institute of Psychiatry, which also still exists, and exerted a huge influence over British, and thence Empire, psychiatry, including Australia. When I trained in Perth many years ago, all the self-appointed KOLs * in the small world of psychiatry had been to the Maudsley and formed a small, tight clique who saw themselves as a cut above the rest of us.
Naturally enough, Lewis was in close contact with the German eugenecists, who, following the Nazi accession to power, suddenly found themselves flooded with money and resources to study "racial hygeine." Germany quickly became the leading light in human genetics, and a major part of that was the study of the inheritance of mental disorder, orchestrated by a Prof. Ernst Rüdin. Anybody who wanted to study the genetics of mental disorder, which meant everybody but the irresponsible Freudians, went to Rüdin's centre for the experience. They included a Dr Eliot Slater, who later became long-time editor of the British Journal of Psychiatry, and a Dr Franz Kallman, who went to the US and took over their psychiatric genetics program, proving to everybody's satisfaction that schizophrenia is a genetic disorder (he advocated forced sterilisation of the patients and their relatives but that bit was played down).
Ernst Rüdin started and oversaw the Nazi program to sterilise and later to exterminate "mental inferiors," eventually involving hundreds of thousands of people. His plan was so successful that it was later extended to gassing "racial inferiors," meaning Jews, Romani and anybody else they didn't like. His daughter became a psychiatric geneticist and, in a rather tasteless move in the 1990s, joined forces with another well-known psychiatric geneticist, Prof. Kenneth Kendler, of Virginia Commonwealth University and editor of Psychological Medicine, to rehabilitate her father's name. Thankfully, it didn't go far. It's sometimes noted that, because the "genetic stock" of mental disorder in Germany was essentially wiped out during the 1930s and 40s, it should have had a very obvious effect in reducing the incidence of mental disorder in the 1950s and 60s. In fact, it had no effect.
What this says is "Theories count." Your theory explains the unseen mechanisms that connect different observations, allowing you to distinguish between valid observations and irrelevant matters. Take a simple example: in Indonesia, if a crow lands on the roof of your house, you need to rush around and make sure everything is OK, everybody is healthy, kids are all accounted for, because it means somebody is going to die. That's what their theory of the nature of the universe says. Meantime, a lot of people in the kampungs still don't see a connection between mosquitoes and malaria.
Similarly, readers will recall that a total eclipse was forecast for April 10th for the eastern states of the US. On April 5th, New Jersey was shaken by a minor earthquake. Hours later, a member of the US Congress, one Marjorie Taylor Greene, tweeted to her swarms of devoted followers that the conjunction of an earthquake and an eclipse means that God is displeased with America and wants His children to repent: "Earthquakes and eclipses and many more things to come. I pray that our country listens." For normally sensible people, earthquakes and eclipses are unconnected events but to the excitable Ms Greene, they are connected by an unseen (divine) mechanism revealed to her alone. She seems to have her own take on unseen mechanisms. For example, she is convinced that the Parkland school massacre of February 2018 was staged and no students were hurt, the whole thing being engineered by a secret conspiracy. There is a notorious video of her pursuing one of the survivors, taunting and baiting him as he walked to a Congressional hearing on gun violence. However, since the parents of the Sandy Hook school disaster successfully sued Mr Alex Jones and his misnamed Infowars channel for $1.5billion for "massacre denial," she has gone quiet on that one. Does she ever offer proof of her bizarre unseen mechanisms? No, you just have to believe what she says because Marjorie Taylor Greene.
What this says is: as a proposal of an unseen mechanism to make sense of what would otherwise be unrelated observations, theories don't just make us feel better, they tell us what's sensible and what's not. They tell us what to notice and what to ignore, otherwise we'd be flooded and unable to make sense of anything, and then they tell us what to do, e.g. exterminate whole races. That's the power of theories.
In mainstream psychiatry, a sustained mood of sadness and despair, loss of appetite, patchy sleep, loss of energy and constipation is "explained" by the theory of an unseen "chemical imbalance of the brain" or (this month's version) a disturbance of "neurocircuitary of the brain." In turn, this mandates drugs and/or ECT and/or being locked up, as nothing else could possibly work. Given this theoretical basis, it's pointless to ask: "What's been the trouble? What's brought this about? Let's talk and see if we can sort it out." This matters, as it is either the case that the human mind is just a manifestation of the underlying brain chemistry, and can be treated as simply a signpost on the way down to the subatomic particles or it is true that the mind can malfunction in the presence of a healthy brain and no amount of brain manipulation will relieve the problem (I say human mind because the biocognitive model says animals also have minds). If the latter is true, then mental problems have mental causes, and only an approach based in the mentality of mind can resolve them. Physical treatments can mask them, but only talking can solve them.
Practically all the theorists reviewed in Theories in Psychiatry oppose the idea of mental causes for mental events. They firmly believe that ordinary physical science will explain all we need to know about the mind with no significant questions left unanswered. Necessarily, and even though they don't often mention it, this includes mental disorder. However, even though they believe it, what none of them has done is prove their case. All we get is bland conviction (Gilbert Ryle, John Searle), fervent conviction (Richard Carrier), abusive conviction (Daniel Dennett), incoherent conviction (Noam Chomsky) or dismissive conviction (all the rest).
The difference between believing an opinion and proving it true is profound. If you believe mental disorder is caused by some physical disorder of the brain, not only must you produce convincing evidence of it, but you also have to prove it can't be due to mental causes. Crucially, this has never been done. No psychiatrist, or psychologist, or neuroscientist, or philosopher, has ever offered a remotely plausible proof that (a) mental disorder is always due to a physical condition of the brain and (b) it cannot be due to a non-physical, i.e. mental, cause. All we are offered is opinion masquerading as science.
When the problem is put like that, it's clear that biological psychiatry is a fool's errand, its hugely expensive research program a case of good money after bad. Biological psychiatry has to answer the question: "How will you know when your program is a failure, that the reason you can't find a biological cause of mental disorder is because there isn't one?" If they can't answer that, they should shut up shop right now, just because their program is irrefutable. It is an opinion dressed up as "hard biological fact," designed to conceal the intellectual vacuum at the centre of mainstream psychiatry. It is an opinion that led to the disaster of psychosurgery, which mutilated or killed hundreds of thousands of people, of untold millions of people being confined in squalid "loony bins," deprived of all their human rights without ever having broken a law, and of many tens of millions of children being prescribed highly addictive drugs for "mental illness" when, sixty years ago, practically no children were taking them. And it is all done on opinion.
In practice, the inestimable advantage of the biological notion of mental disorder is that it produces its own evidence, so it's never wrong. If somebody taking antidepressants, especially paroxetine, develops an altered mental state with intense agitation and erratic, dangerous behaviour, that is not regarded as a predictable side-effect of the drug, even though it happens in about 15% of cases. It is held to be a case of the drug "uncovering an innate tendency" to bipolar disorder [DMS5, pp 124, 133]. For the drug companies, this is an unbeatable business model. It's definitely in their interest to keep funnelling money to the self-appointed KOLs * who scoff at the idea that mental disorder could possibly be due to something so unscientific as "beliefs and experiences." "We've got the science," they chortle as they head off to yet another all-expenses paid conference in some exotic resort.
No. They haven't got the science. They haven't got the practical science, as in valid epidemiological and statistical studies, and they haven't got the theoretical science. But until critical psychiatry gets sufficient leverage, all the KOLs have to do is dream up some hare-brained scheme involving the latest expensive technology, and the money will keep flowing.
* KOL = Key Opinion Leader.
****
References:
1. Wood SJ et al (2023). Dispensing of psychotropic medications to Australian children and adolescents before and during the COVID-19 pandemic, 2013–2021: a retrospective cohort study. Medical Journal of Australia v209. doi doi: 10.5694/mja2.51948
2. Klau J et al (2023). Antipsychotic prescribing patterns in children and adolescents attending Australian general practice in 2011 and 2017. JCPP Advances. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcv2.12208
3. Le Noury J et al (2015) Restoring Study 329: efficacy and harms of paroxetine and imipramine in treatment of major depression in adolescence. BMJ 2015; At: https://www.bmj.com/content/351/bmj.h4320
4. McLaren N (2017). Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Critical Perspective. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 19: 91-104. DOI: 10.1891/1559-4343.19.2.91
5. Blacker CP (Ed). 1933. The Chances of Morbid Inheritance. London: HK Lewis Co.
****
All the material on these posts is copyright but can be quoted or reprinted as long as the author is acknowledged.

👏👏👏🕊️👍💌Forwarded to my humble telegram.. THANK YOU Dr McLaren
I may be too pessimistic here but I have my doubts that any theory can put an end to this Juggernaut. I’m sure some drugs will have to be tossed into the waist bin but I’ve seen too much dumpster diving going on. According to “The Bitterest Pills” by Moncrieff, much of psychiatry had a drug centered model approach. However, somehow the pharmaceutical industry with its massive wallet bought out key institutions and now dominates the narrative with the disease centered model (and probably any model in the future that keeps raking in the dough if for some reason the disease centered model runs out of too much steam.) A big question that probably needs to be asked is, How did Big Pharma get so big? The easiest and most obvious answer that I can think of is that they, at least at some time made a ton of money off their product. Which opens up some questions like, Why do people seem to want mind altering drugs? Why are people so obsessed with these substances? Something tells me that there are a number of things going on here. They may be biological or perhaps hereditary. There is probably a psychological and cultural aspect to it. Breggin uses the term “Spell Binding” to describe some of the effects of these drugs. Could this be a reference to something spiritual? I know academia generally doesn’t want to talk about anything woo woo, but until the consciousness problem is resolved the woo woo stuff will appear to have its foot in the door. Religion and spirituality are a huge part of human culture and civilization and have been for a very long time. Mind altering substances have been also. I believe in some parts of the world, the two are very intertwined in very ancient rituals. I’m not sure if the war on drugs is a winnable battle but it may be a battle worth fighting anyway.