I will be giving a talk on Zoom later this week, on the topic "Can there be a biological psychiatry?" My conclusion: No, there is not, never has been, and never will be, a formal explanatory model of mental disorder as the result of disordered biology. In my view, the belief that there can be such a model, that we should continue spending billions each year on it even though it has never yielded a single remotely interesting bit of supportive evidence, is an urban myth. What's a myth? A myth is a widely held false belief that purports to explain the hidden causes of some thing or event in familiar terms. Among the wealthy, educated classes of the West, it is widely held that only children and primitives hang on to myths but this belief is itself a myth.
In order to distinguish between children and primitives, who don't have the education, resources or good sense to know better and much prefer to believe fairy stories, and the wealthy, educated classes of the West, who have the education and time and resources to know better, but who prefer to believe their own fairy stories, somebody had the bright idea of labeling the latter as "urban myths." An urban myth is a false belief held by wealthy, educated people that purports to explain the hidden causes of some thing or event in familiar terms. However, if they made the effort to look into their precious beliefs, they would find out that, quel horreur, they're a load of self-serving tosh.
The (very) English linguist and philosopher, Gilbert Ryle (1900-1976), said: "A myth is not a fairy story. It is the presentation of facts belonging to one category in the idioms of another. To explode a myth is not to deny the facts but to reallocate them." What he meant was that myths are not fantasies. People look at something and say "Oh, that must be caused by X" when, in fact, it's caused by Y, but they're happy with thinking it's X because it fits with what they know or believe, and they don't know enough about Y to realise it's actually a better explanation.
For example, say a tree dies in the garden. "Yes," they tell each other, "that's because the tree's nymph moved to another place, so the tree died." That satisfies them because they believe in nymphs and sprites and spells and all that stuff, whereas we (clever, sophisticated people) know the tree was damaged by a storm and a fungus moved in and killed it. In formal terms, a myth is a category error, which Ryle defined as: "Properties or entities belonging to one category are presented as though they belong to another category." So instead of being put in the category of "natural events," the death of the tree by a fungus is incorrectly put in the category of "supernatural events."
On February 13th, I reported on an interview published on ABC where the eminent psychiatrist, Prof. Ian Hickie, of the University of Sydney, was asked about depression. It is a biological disease, he said, people may think it has a psychological cause but they're wrong, as he explained:
Hickie: ... you are depressed. That's why you're having trouble with intimate relationships, kids, work, finances ...
Interviewer: ...it's not that your work stress is causing your depression. You're having issues at work because you're depressed ... a lot of people do think that depression is caused by life events.
Hickie: This is the number one myth ... The depression came first ... (but the crisis in life) is not the cause (of the depression), it's the consequence.
He emphasises this point later: "And for most people, (childhood) is not the cause (of adult depression) ... Let's stop blaming your mum." He specifically states that, as a biological disease, depression must be treated with physical measures such as drugs and ECT to prevent further brain damage:
Hickie: ... Now we have evidence of depression as a risk factor to dementia, so treating depression helps to reduce the risk of dementia because in truth there is a physiology and a damaging one. There's stuff going on there neurobiologically during depression, which is bad for your brain. It doesn't just feel bad or look bad, it is bad ... episodes of depression do end, but they often do great damage (to the brain).
Fortunately, we have all these wonderful treatments available today so nobody should go without. The good news, he says, is that as prescription rates for antidepressants and ECT go up, " ... suicide in the populations and suicide attempts go down."
My view is that all of this is an urban myth, a false belief held by wealthy, educated people that purports to explain the hidden causes of some observable phenomenon in familiar terms, and could be exposed if they troubled themselves to learn the truth. The truth, as I mentioned a few weeks ago, and despite 16% of the adult population taking antidepressants and our notoriously high usage of ECT [1], is that suicide rates in Australia are going back up again. Meanwhile, over in the Good Ol' US of A, which is awash with psychiatric drugs, suicide rates are rising remorselessly [2] and have recently hit an 80 year high. How come Hickie doesn't know this? I don't know, you'd have to ask him. I did, and didn't get a response.
This matters, because a study from the University of Sydney tried to sort out whether childhood maltreatment contributed to some categories of adult mental disorder [3]. The researchers' objective was to "determine the contribution of child maltreatment to mental health conditions in Australia, accounting for genetic and environmental confounding." Maltreatment was defined as "Physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, or neglect prior to age 18 years." In a sense, one wonders why they bothered because if you take a proper history, the information is all there. Anyway, after some nifty statistical maneuvering, they concluded: "Childhood maltreatment accounted for a substantial proportion of mental health conditions, ranging from 21% for depression to 41% of suicide attempts."
Compare this with Hickie's claim that depression is an organic disease of the brain that has practically nothing to do with early life experiences. If that's true, then we don't need to worry so much about what's happening on the other side of the world. Catherine Russell, director of UNICEF, published a short video last week on the situation in Gaza in which she said:
Nearly all of the some 600,000 children now crammed into Rafah are either injured, sick, malnourished, traumatised, or living with disabilities. Many have been displaced multiple times and have lost homes, parents and loved ones. There is nowhere safe to go in Gaza ... The violence must end. The children of Gaza need a ceasefire (starts at 0.25).
First thing to note: UNICEF has 714,000 subscribers on YouTube but the video has knocked up only 685 views in 11 days, which says YouTube is not promoting it (or is actively suppressing it). Second, if Hickie is correct, that life events have little or nothing to do with mental disorder, then YouTube is doing the right thing: Dr Russell is simply being alarmist and Israel should be allowed to get on with its war without interference because the kids will be just fine, unless they had bad genetics, in which case there are lots of nice drugs that will get them over seeing their homes and families and legs blown to bits. However, Dr Russell is no fool. She is highly qualified for the post, and is not making heaps of money out of presenting this view. In fact, she's probably being deluged by people who want her kicked out of her job for taking the side of the Palestinians.
On the other hand, the whole "mental disorder is brain disorder" could be just an urban myth, put about by wealthy, educated people who have never had any trouble in their lives and who are, quite by chance, making heaps of money out of pushing a line that profits drug companies. But the one thing you won't see is a proper debate over the question of nature vs. nurture, whether mental disorder is due to bad genes or is the predictable result of bad experiences. That would be too shocking to a lot of very influential people who have built their careers and their fortunes on spreading the idea that mental disorder is due to bad chemicals in your head, and they have just the cure. They are reassured by none other than Thomas Insel, former director of NIMH who said:
"… the biological model (of mental disorder) is sufficiently entrenched to ignore criticism and commit psychiatry to a new reductionist program ... " [4]. That says to them: "Don't trouble yourselves over whether you may be wrong, just stick with what feels right for you." That's exactly how urban myths start and propagate and persist.
So are psychiatrists immune to urban myths? You're kidding.
PS. If all goes well, I will post the lecture on this file in a week or so.
****
There are four chapters left in Part II of Theories in Psychiatry: Building a Post-Positivist Psychiatry, two on philosophers and two to conclude. Professional philosophers may look askance at the next two, on Richard Carrier and Thomas Nagel, asking "Why are they together?" In fact, they're not together, any more than if they were in alphabetical order, but they help illustrate the point mentioned in last week's post: that people who accept the reality of mind and then go forward, trying to work out what it does, are handicapped. The historian and naturalist philosopher, Richard Carrier, tries to go back to offer an explanation of how mind arises, although it goes nowhere. He falls into the same trap as Daniel Dennett (see Substack April 9th).
Richard Carrier is very much alive and making a splash, although he came to philosophy rather late via his interest in the history of religions. He is avowedly atheistic and shares Ryle's and Dennett's contempt for disembodied ghosts. Carrier makes his position crystal clear: the mind can be reduced to a matter of physical particles governed by the laws of physics "and nothing more." In fact, he says that so often that I wonder what he's trying to hide. That becomes clear at the end: what does he rely on to complete his causally-effective chain between atoms in the head and listening to a song you once liked? Just like Dennett, he needs a virtual machine called the mind which has all the properties of a disembodied ghost. Good try, sir, but do not pass Go.
Finally, Thomas Nagel, again famous for one short paper from 1974, early in his long career, called simply What is it like to be a bat? Answer: he isn't sure but it isn't like being a human forced to hang upside down in a belfry, crawling with fleas and piddling down one's face all day. In this paper, he offered an account of the fact of consciousness which has been taken up by lots of philosophers, including David Chalmers: "... fundamentally an organism has conscious mental states if and only if there is something that it is like to be that organism - something it is like for the organism." That goes back to John Searle's definition of consciousness, that it's what being unconscious is not, and is not, in my view, much help. Neither of them. He also thinks that science will answer the Big Question of the nature of mind but not science as we know it. Refreshingly, he says the concept of "...science will have to expand to accommodate facts of a kind fundamentally different from those that physics is designed to explain." I agree totally, but my case is that this has already happened, the new concept of information sciences has done what he wanted. We'll have to wait and see what emerges.
So ends our quick buzz around some of the most influential philosophers of the past hundred years. From the point of view of the mentally-troubled, they're rather a thin show. Next week, a summary and some recommendations.
****
References:
1. McLaren N (2017). Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Critical Perspective. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 19: 91-104. DOI: 10.1891/1559-4343.19.2.91
2. Amendola, S., Plöderl, M., & Hengartner, M. P. (2024, February 14). Suicide Rates and
Prescription of Antidepressants: Trends in the United States, 1999–2020, by Sex and Race/
Ethnicity. Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention and Suicide Prevention. Advance online
publication. https://dx.doi.org/10.1027/0227-5910/a000941
3. Grummit L et al (2024). Burden of Mental Disorders and Suicide Attributable to Childhood Maltreatment. JAMA Psychiatry,published online, at:
JAMA Psychiatry. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2024.0804
****
The whole of this material is copyright but can be copied or quoted provided the author is acknowledged.

Can the talk be attended "live"?