19 Comments
User's avatar
Julian Connelly's avatar

I like:

- We have to get rid of the urge to be number one in the world.

That mainly affects the United States, but it also has an effect on a smaller country like Australia which is probably always trying to move up the ladder.

- International relations are individual Psychology writ large (or words to effect)

Niall McLaren's avatar

Australia has always snuggled up to distant bullies and poked its tongue out at its neighbours.

Jose Francisco Sousa Alves's avatar

The six quotes could justify hate towards America. I believe most Americans don't share (agree with) those views (in the quotes). That's why America is so special.

Niall McLaren's avatar

My experience in the US is that the great majority of people do support the idea that the US is the greatest country ever and has a special right to lead the world, and to punish those who want to go a different direction. I am not aware there has been a single demonstration to oppose the current illegal strangulation of Cuba. Remember that 77million people voted for Trump.

Henry Mencken: Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard. Well, Trump is certainly jamming it up them but they can't say they weren't warned. We'll see what the elections bring. Cheers, JMcL

David Keay's avatar

A friend once gave me a DVD of Adam Curtis's film The Century of the Self. As well as the laudable material I'm sure it contained, I was put off at the time by the notion that the behavior of Deep State... or whatever you want to call it... can be reduced to a matter of psychology, as some of the material indicated.

Well steeped in the documentation of sophisticated power politics by Chomsky, Pilger, Parenti, etc. by then, I saw this approach as naive and simplistic: Group and individual psychologies are entirely different things.

It reminded me of those late 60s pop songs advising us that if we could just learn to love each other and get it together, everything would be alright.

Certainly, these people aren't "stupid" as depicted on, say, Saturday Night Live.

They know what they're doing, act out of self interest: Perfectly rational in a sense, as Chomsky would remind us.

The group perfectly personified by the schoolyard bully or Don Corleone, as he also often sarcastically and hilariously pointed out.

So, yes, I'd have to conclude that individual psychology adapts quite well to that of the group...

Concerning John Mearsheimer: His book The Tragedy of Great Power Politics is one of the very few I've ever abandoned halfway through, due its pragmatic view, seemingly devoid of moral criteria, in which U.S. responsibility for said Tragedy is absurdly understated, as if the world's nations had all been handed a level playing field and "we" simply assert our rights and play our games as just another competitor.

Yet, for co-authoring The Israel Lobby when that took vastly more chutzpah than it would today, I salute him. As well as for his crucial criticism of Western aggression in Ukraine, Iran and elsewhere.

Thanks for selecting the "We Think It's Worth It" Lady's equally heinous "Indispensable Nation" quip!

( Every other nation on earth is "dispensable," then. Disposable, like the garbage, which periodically needs to be taken out.)

If you haven't yet done so, be sure to watch her sing "Don't Fence Me In," with Elvis Costello on the Conan O'Brian Show!

I've always liked Elvis, but to exhibit such stultifying lack of judgement is typical of those in his position.

They must be aware of the grotesque irony. In fact, they appear to be CELEBRATING it, as the audience nervously laughs:

"Oh, give me land... Lots of land... Under starry skies above... Don't Fence Me In."

Niall McLaren's avatar

(apologies for the delayed response). "Group and individual psychologies are entirely different things." This goes back to Durkheim, esp. his Rules for Sociological Method from about 1895, in which he was at pains to distinguish sociology as he was developing it from psychology. He explicitly did not want sociology to sink to the level of being a branch of psychology, he wanted it as a stand-alone science which emerged from group behaviour. The problem is that nobody can define emergence adequately to show that groups have properties individuals don't (apart from mass effects, such as weighing more or making more noise or doing more damage). I think this is a serious failing of sociology and hope to work on it when time permits.

Mearsheimer adopts the positivist, anti-moralist view, which I think is misunderstood, people say "JM says international relations are anarchic, therefore we'd better get in first and attack them." Yes, they are anarchic, bc people attack preemptively. His approach creates the anarchy and licenses it. Cheers, JMcL

Elen Calima's avatar

Mearsheimer’s thesis—that "nations must strive to exert local dominance"—ought to have a parallel in every human society. Only after I have scratched the cars of all the neighbours who dared to park in "my" spot will they accept that my parking space must always be kept clear. We observe this attitude in our Forpus parrotlets (we run parrot aviaries in southern Thailand): "If you land on my perch, you get bitten."

In my view, the biggest problem with this insight is that Prof. Mearsheimer cannot assert it in the same breath as his vision of "multipolarity"—for the greater my "local dominance" becomes, the more my appetite for "global dominance" naturally grows.

Niall McLaren's avatar

That is absolutely right: the higher a person goes up the hierarchy, the greater his sense of entitlement. e.g it simply doesn't occur to J Kushner that he should not use his many government funded mediation trips here and there to raise money for his private hedge fund. If you or I did that, he would send the cops to drag us out but for him, he doesn't see anything wrong with it. Trump himself said it in the Access Tapes: "When you're a star, you can get away with anything."

PS Many years ago, I was at PSU in Haadyai for a year.

Elen Calima's avatar

Hat Yai" means "Long Beach" in Thai. We live in Prachuap, 300 km south of Bangkok, but we do occasionally drive through Hat Yai on our way to Malaysia.

And just between us: my husband and I are both Jewish (though not Israeli) and speak Hebrew. If we were to say even a tenth of what we sometimes hear from Bibi out loud in public in Europe, we would be put behind bars for several years.

Anne-Marie Paul's avatar

Please watch the video on YouTube from the channel Taboo Education: “Why are the americans so stupid” I think the presenter is actually an Australien.

She tells the history of the american school system - and it is rather educational.

Niall McLaren's avatar

She is definitely Australian.

In his excellent commentary, "Fantasyland," Kurt Andersen says: "Americans have always been magical thinkers and passionate believers in the untrue ... If I think it's true, no matter why or how I think it's true, then it's true and nobody can tell me otherwise."

Well worth reading.

Anne-Marie Paul's avatar

Thank you - I will look for the book

Jose Francisco Sousa Alves's avatar

77 million is not a majority of the American people. Plus, consider around 100 million who just don't vote, and, that MAGA is fragmenting.

For a nation like Australia, the question is simple. Which one is (would be) better: PAX AMERICANA or PAX SINICA?

You just cannot avoid leadership amongst the nations.

CHEERS

Niall McLaren's avatar

I have lived my entire life under the "pax americana," without there ever having been a moment of peace. In that time, the US has illegally invaded or attacked dozens of countries, destroying many of them in the process, fomented a hundred right wing or military coups, forced changes of democratically elected governments (including Australia in 1975), imposed brutal financial and other sanctions (just ask Cuba) and forced the world to live under threat 24/7. Granted, for much of that time, China was either prostrate or recovering but now that it has brought itself closer to their natural place in the world, the US is going berserk over the idea that it may lose its self-appointed status as World Policeman. See this article for a small glimpse but which says everything we need to know: the American idea of peace is "I hold the gun to your head while you peacefully do as I say."

https://declassifiedaus.org/2026/10/01/australian-island-bases-hidden-u-s-military-role/

Jose Francisco Sousa Alves's avatar

Right. "...their natural place in the world", makes me wonder. It's about a communist nation, (no democracy), whose record (on human rights, for example) is not that good as well. And, it's been updating militarily, ever. IN THE PACIFIC too. (I guess they made an artificial island...what for?)

The article mentions "possible conflict with China".

So, if that scenario plays out, who will you choose? I mean, which PAX?

Cheers

Niall McLaren's avatar

Chinese are mortally afraid of chaos. 19th Century was chaos, 20th was chaos squared; they have made remarkable progress over past 40yrs and are very happy with their current stability. Their streets are far safer than American, their health services for ordinary and poor people far better, education is roaring ahead but we are expected to shriek "but they're commies" and run the other way.

Watch Andy Boreham's regular Reports on China on Youtube, e.g.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpFu_1Zz0hM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Pe74U_xJKU

As for "possible conflict," that is a real risk but it will be fomented by the US, not by China. Australia has very foolishly handed its sovereignty to the world's most destructive nation and expects to get a good deal out of it by attacking our major trading partner.

As for China "updating militarily," they started a long way back and still have only 1/10 of the number of nuclear weapons the US has, 2 carriers compared with 9, on and on. The US has the motive, the means and the track record of suddenly attacking other countries. China correctly assumes they're on the American hit list and is taking defensive measures to keep the US military far from their shores. That is why Taiwan is so important: it is an American boot in the Chinese front door.

Jose Francisco Sousa Alves's avatar

Rosy China picture. No Mao disasters mentioned (in the Cultural Revolution, famine..). NO Tienanmen, NO TIBET, NO UIGHUR issues mentioned, as well. NOR “the surveillance state” in our days. ( In your text)

At least in Taiwan they have different colors to vote for. In China they vote for shades of red.

That's OK.

Thanks