If papers about panpsychism can get published, then I don't see any problem with the word spirituality. Although maybe you could parenthesis it with mind.
Regarding your recent BPS paper, I was at a science communications workshop yesterday and was chatting to the speaker about how industry involvement in publications/journals prevents criticism. We got chatting about the chemical imbalance theory being implausible and she actually mentioned the BPS model as the alternative. I pointed out to her that the model doesn't actually exist (she didn't know who came up with it) and mentioned to her how, as per Sagan's quote in your paper, it is so easy to be bamboozled when something is repeated enough and the irony of her communicating science incorrectly. She didn't seem to understand what constitutes a model, but it was really interesting as here was direct evidence of exactly your points in the paper (I was actually reading the paper during the talk, but didn't mention this to her until after she mentioned the model herself).
Anyway, she wanted to read your paper so I was going to send her a copy if that's okay?
By all means send it. However, the speaker is a classic example of how people just repeat high-sounding drivel rather than do the hard work of actually finding out what's going on.
Yes I don't hold much hope- she wasn't aware of what neologism meant as I also mentioned about how they can also have similar effect of creating ideas which have no substance. But at least she was open to reading a different point of view.
An article from yourself on here about free will would be great if you have the time- especially about the Libet stuff and why that fits in with your model. You mention it a couple of times in your latest book, but the example (in chapter three I think) from what I can remember seemed a bit ambiguous (at least to me anyway). From memory I think you gave the example of a Bower bird changing direction at the last second based on information extracted from the environment about its current path, which seems to me a calculation by the same processes which sent it on it's initial path rather than an independent informational decision to divert it from the current path. Although I think you do give another example later on about how forward planning does not metabolically cost any extra which made more sense.
In terms of energy balances, which is the critical argument against free will, it makes no difference whether the brain is calculating how to win a game or composing nonsense rhymes. Whether the brain's function is coordinated or uncoordinated, it's all the same biologically. Once the brain is working, decisions are a free lunch. It does not breach Laws of Thermodynamics to say we decide our paths in life.
But how would the more automated decisions be separated from the seemingly less automated ones? I think you give some examples of speech and driving in the book which are automatic and beyond our control (procedural memory in the case of driving). Are these kind of decisions different from if I decide to have a cheese sandwich for lunch? Where does the agency come from for the second kind of decision when ultimately, both types of decision arise from procedures I cannot introspect or change but am rather mere recipient of those procedures? Even if I decide to have a ham sandwich at the last second, this is just a feeling thrust upon me from procedures I am unaware of and cannot interfere with, even though it feels like I made the decision (this is, I think, why some people call free will an illusion). Where does the extra agency come from generally/in your model?
I work in the state service mainstream (sometimes I despair). I read your articles and I always get a laugh.
From the uncomfortable corner where lived experience meets the "clinically" blinded I say. . I really enjoyed that!. Thanks Niall. Our minds do matter.
Dr McLaren 👏👏👏👏👏🌻🌼💥 yes I do agree with your post! Thank you for your integrity and for sharing it.
I will publish your link in my humble telegram!! 💌
The main problem out there is that the system on what humanity exist is not working for us.. partially is the immature soul of millions of people that are not allowed to grow and still are
Illiterate in spite having a degree, or a doctorate schools and universities have degraded souls and bodies, is now difficult to find analytical skills because the integrity has been canceled as a part of us, and changed with idiotic submission, maybe the testosterone has diminish in us 😂.
Your articles need to be spread to spark discussion in opening a different path for those who are labeled "mentally ill".
Specially now for the ones that understand Covid scam/ Genocide as we can fully be diagnose as "schizophrenics" and with a possibility of being detained, drugged and locked in their cities in a near future unless we dismantle psychiatry and nullifie the psychiatrist existence.
How those patients people knew/knows so much about the real intentions about "governments" without having to go through the Covid experience? They have all my respects... no one is mentioning that the diagnosis of schizophrenia has now become obsolete, the feeling of persecution and harming from governments to "simple souls" has been shown to be real, (depopulation etc..) yet
it seems is all ignored..
I feel a sense of urgency to liberate all those forced drugged and locked, yet I feel my voice is ignored wherever I speak up, no response, like if they blocked their ears not understanding, they can be the next and no one will come for them.
Thinking simple how can we consider our selves "sane" not being affected by the insanity around us where human lives are expendables base on increasing the money of the pockets of a few subhumans? How can we change the status quo? Thank you again for your posts! 💌🕊️
How can we change the status quo? I'm not sure, if I knew, I probably wouldn't be sitting in this chair, but one thing I do know: The status quo is not going to change itself. The people who are profiting from it will fight to retain their privilege. If we do nothing, we are complicit.
Yes! I agree we cannot sit and watch, they can take much more benefit if they really care on helping people to go over their crises many times provoked by the same system we are in and in other occasions they are part of a soul evolution..
At least nowadays people can connect easily and there are more chances to spread the information if is not blocked before.
Thank you to reply, I will love to meet you in person, sadly we are on the other side of the glove G-d bless you
If papers about panpsychism can get published, then I don't see any problem with the word spirituality. Although maybe you could parenthesis it with mind.
Regarding your recent BPS paper, I was at a science communications workshop yesterday and was chatting to the speaker about how industry involvement in publications/journals prevents criticism. We got chatting about the chemical imbalance theory being implausible and she actually mentioned the BPS model as the alternative. I pointed out to her that the model doesn't actually exist (she didn't know who came up with it) and mentioned to her how, as per Sagan's quote in your paper, it is so easy to be bamboozled when something is repeated enough and the irony of her communicating science incorrectly. She didn't seem to understand what constitutes a model, but it was really interesting as here was direct evidence of exactly your points in the paper (I was actually reading the paper during the talk, but didn't mention this to her until after she mentioned the model herself).
Anyway, she wanted to read your paper so I was going to send her a copy if that's okay?
By all means send it. However, the speaker is a classic example of how people just repeat high-sounding drivel rather than do the hard work of actually finding out what's going on.
Yes I don't hold much hope- she wasn't aware of what neologism meant as I also mentioned about how they can also have similar effect of creating ideas which have no substance. But at least she was open to reading a different point of view.
An article from yourself on here about free will would be great if you have the time- especially about the Libet stuff and why that fits in with your model. You mention it a couple of times in your latest book, but the example (in chapter three I think) from what I can remember seemed a bit ambiguous (at least to me anyway). From memory I think you gave the example of a Bower bird changing direction at the last second based on information extracted from the environment about its current path, which seems to me a calculation by the same processes which sent it on it's initial path rather than an independent informational decision to divert it from the current path. Although I think you do give another example later on about how forward planning does not metabolically cost any extra which made more sense.
In terms of energy balances, which is the critical argument against free will, it makes no difference whether the brain is calculating how to win a game or composing nonsense rhymes. Whether the brain's function is coordinated or uncoordinated, it's all the same biologically. Once the brain is working, decisions are a free lunch. It does not breach Laws of Thermodynamics to say we decide our paths in life.
But how would the more automated decisions be separated from the seemingly less automated ones? I think you give some examples of speech and driving in the book which are automatic and beyond our control (procedural memory in the case of driving). Are these kind of decisions different from if I decide to have a cheese sandwich for lunch? Where does the agency come from for the second kind of decision when ultimately, both types of decision arise from procedures I cannot introspect or change but am rather mere recipient of those procedures? Even if I decide to have a ham sandwich at the last second, this is just a feeling thrust upon me from procedures I am unaware of and cannot interfere with, even though it feels like I made the decision (this is, I think, why some people call free will an illusion). Where does the extra agency come from generally/in your model?
I work in the state service mainstream (sometimes I despair). I read your articles and I always get a laugh.
From the uncomfortable corner where lived experience meets the "clinically" blinded I say. . I really enjoyed that!. Thanks Niall. Our minds do matter.
Dr McLaren 👏👏👏👏👏🌻🌼💥 yes I do agree with your post! Thank you for your integrity and for sharing it.
I will publish your link in my humble telegram!! 💌
The main problem out there is that the system on what humanity exist is not working for us.. partially is the immature soul of millions of people that are not allowed to grow and still are
Illiterate in spite having a degree, or a doctorate schools and universities have degraded souls and bodies, is now difficult to find analytical skills because the integrity has been canceled as a part of us, and changed with idiotic submission, maybe the testosterone has diminish in us 😂.
Your articles need to be spread to spark discussion in opening a different path for those who are labeled "mentally ill".
Specially now for the ones that understand Covid scam/ Genocide as we can fully be diagnose as "schizophrenics" and with a possibility of being detained, drugged and locked in their cities in a near future unless we dismantle psychiatry and nullifie the psychiatrist existence.
How those patients people knew/knows so much about the real intentions about "governments" without having to go through the Covid experience? They have all my respects... no one is mentioning that the diagnosis of schizophrenia has now become obsolete, the feeling of persecution and harming from governments to "simple souls" has been shown to be real, (depopulation etc..) yet
it seems is all ignored..
I feel a sense of urgency to liberate all those forced drugged and locked, yet I feel my voice is ignored wherever I speak up, no response, like if they blocked their ears not understanding, they can be the next and no one will come for them.
Thinking simple how can we consider our selves "sane" not being affected by the insanity around us where human lives are expendables base on increasing the money of the pockets of a few subhumans? How can we change the status quo? Thank you again for your posts! 💌🕊️
How can we change the status quo? I'm not sure, if I knew, I probably wouldn't be sitting in this chair, but one thing I do know: The status quo is not going to change itself. The people who are profiting from it will fight to retain their privilege. If we do nothing, we are complicit.
Yes! I agree we cannot sit and watch, they can take much more benefit if they really care on helping people to go over their crises many times provoked by the same system we are in and in other occasions they are part of a soul evolution..
At least nowadays people can connect easily and there are more chances to spread the information if is not blocked before.
Thank you to reply, I will love to meet you in person, sadly we are on the other side of the glove G-d bless you
I can have a look but if it's non-medical, I'm probably not much use. JMcL