These posts examine modern psychiatry from a critical point of view. Unfortunately, mainstream psychiatrists usually react badly to any sort of critical analysis of their activities, labelling critics as “anti-psychiatry,” whatever that is. Regardless, criticism is an integral part of any scientific field and psychiatry is no different. As it emerges, there is a lot to be critical about.
If you like what you read, please click the “like” button at the bottom of the text, it helps spread the posts to new readers. If you want to comment, please use the link at the end rather than email me as they get lost and nobody sees them.
****
A policeman patrolling a street one night came across an obviously intoxicated man crawling around under a street light. “Can I help you?” asked the policeman. “I’m looking for my key,” said the man. “Where did you lose it?” The man pointed unsteadily into the darkness. “Over there,” he slurred. “Well, shouldn’t you look over there for it?” “Don’t be silly,” snorted the drunk, “the light’s over here.”
****
A reader wasn’t happy with my comments on schizophrenia last week, specifically that all the genetic research (which goes back nearly 140 years) has amounted to naught. He suggested I should consider “a simple case of schizophrenia,” 22q 11.2 deletion syndrome (previously known as di George syndrome). This case confirms what I said: of the hundreds of minor genetic anomalies discovered over the past 25yrs, not one is either necessary or sufficient to “cause” the syndrome known as schizophrenia (necessary means you can’t have the syndrome without the defect, and sufficient means that if you have the defect, you are guaranteed to develop the psychotic state regardless). Di George syndrome is a rare spontaneous mutation (1 in 4000 births) associated with intellectual handicap and a host of physical problems. About 30% of these people will develop a psychotic state, usually diagnosed as schizophrenia. As is true of all the symptomatic psychoses, the chromosomal defect is neither necessary nor sufficient to cause the mental disorder. Most emphatically, 22q 11.2 deletion syndrome is not “a simple case of schizophrenia.”
What does this have to do with drunks searching under street lights? A great deal, because psychiatry is searching for the “cause” of mental disorder under the glaring street light called “laboratory science,” and finding nothing, all the while ignoring the clues “out there” in the uncharted darkness called mind. The search for the elusive schizococcus or schizogene is wholly ideological, as nobody has shown that mental disorder is necessarily biological in nature. Years ago, psychiatrist Paul McHugh (now aged 95), of Johns Hopkins University, put his finger on this:
Psychiatry remains the discipline of medicine that has yet to grasp the nature of the disorders it treats. This explains why it lacks the power to resist social and political fads claiming to solve the problem of human mental distress.
What he didn’t say was that “biological psychiatry” is one such fad. There is no “biomedical model” to justify it, it doesn’t exist. I often quote Thomas Insel, fmr director of NIMH, who said biological psychiatry is so secure that it can ignore criticism. That’s such a stupid comment but it’s emblematic of the arrogance we’re dealing with. If psychiatry wants to “grasp the nature of the disorders it treats,” then it needs to set out its basic thesis. Nearly 20 years ago [1, Ch. 17], I put the case that the causes of mental disorder, including psychosis, will not be found in the laboratory as they reside in the mental realm. It’s time to look at them again; what follows is really the outline of a much larger chapter.
1. The schizophrenic syndrome. It is indeed a ‘syndrome,’ a recognised collection of signs and symptoms assumed to have a common cause. It’s not a stable collection as there is no sign common or unique to all cases of schizophrenia. Moreover, every sign and every symptom can and commonly does occur in a wide variety of other conditions, including psychotic states, affective disorders, brain disease, drug addictions and personality disorders – and plenty occur in normality, just ask the nice people at QAnon. The idea that there could be a single, unitary “cause” for such diversity, or that there is even a “simple” case, is off to a very bad start.
2. Here, we must pause to ask what is meant by the word “cause”? As a fully-certified and duly reviled dualist, I say there are two forms of causation in the universe. The first is entirely within the physical realm, i.e. matter-energy interactions in the time-space matrix for which the laws of physics (when complete) will give a full account with no questions unanswered. Examples include a rock falling down a hill, the H2O cycle, photosynthesis, putrefaction, nuclear fusion in the sun, digestion, immunity to infection and a fracture healing. In each case, the matter-energy interactions can be traced in huge detail down to the level of subatomic particles.
3. The second form of causation has nothing to do with the laws of physics or subatomic particles. It exists entirely independently of them, subject to its own set of laws which have no points of contact with physics. This is the core of dualism, this is what dualism is and what it means: two sets of laws. It doesn’t mean “two substances,” that’s archaic. Can we think of some nomologically distinct but functional entity operating in its own realm that is significant in daily life? Sure we can, it’s called information. Information is real, insubstantial and unlocalised; it is rule-governed but exempt from the laws of physics, and yet, as we all accept without a moment’s hesitation, it is causally effective. I can send some information to you and, directly and only as a result, cause you to do something else. So information is the second form of causation in the universe. If you want to refute my claim that information is real and effective, you’re in a bind because you have to use information to do it. Even pointing a gun at me to stop me talking is effective only because of the informational content it conveys. The act has meaning above and beyond the physics of bullets hitting heads. But only an individual capable of perceiving information can know that.
4. With that out of the way, we can look at the factors known to be associated with the schizophrenic syndrome. Family history always gets a mention as the early studies were mainly by researchers heavily influenced by the German psychiatrist Ernst Rüdin, architect of the infamous T4 program to kill the mentally-afflicted. They all found a strong family history and assumed that meant it was genetic, so they sterilised the relatives as well. However, for every person with a clear albeit non-Mendelian family history, there are plenty who don’t have that record. Studies restricted to hospital cases were more likely to find a family history; community studies give a different picture, but that’s true of all epidemiological research. Next is male sex then there’s a long tail of factors such as disturbed family background, child abuse and neglect, especially sexual abuse, immigrant status, drug and alcohol abuse, etc. That still leaves a large group who have no obvious contributing factors, usually known as nuclear schizophrenia.
5. There are many examples of symptomatic psychotic states, e.g. 4% of people with closed head injuries will develop the condition and a small proportion with chronic epilepsy. It is common as a phase in progressive brain disorders such as Huntington’s disease (50% of sufferers will first get this diagnosis) but they’re usually later in life. Various intoxications, such as heavy metals or industrial solvents, and metabolic disorders such as Wilson’s disease are regularly implicated. As the reader pointed out, schizophrenia is associated with the rare 22q 11.2 deletion syndrome. This is a spontaneous mutation associated with intellectual handicap and a host of physical problems. About 30% of these people will develop a psychotic state. Again, the chromosomal defect is neither necessary nor sufficient to cause psychosis. It is most important to note that psychotic symptoms occur as a phase in the patient’s decline; they appear, become florid and then, as the disease state progresses, this disappear, leaving only a “burned out” state of chronic brain damage.
6. One group who are routinely overlooked have no family history or drug abuse or head injuries, etc. They are fit and healthy but present with a florid psychotic state purely as a result of psychological stressors. Most will recover as the stressor is relieved but when it doesn’t, they can get trapped in a permanent state of psychosis. Psychiatrists will then nod sagely and say “Ah yes, the stressor uncovered a cryptic diathesis.” This means only a “hidden tendency” and is equivalent to Moliere’s virtus domitiva in opium, i.e. a pseudo-explanation. The rational explanation is that the stress response caused high arousal which resulted in sleep deprivation which caused hallucinatory experiences which pushed the arousal level higher in a self-reinforcing cycle, leading to the appearance of abnormal beliefs as an attempt to explain the distress. To make it worse, the beliefs themselves can produce further arousal.
7. Any attempt to account for schizophrenia as a biological disorder has a real problem: there are hundreds of physical and genetic factors involved, so how can they be incorporated in a single model? They can’t. It gets worse when childhood trauma is included because that doesn’t affect the DNA. Aha, say the geneticists, childhood trauma must have an epigenetic effect, which means the DNA is somehow tied together so it can’t be expressed normally. That’s irrefutable, a classic example of what philosopher Karl Popper called “immunising a theory against refutation,” i.e. making a series of small changes to try to account for objections.
8. Bearing in mind that the simplest explanation is to be preferred, we can tie all these together by saying that psychotic symptoms occur as a phase in a failing mind. The symptoms are generated psychologically, when the level of psychological arousal gets too high, i.e. it exceeds the normal limits, OR the limits of mental function are too narrow. They can be restricted by progressive brain disease or by personality factors stemming from childhood. In a dementing condition, the psychosis will appear for a while and then gradually fade out as the disease progresses and mental function becomes more impoverished.
9. People with an acute psychotic state are highly aroused. Traditionally, the explanation has been that the psychotic symptoms cause the arousal, but that still leaves the problem of explaining the cause of the psychosis. “That’s biology,” exclaim the mainstream psychiatrists but two problems persist: they have no theory or model to justify the belief, and no solid evidence to support it.
10. I suggest we resolve the problem by turning it around: in a healthy brain, the phenomenon of high arousal is sufficient to cause psychotic symptoms. The arousal comes from a sense that something is wrong in life, something doesn’t feel right, the individual feels different, alienated and searching for answers. This is much more likely in people from disturbed backgrounds, especially those subject to childhood abuse and neglect, to people who have been forced to move to a different culture, and so on. But that’s still not enough. That won’t explain why the person’s distress reaches overwhelming levels. The answer is something common to all psychotic states: lack of insight. Distress builds up and up just because the person won’t accept there is something mentally wrong. This also helps explain why people are so keen to accept the “chemical imbalance” notion: it fits neatly with their preference, which is to say: “There’s nothing wrong with me, it’s the aliens trying to influence me.” All of this presupposes an integrative theory of mind and body, such as the biocognitive model.
11. The search for a single biological cause for psychotic states is a complete waste of time and money. Look at all the people who stormed the US Capitol in 2021: they believed some real crazy stuff but did they all have the same brain failing? No, they were just idiots who wanted to believe they were right and everybody else was wrong. That’s wholly a psychological state, a personality defect, not a chemical imbalance, and it points to a real problem: how do we tell the difference between a person who simply believes any bit of nonsense that comes his way and somebody genuinely developing a psychotic state? It’s very difficult, every case is different in details but the principle is the same: something is pushing this person over his limits. It may be physical, like stimulant drugs, it may be purely psychological or it may be a combination, that has to be worked out by taking a very detailed history and trying to understand his world from his side.
****
That’s the barest outline of how we should see psychotic states as psychological reactions to complex life events. Sometimes the events are in the present, sometimes in the distant past; some of them are physical matters impairing the brain’s capacity to do its job of generating the informational state we call the mind, and some are wholly psychological pressures that have the same effect. Sometimes the pressures are entirely external and sometimes the limiting factors are internal, a matter of personality, so that the impact of relatively minor external pressures is exaggerated. The important point is that all of these factors are self-amplifying so that what seemed manageable quickly spins out of control.
Yes, this type of multifactorial model is quite complex but psychiatry has tried all the simple ones and they didn’t work. In particular, the sort of crude, linear thinking that dominates psychiatry today, as in “One gene defect produces one discrete mental disorder for which there is one effective drug,” has to be replaced with a complex interactive and recursive model, where pathogenic factors have a range of self-amplifying effects. Once it starts, if all goes well and the person is able to settle, we call it a psychogenic or schizophreniform or manic psychosis; if things go bad and the person becomes trapped in a self-sustaining state of extreme mental distress, we call that schizophrenia. The value of this approach is that it can pull the huge range of contributing factors into a single model. The reductive biological approach requires dozens, if not hundreds of unrelated models. That’s enough reason to discard it.
The trouble is that the people who are pushing biological psychiatry, who believe it’s beyond criticism, are unable to grasp the notion that mental events, such as mental disorder, have mental causes. They have to think outside their self-imposed limits. When they say things like “It’s impossible for psychological factors to produce the grotesque deterioration of schizophrenia,” they should remember that’s just an opinion. History drips with examples of when Great Men got it completely wrong. For all his brilliance, the physicist Lord Kelvin (1824-1907), missed a few important buses. For example, in about 1890, he decided that the theory of evolution couldn’t be right because the sun would have burned out in the time span Darwin needed to account for speciation. However, he assumed the sun was made of coal. I don’t know that he ever offered an explanation of how it got up there. In 1895, he said that heavier than air flying machines are impossible and in 1902, pronounced: “There is nothing new to be discovered in physics now. All that remains is more and more precise measurement.” Then along came relativity.
We can’t expect older psychiatrists who have devoted their lives to biology to understand something as slippery as psychology but once they die out, the rising generation should be able to cope.
Reference:
McLaren N (2007). Chapter 17 in Humanizing Madness: Psychiatry and the Cognitive Neurosciences.; Ann Arbor, Mi.: Future Psychiatry Press.
****
My critical works are best approached in this order:
The case against mainstream psychiatry:
McLaren N (2024). Theories in Psychiatry: building a post-positivist psychiatry. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press. (this also covers a range of modern philosophers, showing that their work cannot be extended to account for mental disorder).
Development and justification of the biocognitive model:
McLaren N (2021): Natural Dualism and Mental Disorder: The biocognitive model for psychiatry. London, Routledge
Clinical application of the biocognitive model:
McLaren N (2018). Anxiety: The Inside Story. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
Testing the biocognitive model in an unrelated field:
McLaren N (2023): Narcisso-Fascism: The psychopathology of right wing extremism. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
The whole of this work is copyright but may be copied or retransmitted provided the author is acknowledged.

- good to see Psychology getting an honourable mention in relation to psychiatry
- Bringing the 20 year-old philosophy forward was a very good move. It is utterly excellent.