The posting from March 28th asks "What does sham treatment tell us?" That article was based on a report from the US Veterans' Administration health system about comparing transcranial magnetic stimulation (TCMS) for "treatment resistant depression" with no treatment. The patients were mostly white, older (mean age 55yrs), 75% unemployed and about half had problems with drugs and alcohol. Normally, that would be seen as a recipe for depression but if you believe depression is a brain disease that can strike anybody, anywhere, anywhen, then life factors are irrelevant.
The patients were divided in two groups; half got the real TCMS and the rest went through the procedure but the machines weren't switched on. They found that after the "treatment," 40% of each group were better and remained that way during follow-up. That is, the treatment was useless. The researchers thought that "non-specific factors" may have been at work, meaning all the interviews, regular checks, lots of nice people asking how the patients were going, etc. In other words, it was the patients' expectations that they would get better that did the trick, better known as the placebo effect. That reminded me of the old form of "treatment" known as insulin coma therapy, so I wrote to the researchers to point this out and ask their comments. No response, of course.
But a new paper from Germany published on July 3rd has stirred the pot [1]. This was a well-organised study of yet another form of "brain stimulation" known as transcranial direct current stimulation (TCdcS), in which a tiny current (2mA) is trickled through the head, from one temple to the other for half an hour a day. Patients were already taking antidepressants as the researchers wanted to know if the TCdcS would make any difference. They had 24 sessions over six weeks, twice as much as usual, because the researchers expected it to make any changes more obvious. Patients were 60% female (of course) and mean age 40, which is fairly young for this sort of study.
After six weeks, the sham treatment group reported somewhat better outcomes than the treatment group although the difference was not statistically significant. Undeterred, they felt it would be a good idea to try to work out which group was likely to respond beforehand, so they didn't waste time taking tablets that weren't going to work.
This provoked the journal to publish an editorial which said that there were lots of studies showing TCdcS is effective in treating depression [2], although they admitted a similar, large scale study had also found it had no effect. The studies that reported good outcomes included patients with mild and brief states of depression, whom we know are most likely to get better anyway. The German study was directed at the group who were not responding to standard treatment, meaning drugs, but still a third or more of them got better in each group.
However, as far as treatment goes, there is an advantage to DC stimulation of the brain: cost. It costs next to nothing and can be done at home using a gizmo about the size of a phone, with two leads, one for each ear lobe. People can sit at home and get their daily tickle, or even go to the shops and nobody would know they're mental. It gives about the same results at transcranial magnetic stimulation (about $7200 for a course) or 12 shots of ECT as an inpatient (about $60,000) with none of the inconvenience of driving to hospital, parking and hanging around while the staff get organised.
What does all this add up to? It says that if you decide to study the antidepressant effects of, say, honey, and you include in your study lots of people who are likely to get back to normal anyway, then you will "prove" that honey is an effective antidepressant. But hang on, surely the control group should make it clear whether the honey worked or not? Ah, no, because the control group doesn't consist of people who get no treatment at all, it consists of people on antidepressants which are "known" to be effective. The trial doesn't compare treatment with no treatment, it compares antidepressants to antidepressants + honey. In the TCdcS study, it was antidepressants alone compared with antidepressants + DC stimulation. That gets rid of the placebo effect, the fact that people on no treatment get back to normal at almost the same rate as antidepressants, about 60% compared with 63%. It is rapidly reaching the point where psychiatric research can no longer be taken at face value.
But it gets worse, because people don't put 2 and 2 together. A sorely neglected area of research in mental trouble concerns such elementary matters as lifestyle, including diet and exercise. Our good friends at Psychiatric Times have published a lengthy interview with an academic physiotherapist who studies the effects of exercise on mental states. To nobody's surprise, he finds that regular exercise is very effective in lfiting moods.
This is not your average suburban group of people with the miseries, it is mainly directed at long-term patients of mental health services. In the main, they have lost their lives. After years of going in and out of hospitals and barrowloads of psychiatric drugs, most of them have gained massive amounts of weight, sometimes even doubling their original weight. They have lost contact with any friends, have no hobbies or sports, and are too lethargic from the drugs to do anything requiring concentration. Unless they are actively involved in programs, they will simply sit and stare at the wall, smoking and eating and drinking cola. Not surprisingly, they die young. In Australia, people on long-term psychiatric drugs will die on average 19 years younger than their undrugged peers [3].
In the US, where it is normal to prescribe more drugs in larger doses, that figure is 25 years. That's a lot of life to lose, between a quarter and a third of your allotted span. For most of them, they had no choice in the drugs, they were involuntary patients who were being treated to ... to what? Well, we don't actually know. Mental health acts don't say why people must undergo involuntary treatment, only that it will happen. But that's a separate issue. The question here is simple: we have long known that regular, steady exercise is the most powerful anti-ageing factor known. It is established fact that regular exercise, preferably starting in middle age, has a powerful effect in preventing or delaying Alzheimer's Disease and other dementias. Regular brain exercises like crosswords, reading, chess, quizzes and Sudoku are also valuable. The worst thing for people with early cognitive decline is to put them in a room where everything is done for them, with no challenges, no exercise and no social interaction but the idiot box.
This is a bit surprising because anybody who follows the research literature or the Women's Weekly will know that there is an enormous program to find a drug to treat Alzheimer's. I don't know how much is being spent on this, perhaps a billion a year, but the results are very scratchy. The drugs that have been approved are hugely expensive and cause a lot of side effects. They are directed at reducing inflammation in the brain caused by the abnormal proteins that are deposited in Alzheimer's- type dementia. But exercise does that, too. It affects the immune system and inflammatory markers, although the details are not known.
Depression is a reaction to life events. It is a real thing so it needs a real program when a remedy is needed. First step should be talking, not straight to drugs, followed by (if it's needed) home DC stimulation, followed by out-patient stimulation, then maybe magnetic stimulation, then maybe drugs and finally ECT in hospital, when all else fails. But it doesn't fail. I never used ECT and most of the time, I was working alone under difficult conditions. Psychiatrists use ECT because they like the idea of doing something, and because it pays so well. All the talk of ECT being "essential" and "life-saving" is just that: hollow talk.
"But the talking cure is so expensive," the bean counters will complain, "psychologists don’t grow on trees. A prescription is much cheaper." So it is, but how much is a year of life worth? If the drugs cause obesity which leads to diabetes and then to all its complications, what does that cost? We don't know, it would take a while to cost the different forms of treatment but if the government can work out that the AUKUS nuclear submarines are going to cost $368billion over fifty years, they can work out the costs of losing a leg to diabetes.
If exercise works in mental troubles, which it does, why is it that a billion dollars a year is not being spent on studying the effects of exercise on brain health? We know that exercise has a strong feel-good effect, but the answer is because there's no profit in it. There's also very little kudos for academics: they're simply not interested because it challenges the received view. The interest to study the effects of exercise on mental health mentioned above does not come from psychiatrists. The researcher is a physiotherapist. Very few psychiatrists would have any interest at all in diet, exercise, social stimulation and the like. Psychiatrists are irrevocably committed to finding a biological cause for mental disorder but this is no longer an empirical research program. It is now an ideological project, to prove that all mental disorder is biological because they can't bring themselves to consider they could be wrong. Or consider an alternative, even when the alternative - exercise - is cheap, safe, doesn't cause weight gain or loss of libido, and is a lot more fun.
***
I was invited to submit a chapter to a volume on Critical Psychiatry to be published by the International Society for Ethical Psychology and Psychiatry. This grew to two chapters which are ready to go, just waiting on a final review. The first chapter is important. It looks at the influence on psychiatry over the last century of the philosophical doctrine known as positivism. It concludes that positivism has had a huge effect, eventually coming to dominate the field in the form of biological psychiatry, and that this effect has been almost entirely bad. Oh dear. It's one thing to challenge psychiatrists, telling them they don't have a model of their subject matter or their drugs are no good. It's something else again to throw down the gauntlet to the philosophy industry. However, the facts are clear so we'll see what emerges.
***
There have been some problems with the price of the book Narcisso-Fascism on Amazon. The prices shown on Amazon's US site are correct but not on the Australian site. For some reason, the paperback here is shown as $58.00 when it should be about $35.00. The ebook version, Amazon's Kindle, is correct at $10.30. They have said they will fix it in a week or two, so it may be better to wait a bit before ordering.
References:
1. Burkhardt G et al (2023). Transcranial direct current stimulation as an additional treatment....
The Lancet. Published online 03.07.2023,
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)00640-2
2. Voineskos D, Blumberger DM (2023). TCdcS in MDD. The Lancet. Published online 03.07.2023,
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)00822-X
3. WHO (2015). Meeting report on excess mortality in persons with severe mental disorder. WHO HQ, Geneva, 18-20 November 2015. Available at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5269481/
