Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gnuneo's avatar

"Any System that can be gamed, will be gamed" - I'm sure some clever wordsmith has already created that aphorism at some point.

The 'gaming' in this instance is allowing private profit from ECT therapy in Oz.

If people can make profit from a legal act, then morality will not apply for the majority. Many will still do it even if it was made illegal - so keeping such tortures legal is just asking for trouble.

Carolyn Quadrio's avatar

Thanks, Niall, I completely agree with you, and with the team of Read et al. I have commented here before that I have never used ECT in my practice. I have also visited facilities in Italy, where ECT is mostly banned, and they seem to manage very well without it, and that includes a forensic unit and a long-term residential unit for people with chronic mental illness.

6 more comments...

Ready for more?