As political scientist Wallace Sayre (1905-1972) didn’t quite say: “Academic disputes are the more bitter because so little hangs on them.” Psychiatry is different in that, while disputes can have momentous consequences for every living human, public slugging matches are quite rare. In fact, there is so little debate that the general public could be forgiven for thinking there are no disagreements, that all questions in psychiatry are settled. All we see in the media is a steady flow of wondrous announcements of “breakthroughs” in research and treatment, of amazing new mental diseases that we’re all about to catch except psychiatrists are ready and waiting with the perfect treatment, and so on.
For example, lay people reading a commentary in The Conversation by Canadian psychologist Natalina Salmaso, Debunking 5 myths about antidepressants July 24 2024, or any of the many similar published pieces (here and here), could conclude that squabbles over the nature and management of depression were long ago resolved and it’s now just a matter of getting people to take their drugs. In fact, that impression is highly misleading and gives no clues regarding the intensity of the debate within mental health.
Salmaso offered five of what she saw as the most common “myths” that stop people taking antidepressants, along with her correctives to those myths.
“Myth 1: I am stronger if I do this without meds.”
Salmaso replied: “Overcoming depression is like overcoming a broken leg … (your brain) needs to ‘heal’…”
This analogy is completely wrong as it implies the mind-brain problem has been resolved, and that mental disorder is necessarily the result of a brain disorder. There no proof of this claim, and every reason to believe it’s wrong. Misery does not imply brain pathology. Everything says that the reaction to losses is a normal part of mental life and should primarily be treated as such.
“Myth 2: I will be dependent on antidepressants to be happy.”
Salmaso replied: “Antidepressants … allow people to experience all emotions in an appropriate and balanced way.”
Wrong again: antidepressants induce a state of emotional numbing that many people describe as having their heads “full of cottonwool.” Granted, a proportion of depressed or anxious people do benefit from having their anxiety quelled or depression blunted, but plenty don’t and are among the 40% of people who stop the drugs within the first month or two, before or in spite of any therapeutic effect.
Salmaso: antidepressants are a “… curative treatment, much like chemotherapy for certain types of cancer.”
This is bizarre: the cytotoxic drugs used in chemotherapy are actually poisons. They kill cells to achieve their end. I am not aware any qualified person has ever suggested some sort of parallel between cytotoxics and psychotropic drugs. Does she means “specific cures”? If so, she is wrong. Antidepressants are non-specific psychoactive drugs of middling strength. They are prescribed for a wide range of conditions, physical and mental. Similarly, there is no evidence that they "rectify a chemical imbalance,” whatever that may be.
Salmaso: “ … the effects (of antidepressants) will often remain long after you stop taking them.”
That says only that the bout of depression has remitted, which it normally does without drugs anyway, and they’re no longer necessary. That has nothing to do with the drug. Unless the author was talking about persistent side effects, this claim makes no sense. It simply adds to the general sense she is trying to convey that they are remarkable drugs with no downside.
Salmaso: “…a small proportion of people have a more chronic form of depression…” and need the drugs longer.
Before antidepressants were released, the great majority of people recovered from depressive bouts with no complications. Today, the average patient has been taking these drugs for four years although it’s quite common to see people who, despite the side effects, have been taking them 25-30 years and are unable to stop (see Myth 4). That has nothing to do with whether they need them to treat a “chronic form of depression.”
“Myth 3: Meds will change who I am, I will be different or feel high.”
Salmaso: “antidepressants … do not make people feel ‘high’…”
This is partly correct as they actually flatten emotional responses, which some people like and some don’t. However, up to 10% of people prescribed antidepressants will experience a state of intense agitation and/or mania as a potentially dangerous side effect. This is exceedingly unpleasant and most definitely not anything that would be called a “high.” More to the point, genuinely depressed people, and not people feeling just “a bit glum,” will want to feel different, that’s what they’re complaining about. Obviously, if people worry about “feeling different,” they’re not so worried about their mental state as to want drugs to change it, and almost certainly shouldn’t be prescribed them.
“Myth 4: I will become addicted.”
Salmaso: “Antidepressants … are generally not addictive and have a low potential for misuse.”
This depends on the definition of addiction. In most patients, these drugs produce an intense physical dependence so that rapid or abrupt cessation causes moderate to severe withdrawal symptoms (which drug companies call ‘discontinuation syndrome’). As a result, many people must take them long term as every attempt to stop results in a wide range of disabling symptoms. Medical people mostly misconstrue withdrawal as “the mental illness coming back” and tell the patient to resume the drug, rather than reducing it much more slowly. Antidepressant withdrawal symptoms have nothing to do with mental disorder as they occur in people who were prescribed antidepressants for reasons other than depression, such as pain management, sleep disturbances, disabling dermatitis, irritable bowel, etc.
Salmaso: “withdrawal symptoms … are generally short-lived and can be minimised by tapering off treatment slowly.”
Nothing could be further from the truth. Antidepressants very commonly induce severe physical dependency which results in a wide range of quite profound and/or disabling, long-lasting and sometimes dangerous withdrawal effects. Britain’s Royal College of Psychiatrists was recently forced to withdraw their opinion that withdrawal is brief and minor, and replace it with the factual statement that withdrawal symptoms can be severe and may last for many months or even years. It is certainly true that tapering can result in relatively asymptomatic withdrawal but this means many months, not a week or two. Withdrawal from venlafaxine in particular can take years.
“Myth 5: Meds should only be used as a last resort.”
Salmaso: “Reserving antidepressants only for extreme cases doesn’t make sense …”
There is no convincing evidence that these drugs benefit mild to moderate cases (if there is such a thing as “mild depression”). Antidepressants can cause huge (50%+) weight gain as well as profoundly depressing sexuality which may become permanent (now called Post-SSRI Sexual Dysfunction, PSSD). When patients are given a full list of the side effects of antidepressants, many don’t want them. To make it worse, as the rate of prescription of antidepressants goes up, so too does the rate of suicide. Even though the US is awash with psychiatric drugs, their suicide rate in 2022 was 14.3 per 100,000, the highest rate since 1941.
Salmaso: “To date, major long-term consequences of taking antidepressants as prescribed have rarely been observed in the short-term …”
Of course they haven’t, that’s what short-term means, dumbo, but it’s absolutely false anyway. Persisting sexual dysfunction, obesity, akathisia, tardive dyskinesia etc. are common but are seriously underestimated because psychiatrists don’t want to know that their favourite drugs are nasty and dangerous.
Salmaso: “Depression significantly increases risk of cardiovascular disease, gastrointestinal disease, respiratory disease and Parkinson’s disease, to name a few. It also seems to worsen the outcomes for cancer.”
It’s actually the other way around: being physically ill causes depression, which is hardly rocket science.
Salmaso: “Newer medications are now largely designed based on scientific theory.”
This is just drug company propaganda. The great majority of psychotropic drugs are found by chance or by tinkering with existing drugs. The latest “hot new drugs for depression” are ketamine, a 60 year old anaesthetic agent, and psychedelics such as MDMA and psilocybin, first championed by the “neuronaut” Timothy Leary in the 1950s. As for theories, mainstream psychiatry doesn’t do theories. Hunches yes, articulated theories no way. Recent attempts to find a “cause for depression” in inflammatory or other immune responses and so on are simply trailing along behind the technology with no prior theoretical basis: these well-funded programs are technology-driven, not theory-driven. As a result, drug companies are turning away from psychiatric drugs. We may be starting to see the end of the era of aggressive pharmacologic expansion in psychiatry, as has happened with psychosurgery, psychoanalysis, insulin and other somatic treatments. We wish.
It isn’t clear why a psychologist is pushing the idea of “more drugs for more people,” as her article pointedly fails to mention how toxic antidepressants are, especially the older tricyclic drugs which are still commonly prescribed. It says nothing about the high to very high incidence of major side effects such as akathisia, drowsiness and confusion, mania, obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure, sexual dysfunction, suicidal ideas and impulses, especially among young people, and homicidal ideas and impulses. The way she puts it, antidepressants are wonder drugs and only a fool would refuse to take them. While it sounds great, there’s no truth in it.
What’s The Conversation? It’s an online opinion column for “university experts to share their knowledge.” They publish material only from people with university posts, i.e. the elite. They have an “editorial charter” that says their scribblings are “ … responsible, ethical and supported by evidence … a fact-based and editorially independent forum, free of commercial or political bias … open, transparent and accountable. Where errors occur (we) correct them expeditiously.”
The editors were contacted to tell them of the serious faults in this article but they said they don’t publish rebuttals. I then lodged a complaint to say this article is nothing but drug company propaganda as it is factually wrong and seriously misleads the readers. A few hours later, they replied:
Thanks very much for sharing these concerns. This article was published by The Conversation Canada, which is a different edition with a separate editorial staff from The Conversation Australia + NZ.
Now there’s a rule in journalism which says that if you’re going to tell lies, try to make up a lie that will fool people. Don’t insult the intelligence of your readers. However, this self-righteous bunch of elitest turds take it further: they assume their readers can’t actually read. The first two words on their page are “Edition: Australia,” just as on the Canadian version, it says “Edition: Canada.” Yes, they’re separate, and the Australian crew are fully responsible for their own site.
What happened is that they saw the article on the Canadian site, circulated and read it, talked about it and decided to publish it on their site. Now they’re saying they didn’t publish it, it was those treacherous Canucks. However, when we contacted them to correct it, they said they don’t have any space (“Thanks for the pitch. It’s an interesting idea but unfortunately I have to decline. With current resources we’re only able to publish a small minority of the pitches we receive and while this idea has merit I’ve reluctantly decided to prioritise other content”). What crap. The reason they haven’t got any space is because these past few weeks, they’ve been publishing a swag of stuff on one of “society’s biggest problems.” It’s called the Olympic Games.
The Conversation is not a member of the Australian Press Council so you can’t complain to them. They say they are an ethical publisher with a “global editorial policy” but they don’t take any notice of it. When this is pointed out, they pretend they had nothing to do with it. When asked to retract the false material, they don’t respond.
It may be possible for editors to debase themselves further but just for the moment, I can’t imagine how. If this is all we can expect from an allegedly ethical, university-affiliated publication, then critical psychiatry is doomed. The drug companies have won.
*****
The whole of this material is copyright but can be quoted or retransmitted on condition the author is acknowledged.

Thank you again! 👍🏻💙💚💖🌹♥️🙂🤗👏🏻👏🏻 Concise, scientific, to the point with integrity professionalism from a soul that shows high integrity, a warrior soul for humanity, and love Thank you Dr McLaren may G_d protect you and give you long and healthyife that you can continue making a difference in this dimension please take care Orli 🙋🏻🙋🏼
https://t.me/OrliBerm/7346