Introducing Narcisso-Fascism.
Welcome to Post No. 1 on the concepts driving humanity's headlong rush to damnation. This Substack is built around the book, illustrated above, which was published in July 2023. It would help readers to be familiar with it, it's not difficult reading. Comments and questions are welcome but should be restricted to the material in this column or in the book. Keep them brief (nobody reads long comments, including me), original (i.e. not repetitious rants) and to the point.
***
Something this morning reminded me of Bertrand Russell, who loathed nuclear weapons. In 1946, in an article published in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, he said:
If any of the things that we value are to survive, the problem (of nuclear weapons) must be solved. How it can be solved is clear; the difficulty is to persuade the human race to acquiesce in its own survival. I cannot believe that this task is impossible.
Well, nearly 80 years later, it's worse. Very, very much worse, and we have to know why, because it's starting to look as though Russell got it wrong: maybe it is impossible, after all. In 1946, there was only one existential threat to humanity, these weapons. A year after World War II ended, the fear was that another war would erupt and the belligerents would go nuclear from the outset to prevent a war of attrition. Now, we have two: militarism and climate change.
I'm satisfied that the evidence for anthropogenic climate is now irrebuttable. Only fools and capitalists think otherwise, but let me make my position clear:
There will be no solution to the climate crisis until we have controlled militarism.
The forces producing destruction of the natural environment by climate change are exactly the same as those driving militarism, only hidden behind a façade of beneficial free market capitalism. Uncontrolled neoliberal capitalism (which includes consumerism) and militarism are intimatly related: armies are simply the enforcers of monopoly capitalism. So what drives this? The driving force is what this Substack is about: the combination of the narcissistic trait in our personality structure, what we can call the fascist political technology, and the biologically-based human drive to be top of the pile. Three different and seemingly unrelated parts of the human animal that come together to produce impending catastrophe. Understanding them is the first step toward dismantling the juggernaut that is hurtling toward the cliff edge.
It is important to understand that the modern notion of "personality disorders" put about by the American Psychiatric Association is absolute rubbish. There is no such thing as a "category" of personality disorder, e.g. narcissistic personality, sociopathic, borderline, etc. These are just labels stuck on people so the psychiatrist doesn't have to think too much about what's actually going on with them. In fact, their diagnostic system is so bad that they were going to drop it for the latest version of their Diagnostic Manual (DSM5) but it was too difficult for the poor dears and also would have shown up the faults in the rest of their system, so they stuck with pretending it's science. It's not.
The alternative model is what's called a dimensional model, which says that all human behaviour can be classified along a series of axes or dimensions, such as narcissism. It says we all have the urge to be the centre of attention, it's just a question of how strong that urge is, and what form it takes. Some people don't like attention, others can't get enough, but it's all a matter of degree. Same with obsessionality: the idea of an "Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder" is so crude: we're all obsessional to some degree or other, we have to be or we wouldn't get anything done, we'd spend all day looking for the tools we need. Where are the knives and forks in your house now? Answer: Where they should be, so you can find them for breakfast. It's tax time, have you got all your documents ready? Where are your car keys? For that matter, where's the car? Is it serviced and ready to go, tyres inflated and so on? A degree of obsessionality is essential for survival, but it can get out of control and take over a person's life. And we've all got a narcissistic streak, but it needs to be kept under control.
Same goes for the drive to dominate and control people. We can run a little experiment. We'll take one square kilometre of fertile land, with some bush and creeks and pasture and so on, and at dawn on the first day of the experiment, we put one hundred people on it, spread around at one per hectare (that's 2.5ac). They'll have supplies and tools and camping gear and some fishing lines and so on. Where will they be at sunset on Day 1? They will have formed little groups, probably about a dozen people in each, and they'll be setting up little communities, maybe playing a bit of football or having a singalong before they go to bed. What happens next? The next thing is they will form dominance hierarchies within their groups. That's biological, that is going to happen. Sure, they'll dress it up with some nice justification but you can be sure of one thing: What they won't form is a harmonious, productive group with no power structure.
Soon, a footy match will turn into a squabble, or one group will decide they need better access to the water, or they'll feel that another group isn't treating them with respect, and the squabbles will turn into push and shove and before long, they'll be glaring at each other across palisades and then the rocks will fly, followed by spears and arrows. That is inevitable. There has never been a day in human history when it didn't happen, just because humans are hierarchical animals. And it's all based around the testosterone economy, so it's not going to change. The best we can hope for is to understand it and bring it under control, because now, our survival depends on it.
The point about hierarchies is that the people who get to the top want to be there, they work long and hard for it, and they don't want anybody to displace them. They get very suspicious of whoever's coming up through the ranks, so their first action is to kick away the ladders they used to get to the top. Paranoid thinking and dominance go hand in hand. Whatever it is they're top of, they will want more of it, and more and more, and they also want their underlings to have less. As Gore Vidal (cousin of Al Gore) said: "Success is not enough. One's friends must also fail." Finally, they will start to believe they're justified in what they've got, and they feel fully entitled to taking everybody else’s share. The higher they get up the ladder, the more grow their sense of privilege and the insatiable desire for more. These are not foibles due to bad potty-training in children, these are hard-wired into the species.
We had a little demonstration of this a few weeks ago when some rich peanut gave a talk to a forum organised by the Australian Financial Review. A Mr Timothy Gurner, aged 41 and worth $929million, said workers have grown lazy and the unemployment rate needs to go right up so they feel the screws and get back to work for reasonable pay. Tim who? Apparently, he got a bequest of $34,000 from his grandfather at age 20, then managed to borrow a six-figure sum from his employer, and started developing high end properties. He is associated with the wealthy Liberman family and Harry Triguboff, who founded Meriton Properties. Jon Schwartz of The Intercept gives more details.
Now you would think that somebody who went from $34,000 to $930million in a quarter of a lifetime would be happy with that but no, not at all. How did he get it? From screwing the arms of his workers, and the suppliers, and the people who buy his stuff, and everybody. About $920million of his fortune should have gone to them but he snaffled it. Now he wants more, and he wants his workers to have less. Because humans.
Gurner is this week's Exhibit A in the rogues' gallery of greedy capitalists who are constitutionally incapable of knowing when enough is enough. You don't make that sort of money in that time by being fair and reasonable. Talking of fair and reasonable, I see Mr Bezos and Amazon are being sued by the Federal Trade Commission and no less than 17 states for using "unfair and illegal tactics to maintain its power" (NYT, 27.09.2023). If you want to see what a petty-minded and wantonly brutal arsehole he is in his private life, see this.
People who get to the top have no scruples how they get there and, once there, they will do anything to smash the competition so they can stay there. This is true of individuals and of collections of individuals, ranging up to nations. Nation-states and religions are just individual humans writ large.
People say "Oh, but you're painting such a gloomy picture of humans, what about creativity, compassion, altruism...?" Yeah, what about it? Creativity, compassion and altruism are not driving us to destruction. It's the bad bits that are doing the damage, and that's what this column will be about. You want nice, turn on the Teletubbies.
***
Another picture. An Eastern King parrot who drops in some mornings for a bit of corn:
He has no control over what happens to the environment.
We're destroying it for him and his kind.



Don't know if there is a time limit for asking questions:
1. Can people with high narcissism be helped in terms of their personality to become less narcissistic? Did you ever treat such people?
2. Does modern technology increase narcissistic personality disorder rates? For example, mobile phones and selfies etc?
❤️🙏🏽Nice wrap. I was thinking ‘what about’ at the end! Guys like you are the other end of the human spectrum. Thanks for reminding me that integrity, humaneness and a handful of other virtues, while rare, does walk amongst us. They seem to be fading ideals in a society with a confused idea of what ‘winning’ looks like!