In the first two parts of this series, I raised the question of whether psychiatry has a formal model of mental disorder because, if they don't, then mainstream psychiatry is not a science. Despite claims, there is no such thing as a "biomedical model of mental disorder" to justify the claim that mental disorder is all due to brain disturbances. That is pure ideology and, despite its popularity among academics, it's also considered extreme. Psychiatrists who prefer a more moderate or humane approach hold up the "biopsychosocial model" (BPSM) as their scientific paradigm. This, they say, was written in 1977 by George Engel and is unique to psychiatry. It allows the integration of biological, psychological and social facts about a person's mental state, leading to a fully-developed scientific treatment program. The BPSM is widely supported but, when we look for the details, there aren't any. Engel never wrote it, there isn't a journal of biopsychosocial psychiatry and no textbooks outlining the model, there is no learned society, no conventions or scientific meetings, no university courses, nothing. Where there should be a scientific model there is just an echo chamber where people repeat the same credo over and over until they all accept it as truth. But scientific truth is not established by repetition of a falsehood. Age of Fraud (Part 2) ended with these questions:
Is there something else going on? How come intelligent, well-educated people consistently and persistently insist that something is true when none of them has ever seen it or can produce it?
I think there is something else going on, and it's very serious, but we need to look outside psychiatry for the details. We know that in practically every moral system in the world, people who say something is true when they know it isn't are committing a moral offence. In science and medicine in particular, stating a falsehood is a very serious matter; people who do this can be booted out of their professions. However, if people say something false with the goal or plan of gaining a reward or benefit of some sort, that shifts it up several levels of seriousness, into the area of an actual offence known as fraud. This can be small-time, as in the Monty Python "Dead parrot" skit, or very big time, as in the unfolding saga of the bankrupt crypto exchange FTX.
The dictionary definition of fraud is:
Fraud: n 1. deliberate deception, trickery or cheating intended to gain an advantage. 2. an act of such deception. 3. something false or spurious. 4. Inf. a person who acts in a false or deceitful way (Collins, 1979).
At the least, it seems that psychiatry is touting something false or spuriousd, so we move to the next level, to the law on fraud. Legal jurisdictions that use a criminal code tend to have much the same definition, but the message is clear: if you cheat somebody with clear intent, then you are guilty of a crime. The Queensland Criminal Code (1899-2021) at S.408C states inter alia:
(1) A person who dishonestly … (d) gains a benefit or advantage, pecuniary or otherwise, for any person; … commits the crime of fraud (Qld Criminal Code, 1899-2021).
S.408C (2A) of the Code lists aggravating factors, including: “… (b) the offender carries on the business of committing the offence.”
S.408C (3)(a) specifies broadly that it is done for “… any benefit or advantage, anything evidencing a right to … receive a benefit …”
The fact that for 25 years after the first warning in 1998 that their model doesn't exist, psychiatry has "carried on" claiming they have this model constitutes an aggravation. This is also true of the fact that psychiatrists routinely misrepresent the nature of that warning. As for a "benefit or advantage, pecuniary (financial) or otherwise," psychiatrists presumably benefit from claiming the BPS model is real, otherwise they wouldn't do it but the benefit need not be financial. The intangible benefit of the prestige of being given vast and unique civil powers over patients would be one such advantage but there is also protection from criticism as a specialist, and the money that comes from it. Imagine psychiatry without the threat of detaining and treating people against their will. It would be rather a shrunken affair, giving new meaning to the slang expression "shrinks."
However, there can't be a crime without a guilty mind or mens rea but this is a sticky area. Criminal codes normally provide a defence relating to genuine mistakes, thus:
S.24. Mistake of fact:
(1) A person who does or omits to do an act under an honest and reasonable but mistaken belief in the existence of any state of things is not criminally responsible for the act or omission to any greater extent than if the real state of things had been such as the person believed to exist (Qld Criminal Code, 1899-2021).
You saw the quotes about psychiatry's wonderful BPSM in Part 2, these are from people at the top of the psychiatric foodchain. Is this defence of an "honest but reasonable but mistaken belief" available to professors and editors who have repeatedly been warned that their preferred model doesn't exist, and who have uniformly failed even to respond to the charge? I submit that psychiatry's lavish support for a non-existent model is neither honest nor reasonable as it ceased being a mistake in 1998. This leads to further questions, the first being: is this a matter of a criminal conspiracy to defraud the public? If it is, then we should immediately involve the police but I suspect they won't want to touch it because it would be too difficult to prove. All the academics would stand up and swear they have the BPS model.
However, there is a broader meaning of conspiracy, what is called a conspiracy of the like-minded, more politely known as tacit agreement. Say there's a group of people who run a football club, and they are approached by the local Gay Pride group who want to hire their football grounds for a march and party. The footballers don't have to sit down in a dark, smoky room and work out what to say. They are like-minded, they all know what to say: "Piss off, we’ll be using it." When psychiatrists are asked "Do you have a model to guide your practice, your teaching and research?" they all know what to say: "Of course, we've got the biopsychosocial model." If asked "Can you point me to it?" they reply irritably "It's in the literature." Asked to provide a copy, they abruptly end the conversation and you will never hear from them again.
Now that says something, because professionals are not allowed to leave the hard work to others. Before you take off in a plane, the pilots sit at their controls for half an hour and check everything. At the end of an operation, two nurses count every needle and instrument. And when a psychiatrist like Ronald Pies says academic psychiatry has advocated the biopsychosocial model for 30 yrs, he needs to provide it, not say, as he did, "I don't have time for this conversation." Psychiatrists seem to think they can flick critical questions aside and just keep repeating the same empty mantra to silence critics. This raises the question of whether there could be a civil case of a tort, an injury caused by psychiatry's abject failure to reach the standards expected of specialists. Civil cases are determined on the balance of probability, but it would not be an easy case to pursue as the entire resources of the psychiatric profession and of the drug industry would be thrown into the battle.
Psychiatry is a peculiar beast as it straddles the border of law and medicine. These, of course, are highly developed fields with long histories in all cultures. Crucially, each of them has a long record of enquiry into the ethics of professional activities. In law, people charged with crimes have firmly established rights that must be observed very strictly before they can be convicted. A defendant has the right to know the nature of the accusations, to see all the evidence, the right to cross-examine the accuser, to be tried fairly by a jury, and above all, the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt. This is absolutely basic to Western law as we understand it because we believe that it is far better morally to let wrong-doers escape justice rather than wrongly convict one innocent person. This is a major argument against death sentences.
Medicine has similar rules which are enforceable by medical boards. Patients have the right to be treated regardless of any fact other than their illness; there should be equality in services, privacy, the right to request and the right to reject treatment, to know the risks and benefits of treatment vs. no treatment, and so on. There are strict rules over what constitutes valid treatment and a firm line is drawn between acceptable medicine and quackery.
Now you might think that since it straddles these fields, psychiatry would have adopted the entire ethical principles of each of them, or even just the bestbits of each profession. You might also think that because the mentally-disordered are among the most vulnerable in the community, they would have extra protection, but no, none of it. Psychiatry has dropped all ethical principles of each world. In dealing with the mentally-disturbed, psychiatry has just one ethical principle: "Our self-imposed right to treat negates all your wishes, your objections and your civil rights."
Psychiatry is not so much a hybrid of medicine and law as the mongrel offspring. It doesn't have a foot in both camps, it occupies a walled enclave between the two fields in which it is a law unto itself, totally indifferent to the ethical demands of both medicine and law. For example, a person can be forcibly taken into custody by police without any charges, without knowing who has lodged what accusations and can be held incommunicado without warnings of any sort. Anything he says is most likely to be used against him. When it comes to a tribunal hearing, these are not courts. In Australia, they are classed as "quasi-judicial proceedings" and the emphasis is on the quasi. Members of the tribunal are largely chosen by the tribunal itself, with essentially no independent oversight.
The great majority of people appearing before mental health tribunals have no legal representative even though they can lose almost all their civil rights indefinitely. The rules of evidence do not apply. Witnesses are not sworn and hearsay evidence is routinely admitted. Patients are usually too frightened, too confused and/or too befuddled by drugs to raise objections. Decisions are made after a few minutes of secret deliberation by the tribunal and decisions are not publicised. The ostensive reason for the secrecy is to protect patient privacy but the net effect is to hogtie the patient in an elastic system of rules and to protect the psychiatrists from recrimination.
All of this takes place in a scientific vacuum. There is no written justification anywhere in the world which warrants this massive transfer of authority to psychiatry. None. There are plenty of reasons, legal, moral and scientific reasons, why this should not happen but they are ignored. So, is the profession of psychiatry guilty of a massive scientific conspiracy to defraud the general public and to enrich themselves at public expense? Interesting question but I'll promise you one thing: you will never read a response from mainstream psychiatry. Twenty-five years of trying to expose the deception of the non-existent "biopsychosocial model" shows their only responses are: Ignore the criticism until it goes away but if if doesn't, then attack the critic.
I am not able to give any individual psychiatric advice beyond this: If you are taking psychiatric drugs, do not under any circumstances stop them abruptly as you are likely to go into a severe and potentially dangerous withdrawal state. They can only be reduced under close medical supervision.

I am so thankful that you stayed in Psychiatry. God knows it was not the easy choice for you. I remember when Psychiatry was generally thought of as a combo of medicine and philosophy. Dr.'s were chasing a sound philosophy and it was evolving. The evolution seems to have stalled in favour of this pretend bio psycho social model and lots of chemical lobotomy drugs. The only ones winning are the drug companies and the doctors no longer have to give the patient much thought. Just numb and dumb them into complacency.Life quality of a patient goes from bad to worse. Thankfully you kept going with an alternative theory that is very helpful and easily applicable. Many patients sense that something is amiss in this process. Thank you for acknowledging that there is indeed an elephant in the room. It's a tough place to be alone with the truth in a pack of false believers.
My experience means I agree with almost everything you say. You are one of the very few psychiatrists to publically say all this. In particular you know that people are being tortured - Akathisia - by neurotoxic drugs in psych 'hospitals' and not really treated - it is very serious abuse.
What I do not understand is why you didn't get out and be a GP or do some other academic profession?