This week has been a very "ADHD" week. Submissions for the Parliamentary enquiry into Assessment and Support Services for People with ADHD close on June 9th (the terms of reference are here) so I have been busy finalising my effort. And, like all these things, it grew. Other members of the Critical Psychiatry Network of Australia (CPNA) will be focussing on the vague diagnostic boundaries, the misleading statistics of this "disorder" and risks of drug treatment. My approach is to question the entire basis of assuming that we can classify some behaviour as normal and some as "sick" where Sick = Genetically-Determined Brain Disorder = Drug Treatment.
As always, it's necessary to deal with the critics before they start squealing, and the most common complaint is that any (and all) criticism of psychiatry should be ignored because the critic is "anti-psychiatry." This is what is called the genetic fallacy, the idea that the truth of some information depends on who provides it. So when they don't like the message, critics try to shoot the messenger, also known as ad hominum attack, going for the person (for an appalling example of how the ADHD industry attacks critics, see [1]). The expression "anti-psychiatry" comes from the 1970s, and is permanently tied to the psychiatrist and author, Thomas Szasz (1920-2012), who spent most of his career at bucolic Upstate University of NY, at Syracuse, NY.
Szasz always insisted that he wasn't an "anti-psychiatrist" as he was a psychiatrist, but he published a torrent of material over nearly fifty years arguing that there is no such thing as mental illness, that psychiatric patients and psychiatrists are engaged in a massive fraud, and that psychiatrists fill the role of the witch hunters of medieval life. He was a relentless self-publicist and thoroughly enjoyed his public role of provoking rage and hurling it back, with interest. He was a committed libertarian, meaning all governments are automatically bad, and his approach to psychiatry has to be seen through this political lens. People who knew him worshipped the ground he walked on and (still) react badly to even the slightest criticism of his views. There was, however, a dark side to him, that anybody who questioned him in any way got the flick. Immediately.
I first heard him speak in July, 1977, in my final year of training, had a few emails at some stage and met him once very briefly, not long before his death. Perhaps ten years ago, I read several thousand pages of his vast output in order to write two chapters for one of my books [2], but I was totally unconvinced by his arguments. His case was that there is no such thing as "mental illness" because "illness" means physical disease of the body, and there is no evidence of physical disease of the body in mental illness; therefore, the patients are lying to the doctors and the doctors are engaged in a massive conspiracy to keep themselves in cushy jobs by locking up social nuisances to keep in sweet with the authorities. Patients who complain of mental distress either have problems of living, which can be solved with a friendly chat, or a formal brain disease (e.g. schizophrenia) or they're scammers. Soldiers, for example, who complain of mental symptoms are only trying to get out of their duty while veterans who claim pensions are fraudsters.
From this came the idea of "anti-psychiatry," variously interpreted as:
"denies there is mental disorder," or ...
"believes mental disorder is a real brain disorder but psychiatrists don't know what they're doing," or ...
"mental disorder is wholly psychological; psychiatric drugs are dangerous and destructive to mental and physical health and psychiatrists don't know what they're doing," or ...
"mental disorder is wholly a reaction to a toxic society and psychiatrists are part of it because they don't know what they're doing."
There are various combinations of these views but, for mainstream psychiatry, if you say anything negative, you're a bad critic and you must be ignored and/or attacked. Has there, in their view, ever been a good critic? No, all critics are ipso facto bad. When the previous UN Rapporteur on the Rights of the Mentally Ill, Prof. (of psychiatry) Dainius Puras, of Lithuania, published his final report in 2019, he (mildly) suggested there is an excessive reliance on drugs and detention throughout the world, and psychiatry needs to consider social factors and social responses. The reaction was swift and vicious. He was accused of pandering to the "global anti-psychiatry movement" and encouraging the "creeping demedicalisation of psychiatry." When I published an article defending his views, I was accused of being "dangerous ... biased ... anti-psychiatry" and so on [3, this cites the earlier articles]. When I objected to this infantile character assassination, the editor dismissed my complaint as it was just "robust scientific debate." So that's a bit of background, now back to ADHD.
There is a group called the Australian ADHD Professionals Association (AAPA), consisting of psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers and various others. Last year, they released what they called the Australian evidence-based clinical practice guideline for ADHD, a 200 page booklet outlining their position (available here). Professionally put together, it represents thousands of hours of work and a great deal of money. I'm sure a lot of people will be impressed by it, including the people in Parliament and government who make the decisions. That is its purpose, to sway public opinion into believing that a) ADHD is a real genetic brain disease, b) it is very common, c) left untreated, it leads to serious or even catastrophic consequences, but d) psychiatrists to the rescue, there are drugs available, all we have to do is screen lots of people to find the cases and start the tablets, and e) there should be all sorts of new services and benefits for sufferers, sorry, people living with ADHD (there's a section on p68 which tells you how to think and talk).
How many people? Well, it seems they're aiming to have 10% of the population on their drugs in fairly short order. To me, this is very strange, because it's not that long ago that this "condition" didn't exist. Well, not where I come from. As a member of the baby boom in the 1950s and 60s, I attended state schools in a small regional port which also held the district high school of about 1000 students. Having lived there most of my life, and especially after having worked as a postman, I knew practically every child and every family at that school. It was not a "nice town": when I went to university, I was mocked for my lack of savoir faire (but not for long).
I can state with absolute certainty that in my twelve years of school, I never once saw a child exhibit the type of behaviour which is now labelled "ADHD." There were 45-48 children in each class and, of necessity, teachers maintained tight discipline. Each child had a set desk and no child stood up and walked around without permission as there was no need, everything was in the desk. No child spoke out of turn or annoyed the surrounding children or, god forbid, answered the teacher back. Teachers walked up and down the aisles checking work so children couldn't and didn't sit there daydreaming.
At any school, there were good children and naughty children; bold children and shy children; there were children who liked school and plenty who didn't, who left the day they were old enough; they got jobs and they were fine. For some, school was a relief from their home lives while not a few regarded it as a form of low-grade torture. There were broken families, and fostered children; children of alcoholic fathers or whose fathers who were in prison, and some mothers we knew went to the port to meet sailors, especially when naval ships were in. There were clean and tidy children in shoes and neatly-ironed clothes, and scruffy, barefoot kids with bad teeth, ringworms and nits who slept in their clothes; bright children and children who would now be in special classes but, just as there was no obesity in those distant days, there was no ADHD.
While schools and models of teaching have changed dramatically over the past decades, there is not the slightest doubt in my mind that the diagnostic category of ADHD is a fad. Some neutral person needs to study this issue carefully, to ensure that the "epidemic" of ADHD is not being caused by the secular combination of trends in modern teaching, by a biological and venal psychiatry financed by drug companies to create more diagnoses, by parenting within the nuclear family and other, broader social changes. Except, as the example in [1] shows, and I can confirm, if you dare to criticise mainstream psychiatry, you can expect the very demons of hell to land on your shoulders and start clawing.
While the AAPA Guidelines looks terribly scientific, it is actually little more than propaganda because the complaint above ("psychiatrists don't know what they're doing") is true. When it comes to labelling the behaviour of children, adolescents and now adults as "deviant/sick," psychiatrists genuinely don't know what they're doing. How do we know this? The proof is in their Guidelines: they don't have a model of mental disorder. That's the polite way of saying "Without a model of your topic to tell you what is evidence and what is noise, all you're doing is groping in the dark." But the people in Parliament and government can't read this thing and know what's missing, which means it's very subtle propaganda.
So a small group of true-believing psychiatrists with no model of mental disorder want to put 10% of the population on dangerous and addictive drugs - for life. That makes the wave of lobotomies in the 1950s and 60s look like small bickies indeed.
1. Watson, GL, Arcona AP, Antonuccio AP, Healy D (2014). Shooting the Messenger: The Case of ADHD J Contemp Psychother (2014) 44:43–52. DOI 10.1007/s10879-013-9244-x
2. McLaren N (2012) A critical review of Thomas Szasz. Chaps 12-13 in The Mind-Body Problem Explained: The Biocognitive Model for Psychiatry. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
3. McLaren N (2020). Commentary: Criticising psychiatry is still not "antipsychiatry." Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry. https://doi.org/10.1177/0004867419887797
