Recently, a person I saw some years ago requested copies of my reports as he felt I had made the wrong diagnosis. He was quite excited by his new diagnosis, which he had made himself after watching some YouTube videos, and was hoping my reports would help him access social security benefits. After having a look at them, I didn't think they would but sent them anyway. His email included the link to a YouTube channel he had used to learn "the truth" about himself. It is hosted by a self-diagnosed autistic engineer who uploads a video every week on "the spectrum in adults." The earliest I could find came from 2016, and he seems to have made hundreds, some with well over 2 million views.
I've heard that cat videos are the most common on YouTube but a quick search suggests autism isn't far behind (I don't recommend it, that's all you'll get for the next week). Having watched four, I feel I'm now up to speed on this remarkable diagnosis that didn't exist when I trained, and which I never once made in my unworthy life. They reveal something important, so I'll go through them in some detail. As it's important to let the speaker present his own case, I'll mostly use direct quotes. Also, as the presenter seems to have trouble with pronouns and plurals, I'll lightly edit what he said.
First is How do you know you're autistic? 9 Common Ways to discover your autism as an adult. First point he makes is the "unconscious myth" that diagnosis by a professional is the normal way for people to "discover" they're autistic. Instead, the most common is to have one of your children diagnosed (presumably by a professional). People say "Oh, but I was just like that," which, he implies, confirms that it's genetic and they've had it all along. Next, same thing happens when a friend or relative is diagnosed: "People say 'If you're autistic, then so am I.'" No. 3: "YouTube had identified me as autistic or keeps recommending a lot of autistic videos" (quite how YouTube's mindless algorithm achieves this isn't clear, but obviously its owners have their viewers' best interests at heart).
The fourth is reading the memoir of a person who says s/he is autistic, which seems to be the way the presenter arrived at his own diagnosis: "Reading an autistic memoir. I got halfway through the book and I resonated so much with the book ... I did an online self-assessment quiz ... the official internet diagnosis was 'Maybe, probably,' so I called a local support group, told them I diagnosed myself yesterday." The rest, it seems, is history. No. 5 path to autism is the result of "a long time search. Maybe you've always had this niggling question in the back of your mind, you get a diagnosis that doesn't quite fit. You've been looking for a long time, then you find out what autism is and you realise it fits." Again, the speaker gives his own experience: "I'm an engineer and had previously diagnosed myself as an engineer and was happy with that diagnosis." Engineers, it seems, are odd, quirky wierdos who don't fit in, but autism is so much more comfortable.
Next on the slope is being given a diagnosis of ADHD, either correctly, because autism and ADHD overlap so much, or incorrectly, it was autism all along. Now we have "major burnout," a person suffers some sort of nervy turn and realises it's all due to autism. Closely associated are "big life changes, including the pandemic, divorce, redundancy, having the first child, starting full-time work. This brings the person to say 'There must be something wrong with me, it's my fault, I don't know what I did wrong.'" For the presenter, starting full-time work caused his wheels to fall off and led to his epiphany. Finally, we come to it: "I saved the most boring for the last, you're diagnosed by your psychologist ... this can be the start of a genuine self-discovery process ... self-diagnosis is equally valid."
This is important. Most of his videos seem to be directed at encouraging people to diagnose themselves regardless of what anybody, especially a professional, may say, and there is a full video on how to do it. Are you Autistic? 25 Questions to Ask Yourself helps the nervous or hesitant over the threshold. These are given in seven categories of experience, of which the first is "feeling different." "Have you always felt different from your peers? Do you feel you're an outsider, that you don't really belong, even in a group? Do you worry about not being believed when you tell others about yourself?" Next category relates to "routine: Do you adopt different mannerisms when you're home alone, things you wouldn't do in public? Perhaps some form of stimming?" (for beginners, 'stimming' means 'self-stimulation,' usually repetitive movements, sounds, lights, etc. The classic form, from last century, was seen in autistic children who would look at the sun through their opened fingers, and move their hands so they got flashes of light in their eyes. Otherwise it could be drumming fingers, touching, tapping, singing, all sorts of things).
Moving on, he asked: "Do you have gaps in your skill set, there are some simple things that other people can do but you can't? ... Do you like to be prepared and dislike last minute changes? Are your routines sometimes seen as extreme or odd?" Here, he gives his own experience: "I eat the same thing at every mealtime, some people see it as extreme but it's fine by me" (that wasn't clear, does he eat cereal three times a day? Although he liked talking about himself, he didn't give examples). Next three questions were related: "Do you like to focus on one thing at a time because it takes a lot of effort to 'change gears' to switch between tasks and do something else? Do you go through cycles of hyperproductivity and then burnout, working really hard then crashing, or coping fine for a while then falling to bits later? Do you struggle to hold down jobs, friends, relationships, maybe due to misunderstandings or for no apparent reason at all?"
The group of questions relating to communication is important because the classic description of autistic children is that they failed to develop language. Judging on the presenter's high verbal facility, this has completely changed over the years: "Do you have trouble expressing what you really mean, especially under stress? Are there some common types of communication that you find extremely difficult or uncomfortable?" He mentions phone calls, emails, SMS, maybe having a strong liking for one and actively disliking or avoiding the others. "Are you sometimes very gullible, struggling to tell whether people are being serious or not? Do you often wish people would 'say what they mean' and get angry when they don't, because you get confused and don't know what's going on?"
Unusual sensitivities was also a feature of classic autism: "Are you particularly sensitive or insensitive to some things, such as lights, noise, taste or smells? Does this lead to significant discomfort in some types of public places or social activities? Do you feel that dealing with the outside world can be difficult and stressful? Do you often have significant anxiety about having to go out and face it?"
He sees problems with attention as important: "Do you often notice things that others don't? Are there sometimes things that are obvious to others that aren't obvious to you, so you think 'Where does everybody get this information from?'"
Classic autism was about the failure of socialisation in the developing child. These children simply don't relate to other people in the normal way. The emphasis here is different, not looking at observable behaviour but all attention is on the inner experience: "Do you have uncommon interests or passions that others just don't get, you wish you could share with others. They're interested in other things (which don't interest you), which makes small talk and talking with other people really challenging at times. Do you find dealing with other people is difficult or confusing? Do you feel it's your job to fit in if you want to make friends? When socialising, are you constantly worried about doing the right thing socially? Either censoring yourself or masking because you're not sure if the real you is appropriate, that showing your real self would be seen as odd or risk rejection? (Masking refers to the actions or coping strategies that individuals use to conceal their genuine thoughts, emotions, or challenges).
Finally, we come to the emotional group: "Do you often feel overwhelmed by other people's emotions, or not feel them at all? Are you often surprised when people tell you what they're thinking and feeling because you had no idea? Have you been diagnosed with depression or anxiety or other labels that either keep changing or don't quite fit?"
He concludes this video by pointing out that while these are very common autistic experiences, they're just a sample: "I could have picked a hundred different questions but meeting other people on the spectrum is the best way of learning about autism, by relating to the inner experience of another person on the spectrum.
(If you feel this is getting boring, you're not the only one, but do persist).
A video titled Seven signs of undiagnosed autism in adults features the speaker seated in front of a framed certificate that says "Certificate IV in Life Coaching," whatever that is. First sign is difficulty fitting in socially, generally feeling awkward and out of place, missing social cues and coming across as "eccentric" from trying to be like everyone else. Next is the need for structure and routine. This wasn't entirely clear as we learn that a very rigid and inflexible person and a chaotic person are "often two sides of the same coin." Speaking of himself, he said: "One of the reasons I need routine and stability and security is because I am so flexible." This became quite bizarre, in that he can't follow routine so he decides in advance what to say and do with the end result that he looks out of place. It can come across as resisting the status quo or determined to be different for no good reason, "... all of which points to internal executive function challenges. What you are seeing are my coping mechanisms that allow me to work and get stuff done but if you interrupt or throw in too many unknowns, then I won't be able to concentrate, I won't be able to prioritise or organise my almost infintely chaotic brain so I'll flip from super-organised to super-disorganised." That explains why both high levels of obsessionality and low levels are caused by autism.
Having cleared up that point, the third group of signs relates to sensory sensitivities and, equally importantly, sensory insensitivities. Once again, both high and low sensitivity are "pretty strong signs of undiagnosed autism." Here, he pointed out that there is considerable overlap with ADHD, e.g. clumsiness is caused by not being able to tell where your limbs are in space. Fourth group is "spiky skill sets," an expression he often uses. It means being good at some things and no good at others: "Some things I'm extremely good at and some things I really, really struggle with." He gave examples of being very good at table tennis but not at ordinary tennis, and mentioned en passant that he can't cope with online menus in restaurants, whatever that means.
Group five is "emotional regulation," meaning "meltdowns, shutdowns and withdrawals. What happens when the world gets too much and I have to shutdown? ...Don't talk to me at all for the next 2 hours, I need to decompress" (he forgot to mention 'burnout,' which often follows a burst of "hyperproductivity"). Group six relates to "unusual associations and mental jumps," i.e. "picking on esoteric meanings or side meanings or a quote... for example, if somebody asked you to pick a random vegetable and you picked rhubarb" (my immediate response to that question was chokos). He often describes these as brain functions: "It makes communication much more difficult if a link occurs in my brain but not in yours, ... that can make communication a bit more challenging."
The last group is being "Just a bit different. The person stands out as the odd one out for some reason and our brains are very good at picking the odd one out.... you can spot autism in under a second. Our brains do this ... if you find yourself the odd one out in lot of settings, that could be a sign you're autistic" (my emphasis).
Finally, we come to How to spot Autism in High Masking Autistic women - what's behind the mask? which has had 2.1million views. Masking, he says, means "concealing the physical signs of autism." Thoughout this video, the presenter clearly implies he has a very good knowledge of the inner experience of "neurotypicals." Oddly enough, he hardly mentions women, possibly because he spends most of the video talking about himself. It also isn't clear why it is necessary to intrude on people's privacy but there you are. At 2.40, he says: "If you want to see autistic traits in a person, look beyond the mask ... Under pressure and enormous life stress, you're more likely to see a different side of a person." 4.05: "I can't string two words together to save my life" (there was no sign of dysfluency in an hour of videos). 4.40: "I struggle to read, so I avoided subjects with a lot of reading, I did science, maths and engineering (since written material) is quite inaccessible due to a hidden gap in my skillset" (he managed chemistry and physics and maths and materials science without reading? Truly amazing. I wish).
5.15: Typical gaps which indicate autism include poor social skills, or lack of knowledge or understanding, or inconsistent executive functions due to a "spiky skill set," sensory sensitivities and information processing needs. As examples of gaps (5.25), he describes "a person who has very high energy and is extremely social sometimes, and other times, needs alone time and goes home and crashes" (at 5.40, we see a picture of a glamorous young woman stretched out luxuriantly, with no signs of distress, perhaps to illustrate an ideal crash).
8.22: Inconsistent executive function is an obvious sign of autism, he says, illustrated by talking about how, if he is given a task, he has to do it his way or not at all as he becomes so agitated he can't think straight. At 11.30, he says that if people say they are autistic, everybody has to accept this as disputing ("invalidating") it is a terrible thing but high-masking people don't look autistic: "I cannot overemphasise how important it is to validate that experience, even if it doesn't quite make sense to you." The video ends with "four tips on the way forward: So if this is you and you're going through your own unmasking journey, you can: 1. Share your experiences or read other people's experiences in the video comments below. 2. See my other unmasking videos, 3. contact my online social group, and 4. speak to a mental health professional, including my sponsors, BetterHealth Online Counselling." Apart from the reposing lady at 5.40, there was no mention of women, masked or unmasked.
OPINION: First point: autism used to be a formal, scientific diagnosis. Fifty years ago, nobody had heard the word, now it's everywhere. But what happened in that time is that it has lost its scientific credibility. What used to be an attempt at an objective assessment of a handicapped child is now WOTY (Word of the Year) and all objectivity has been scrubbed. It is now entirely subjective, and the individual's subjective decision is absolute. According to this and many other sources, autism is something you decide for yourself, then you rush about finding support to get social security and other benefits (like doing your exams at home, in your own time, etc.).
Next point: the speaker shows not an iota of distress or disturbance. He sits squarely in a chair facing the camera and talks steadily in a calmly confident tone. That's OK, we don't expect a neurologist giving a talk to slur her speech and dribble from the side of her mouth, but this bloke says he is "talking from lived experience," which he regards as infallible. Next, he presents this material as amazing discoveries, but most of it's old hat. Dr Freud beat him to "masking," although old Siggy invented a much better expression, ego mechanisms of defence. Similarly, he uses novel terms like "meltdown" and "burnout," rather than the old terms, "anxiety attack" and "miseries/pissed off." The implication is that boring people panic but we autistic types have our own, unique brand of nervy turns, so we have to be treated as special. Crucially, nobody is allowed to disagree with us, because that's immoral. In fact, the whole point of modern science is to take the morality out of it, to stop judging and look at facts, whereas these people want to recast science in moral terms. We see it when he says he has to do things his way or not at all because he has a meltdown (commonly known as a tantrum).
As for objectivity, the essential point is always to have a cut-off point where something stops being normal and becomes abnormal, just because every one of the hundreds of signs or symptoms he mentioned is invariably seen in normal people. You don't like people upsetting your routine? Who does? You have good days and bad days? Don't we all? Sometimes you feel like mixing, and others the world gives you the shits. Snap! That's me, except I had to earn a living so I learned very early to put up with idiots.
So there's no cut-off from normality, but there's also no cut-off from abnormality. "Under pressure and enormous life stress, you're more likely to see a different side of a person." Well, that's called a stress reaction, it was known to Shakespeare ("A horse, a horse, my kingdom for a horse"). He implies that only autistics suffer "burnout," which is undefined, but surely we all get worn down at times? Unable to mix socially? Generally known as social phobia, and so on. But the most important point here is: he does not, and cannot, offer any sort of distinction between his "disorder à la mode" and personality disorder, because there is no such border. Every feature he describes is also absolutely typical of one or most personality disorders. And don't forget: personality disorder doesn't just mean aggressive, it means "persistent discomfort or maladjustment to the society." But the one feature he doesn't recognise is .... self-involvement, the endless fascination with self that is the starting point of this odyssey.
But the most important target of his evangelising is the anxious personality, the insecure, uncertain person with fragile self-esteem who can cope on a good day but goes to bits under any sort of pressure to perform, because that's what anxiety is. Anxious personality isn't recognised by the vast committees of the Great and Good who write the DSM system. For them, anxiety is a brain disease which needs lots of drugs but with their conflicts of interest, of course they'd say that. I say: Anxiety is wholly a psychological state. People get trapped in states of self-reinforcing psychosomatic arousal, which can be either general or specific to certain situations, which wrecks their lives, but which readily responds to non-chemical management [1]. And this goes to the heart of the problem of psychiatry: you can rearrange the clusters of symptoms to suit any diagnosis or justify any cause just because mainstream psychiatry doesn't have a model of mental disorder.
So we have to leave it at that: if you want to believe your mild anxiety symptoms are a brain disorder for which you should join a support group, all well and good, much safer than psychiatry's drugs. But beware of one crucial point: the features of the "autism movement" are also the features of the common or garden cult. Granted, "autism" doesn't have a single guru leading the pack, it has hundreds, all with their own Facebook pages and Youtube channels and Instagram and Telegram feeds, take your pick. But in order to join the faithful, you are asked to believe that what you believe about yourself is sacrosanct, that nobody else is allowed to dispute it, that they have all the answers you will ever need and that you will feel wanted and valued when you join your own kind who will educate you in the path of righteousness and you too can repose as calmly as the charming lady at 5.40, secure in having arrived at inner peace and harmony just by accepting that you're a teensy bit freaky. But FFS, who isn't? And vive la différence, three cheers for screwballs and troublemakers and misfits who are grit in the cogs of the smooth-running machinery of the rigid, hierarchical, patriarchal, capitalist state that wants everybody shitfaced on their dangerous and expensive "ethical" drugs in front of the idiot box while they get on with the important business of blowing Gaza and Ukraine and Darfur and Yemen and Afghanistan and Syria and everywhere else to smithereens rather than getting upset about it and joining demonstrations.
No, mate, you're not autistic. I have a friend from university who has an autistic child. The child was developing very well until age two then, with no illness or injuries, deteriorated. Now, as an adult, their child is unable to speak beyond a few words like dada and mama, can't care for itself in any way, is doubly incontinent, cannot walk in a straight line, catch a ball or use a key to open a door, and doesn't relate to humans, all with no evidence of brain damage. That's autism.
Today's "autism movement" has become a cult of the self.
BTW, there's no such thing as an "unconscious myth." If it's a myth, it's fully conscious.
****
Reference: McLaren N (2018). Anxiety: The Inside Story. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
****
All this material is copyright but can be copied or retransmitted provided the author is acknowledged.

I just like you used the word, “smithereens”. You, Sir , are most certainly on the spectrum with your intense fascination with debunking psychiatry. Actually brilliant job, couldn’t put it down. And, that’s saying a lot for someone with ADHD and Autism , ha!
Diagnostic du jour