Last week, the former UN Special Rapporteur, Prof. Dainius Puras, of Vilnuis University, Lithuania, visited Adelaide to speak at a conference. During the week, he found time for an informal talk to the Critical Psychiatry Network, which was broadcast on Zoom. His full title with the UN was the snappy Special Rapporteur to the UN Human Rights Council (HRC) on the Right of Everyone to the Enjoyment of the Highest Attainable Standard of Physical and Mental Health. In the main, his reports concerned mental health. To begin his talk, he explained the unique position of the 42 mandated special rapporteurs, that they are not employed by the UN but have to survive on their salaries from home, so they can't be dismissed from their posts. The HRC pays their costs, but that's all, so they are generally free to report the facts as they are without risk of being pressured by people who don't like the unpleasant facts they've discovered.
His annual reports showed world-wide a heavy and ever-growing reliance on "managing" mental disorder as firstly, something that needs to be managed and second, where management means drugs and incarceration. His report of April 2020 [1] stated:
... despite promising trends, there remains a global failure of the status quo to address human rights violations in mental health-care systems. This frozen status quo reinforces a vicious cycle of discrimination, disempowerment, coercion, social exclusion and injustice. To end the cycle, distress, treatment and support must be seen more broadly and move far beyond a biomedical understanding of mental health. Global, regional and national conversations are needed to discuss how to understand and respond to mental health conditions. Those discussions and actions must be rights-based, holistic and rooted in the lived experience of those left furthest behind by harmful sociopolitical systems, institutions and practices.
This is fairly moderate: Can we look beyond the idea that mental disorder is necessarily biological and must be managed harshly? Needless to say, the people who push the biological wagon and believe most firmly in drugs and locking people up were outraged. One of them was the irrepressible Prof. Ian Hickie, Co-Director of Health and Policy at the Brain and Mind Centre, University of Sydney, former director of beyond blue, the National Depression Initiative, and a whole lot more beside. In a textbook example of begging the question (i.e. assuming the truth of that which requires proof), Hickie claimed that recasting mental disorder as a "health issue" has been entirely beneficial:
The actual history of societal approaches to mental health has been a continuous journey from ignorance, discrimination, social isolation, institutional abuse, and neglect to a more enlightened, socially inclusive, and holistic approach to the societal and economic importance of optimal mental health and wellbeing ... This has been accompanied by the movement to less restrictive and more balanced (including greater emphasis on psychosocial care) and higher quality mental health care ... this progressive journey has been facilitated by the conceptualisation of mental disorders primarily as health problems. The fundamental role of biomedical and clinical leadership ... is clear [2].
Sometimes you wonder what planet this bloke lives on but we'll come to the answer. The question he begs is this: "Is mental disorder correctly classified as a 'biomedical' condition that should be managed by standard medical means?" He believes and relies on the answer Yes, most definitely it is a medical condition which, of course, is unproven. Otgherwise, as a matter of established fact, the history of psychiatry has been the replacement of one form of ignorance (possession states) with another (chemical imbalance of the brain); institutional abuse has become legal institutional abuse such as Queensland refusing entry to the HRC Subcommittee for the Prevention of Torture; and yes, psychiatry is now holistic if you call handing out pills for everything holistic.
But that's the point Puras is making: for all the high-sounding talk about progress and enlightenment and all that (and few can match Hickie for high-sounding talk), down here at street level or back there in the mental hospitals, very little has actually changed. I first walked onto a psychiatric ward in 1969. The last time was about five years ago. I swear nothing had changed. Nothing. Possibly the biggest social change is that citizens are now invited to label themselves (the latest label is neurodiverse, but it follows a long list such as ADHD, ODD, OCD, ASD, bipolar, etc) and then badger their general practitioners for drugs, pressure which GPs are incapable of resisting.
Now I have no doubt somebody is already shrieking "But I'm neurodiverse, how dare you dismiss my reality," which raises an important point I've been hammering for years (to no avail, mind you): that the institution of psychiatry is engaged in a major, long-term program of reclassifying personality factors (for which there is no drug treatment) as "illness," and putting people on drugs for life (see Chapters 14-16 of [3], also [4]). Let's take last week's example of "Rejection-Sensitive Dysphoria" (RSD), an amazing new diagnosis consisting of:
... 'unbearable' pain as a result of perceived or actual rejection, teasing, or criticism ... a brain-based symptom that is likely an innate feature of ADHD. Though the experience of rejection sensitive dysphoria can be painful and even traumatic, RSD is not thought to be caused by trauma.
If it's "brain-based," the next step will be to find a drug for it, which will require lots of expensive research. First point: discomfort upon feeling rejected is real. It actually has a strong basis in biology and is widely distributed in nature: a puppy that's growled at by bigger dogs slinks away and hides. If you pick it up and pet it, it will react excessively ("gratefully"). The need to feel part of a group is imprinted in our DNA. Second, in humans, the factor that triggers the sense of hurt is one of the general rules of life acquired by an individual during early life, mostly by about fifteen. These rules are better known as personality factors. To call that trigger "brain-based" is an abuse of the concept. It is brain-based only in the sense that, ultimately, everything we do is brain-based because when the brain stops working, so do we.
There is, however, a profound difference between "brain-based" as in "structure of the brain," and "brain-based" as in "learned." It is ultimately true that speaking Swahili but not Turkmen, or preferring heavy metal to rap, are "brain-based" and not "liver-based," but there is a profound difference between "coded in the DNA" and "learned, acquired, a matter of choice." This difference is blindingly apparent to ordinary humans but falls in one of psychiatry's (many) blind spots. So be assured, if you "suffer RSD," there's nothing wrong with your brain, you just have a personality disorder. Omigod nononono, I'd rather be sick than a weirdo!!! OK, have it your way, but when it comes to personality profiles, I do not fall in the "normal range," for which I thank whichever gods are on duty today. Being normal? Imagine having to trust Scott Morrison. What a frightening thought. I'll keep my suspicions, thank you.
So back to Bro. Hickie. Bear in mind that I have spoken to him once, briefly, about 30 years ago and thought his understanding of mental disorder was, shall we say, stereotyped. I am simply using him as an exemplar of what Dainius Puras was referring to in his reports, as in "We must move beyond a biomedical understanding of mental disorder." We have to ask: What planet does Hickie live on? We all know that one, he lives on Planet E-S (executive suite). He inhabits handsome offices in surreally quiet buildings on elegant campuses (campi?) and occupies himself flitting from meetings with other politicians to conferences with drug companies and research seminars with the like-minded and maybe even a bit of indoctrination, sorry, teaching on the side, but as for getting vomit or blood or shit smeared on his Armanis, no, I doubt he's done much of that.
Second question: As card-carrying residents of Planet E-S, how much psychiatry do the Hickies of the world of psychiatry actually know? Without interrogating them (they're too smart to agree), I don't think they know much at all. Hickie talks about a "holistic approach to the societal and economic importance of optimal mental health and wellbeing"? What crap. In fact, it's the worst form of crap, it's deceptive and self-serving crap. It's what you'd expect from people who take a lot of money from drug companies and don't believe this could produce bias. Don't believe or don't care, same difference. It's what you'd expect from people who have no model of mental disorder to guide their practice, teaching, research, administration and politics of psychiatry, but who believe firmly that a full understanding of the brain is all you need to understand mental disorder. Above all, they want you to believe it too.
Failing that, there is the fall-back position called "evidence-based practice," which, because there is no model to guide it, only means picking the evidence you want to see. If you want to see all mental disorder as a moral failing, that's exactly what you'll see: "Why don't you get up and get a job? What do you mean, scared of interviews? There's nothing to be scared of, you're just lazy." If you want to see it as "chemistry," that's what you'll see except there's nothing to see so you keep getting grants to study the effects of psilocybin on inflammatory kinins absorbed by defective microvilli in irritable bowel syndrome (here) but when that turns out to be a shower of malabsorbed faecal material, you rush off to the next fad. Excuse me, evidence-based research indication.
Hickie and all the other HIMS (high income movers and shakers) in psychiatry do not have a solution to the issues raised in Prof. Puras' very moderate reports. They are the problem. They are the problem because they believe as a matter of faith that mental disorder is a physical condition of the brain and more to the point, they actively repress alternative views. Some years ago, I was invited to a conference and, at the end, sat on a panel with the other speakers. I mentioned that mainstream psychiatric journals no longer publish material of a psychotherapeutic nature. "Oh," said a senior psychiatrist on the panel, "that's not true. Journals regularly publish alternative views." That weekend, I checked all issues of the British and American Journals of Psychiatry for the preceding two years, about 400 original papers, editorials, commentaries and so on. Not one was on the topic of psychotherapy. Not one. I didn't bother telling the self-assured shrink, not because I was concerned he might have a mental breakdown from the cognitive dissonance and end up with ten different drugs and ECT, but because I knew it wouldn't penetrate his head.
A week or two ago, I asked whether psychiatry is a cult. It has many of the features of a cult, and we will talk about them in due course. What we see here, in psychiatry's response to the Special Rapporteur's widely-canvassed and carefully-balanced conclusions, is an important part of any cult, what is called the illusory truth effect, or repetition illusion. Simply, people believe what they're told repeatedly, even when it's patent rubbish. People believed in tree spirits because that's what they were told from infancy but, and this is important, the belief then shapes what they see as adults. You believe in tree spirits, well it's just amazing how much evidence you will see to prove they exist. It's the familiarity that counts. When the first drawings of Australian bush were sent back to England, they had to draw kangaroos walking clumsily on four legs, just because nobody would believe in hopping animals.
So psychiatrists constantly repeat the refrain "Mental disorder is brain disorder, and everything is getting better and better. PS Please send a few milllion more for research and conferences." In a self-reinforcing process, they say it because they believe it and they believe it because they say it. They believe their journals are fair and balanced because that's part of the narrative, that psychiatry is fair and balanced and progressively psychosocial yahdy yah, and they get angry and defensive when anybody questions that: "Oh, you're just extremist and dangerous and anti-psychiatry." Which, as Prof. Puras said in a recent email, is exactly what he gets from his colleagues in Vilnius. It's everywhere. Psychiatrists have to believe that they're right just because the alternative is too scary. Like a cult, people join to allay their fears then they become too scared to leave. Now that's irony for you.
References at the end.
Note: a commentary on Mad in America last week gave details of a small court win against the manufacturers of ECT machines: https://www.madinamerica.com/2023/08/partial-win-ect-justice/
****
I will shortly start a second blog on politics through the lens of the model outlined in Narcisso-Fascism (the price is now corrected to AUD). It will go out automatically to all subscribers; if you don't want to receive it, there is a link to unsubscribe from that section. My point of view is critical: anybody from any wing or branch of politics is fair game. So let's have a look at one typical topic, starting with an item of news. As you may know, Norway puts all the royalties from its vast gas and oil fields, as much as 40% of the sale price of the fuels, into a sovereign wealth fund. This past year, the fund declared a profit of US$143billion. That's with a B. It amounts to about US$27,000 for every man, woman and child in the country, although they won't actually see it because it's mostly reinvested. The fund is worth about $1.45trillion. With a T. That's a lot of money to have sitting in a bank somewhere for when you get too old to chase the reindeer out of your garden. It is indeed a very great deal of money. All of it comes from their royalties.
In the book, I develop the idea that humans are acquisitive animals, but the more we have, the more we want and the more we think we're entitled to. This is biological and the actual mechanism is described. As an example, look at the three ring circus underway in West Australia this week. Australia's richest person, and the ninth-richest woman in the world, Mme Gina Rinehart (US$23.6billion) is staging yet another slog 'em and drag 'em out brawl with her various relatives and erstwhile business partners. Ms Rinehart, née Hancock, inherited a fortune which has only grown since but she is implacable in her hostility toward anybody who thinks they might like a bit too, including her two eldest offspring and her father's former partners, etc. The details are sordid and not interesting unless you're the sort of person who buys Royals at the supermarket to keep up with young Harry Windsor and whatshername.
Under the terms of the original agreement with the West Australian government (in the 1960s), which was in a rush to develop what are the world's largest ironfields, the State government got a royalty of 25c per tonne of ore shipped out (these details are difficult to find and aren't guaranteed). At the time, the price of ore was $2.50 a tonne, meaning the state got a 10% royalty. That is still the case. 25c, I mean, not 10%. The family who owned the cattle station where the ore was discovered, the Hancocks, very wisely opted for a 2.5% royalty on the sale price. When ore hit US$220 a tonne recently, that meant they got AU$8.25 royalty, or twenty-five times as much as the state. It's now down to about US$110, so they'll have to struggle by on about AU$4.00 but what they lose on the swing of the price, they gain on the roundabout of volume, because the volumes are enormous. This month's battle royale is over a particular field that exports 47million tonnes a year. That yields the matriarch something like AU$190million a year. From this field alone. Not counting all the rest, nor the capital appreciation of her myriad assets.
Now you'd think that with that sort of loot cluttering up her various bank accounts, she wouldn't begrudge her offspring a shekel or two, but you'd be wrong. It seems she wants it all herself. And has always done so. Because she's entitled to it. Her father discovered the ore, he left it to her, it's hers so you can all get effed. One report says that at one stage, her son, who changed his name back to Hancock in spite, couldn't afford to get new brakes on his car because she had tied up all the money in some unfathomable trust account or something.
But my point is simple: they shouldn't have this money. While Rinehart gets nearly $200million to squirrel away, the WA Government will get about $12million, which is a drop in the bucket (BTW, like the Federal Government, WA has no sovereign wealth fund, partly because of stupid politicians who were opposed to such things, and also because the royalties are so small it hardly gets any). At the very least, it should be the other way around. It is an obscene travesty, an unassailable argument against untrammelled capitalism, that these people have this sort of money to play their legal games with while the country is facing a housing crisis. That's because the money being stashed in offshore tax havens by gigantic multinational corporations is actually the people's money. Not that they'll ever see any of it. Compare this with the far-sighted and sagacious Norwegians who ignored the pathetic bleats and threats of the mining companies and settled on 40% royalty for the nation.
Believe this: The more people have, the more they want and the more they feel they are entitled to. That's genetic, by the way. It can't be rectified by appealing to their better nature because the wealthy don't have one. It can only be rectified by legislation, which they will oppose bitterly, spending our money on legislators to help them hide their ill-gotten piles of gold.
References:
1. Puras D (2020). UN Human Rights Council. Report of the Special Rapporteur on the right of everyone to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health. UNHRC Document A /HRC/44/48. Final report: July 16th 2020, UN Doc. A/75/163. At:
2. Hickie, I, (2019). Building the social, economic, legal, and health-care foundations for “Contributing Lives and Thriving Communities”. The Lancet Psychiatry. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(19)30378-5
3. McLaren N (2012). The Mind-Body Problem Explained: The Biocognitive Model for Psychiatry. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
4. McLaren N. (2011). Temper Tantrums, Mental Disorder and DSM-5: the Case for Caution. Psychiatric Times, Feb 22, 2011. https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/temper-tantrums-mental-disorder-and-dsm-5-case-caution

As I will soon be returning to the Ivory Towers, the first invite I received is to a lecture on Developing new treatments for psychosis, by a professor who is chief investigator on several randomized controlled trials for repurposed and targeted treatments and (amongst other positions) Honorary General Secretary of the British Association for Psychopharmacology. Titles of this individual’s publications investigate Inflammation and brain structure in schizophrenia and other neuropsychiatric disorders using Mendelian randomization, and The psychopathology and neuroanatomical markers of depression in early psychosis. I haven’t read them, but it seems to me they are alluding to the biological model of mental disorder, and whilst not specifically referring to chemical imbalance theory, advocate theories of markers and structures that reinforce the idea that investigations of the brain will yield all the answers and must continue. I received a second invite to a talk investigating the molecular genetics and brain correlates of executive functioning, a pivotal cognitive process implicated in psychiatric disorders (speaker from your neck of the woods-Professor Scott Clark, Head of the Adelaide University Discipline of Psychiatry). These kinds of lectures always conspire in my mind to support the biological basis of mental disorder without specifically stating it, and whilst the speakers may not have ties with drug companies, they enjoy the trappings of academia whilst seemingly conducting worthwhile research.
Would you call this deceptive and self-serving crap alongside the Hickies of this world? Or just a waste of time and money? I have the links to virtually attend either of these talks by the way if you or anyone else wants them.
It's hard to imagine anyone getting locked up these days for “having” ADHD, especially in the industry I have worked in the last few years, where the “softer” side of this “psychiatric disease” is embraced as a different way of thinking and part of the grand “neurodiversity” of the world. I wonder if such people ever consider the darker (real) side of these diagnoses (is Lucy Letby neurodiverse?), their origin, history, drugging of children (and now adults of course) and how their promulgation of such concepts supports the psychiatric machine. We were reminded at a recent work meeting by an “adhd’er” that October is ADHD month and I have witnessed the ludicrous spectacle of people leaving our company and then two months later declaring themselves to be an employed ADHD coach- but they do and there is a huge demand for it. Two employees also recently declared themselves to be “autistic” (one did this via a video shortly after the first person wrote a piece declaring their own autistic “neurodiversity”, almost as if it was a competition. Neither of them, are of course, autistic). However, people embrace it, this new fad of neurodiversity and whilst I stand by my original comments on it which you wrote about (I have left a new comment on that article today also), people genuinely think that phrasing their “conditions” in this manner helps them -I believe it is now also considered a protected characteristic at least in the UK. My final analysis is that, although ND may help some people in certain circles, it is of course false to equate neurons with thought (by definition it states thoughts are biological basically) and the whole concept is essentially a narcissists’ dream and of course cui bono?
Thank you Dr McLaren, I discovered you through The Pink Panthers website, I really enjoy your articles and specially your integrity! We need people like you in society, in our schools, our universities and communities, you are the light that can be seen at the end of the tunnel.. G_D bless you! 🌹🔥👏🕯️