Two recent reports on ABC Four Corners have investigated treatment of chronic pain. In particular, as the reports show, the hugely expensive and dangerous implanted spinal stimulators are long-overdue for a proper assessment. However, over-treatment and over-billing have been rife in the "chronic pain" industry for decades, so we can hope some good comes of it. Over the past dozen years or so, our old friend ketamine has been touted as the "must-have" treatment. While it doesn't do as much damage as a failed operation, it still carries plenty of risks. However, it's probably just a matter of time before somebody announces that other psychoactive drugs such as ecstasy (MDMA) and psilocybin are magic for pain - and makes a fortune.
Apart from the fact that chronic pain hurts and wrecks lives, a major part of the problem is that, in many countries, pain management has largely been privatised. Since a great deal of pain is covered by insurance, such as industrial, motor vehicle or military, and the sufferers are often desperate, the stage is set for cowboys to move in. Promising a quick and painless cure for pain is a certain path to riches, so that's what happens. Meanwhile, the shortage of pain management services in public hospitals pushes people toward the private sector but this isn't because the hospitals won't pay for them, it's because the hard-headed physicians and suspicious bean counters don't think they're very good. And they're not: I always believed that treatment should be approved by a committee reviewing the files anonymously, which is a great way of reducing costs and, above all, complications.
They use a similar system in Norway for ECT. Only public hospitals are able to give it, and there is normally an eight week waiting list, so they hardly use it. In Australia, the large private psychiatric industry in Victoria uses ECT 600% more than in New Zealand, where psychiatry is almost entirely public [1]. The system in Queensland is that if a psychiatrist tells a private patient to have ECT, it will happen. If the patient objects, she (most private ECT patients are older women) will be detained and she will get it anyway as mental health tribunals almost never reject an application. If we want to reduce the use of ECT, all we have to do is insert a review committee in the process. It doesn't even have to be a committee that disapproves of ECT, simply slowing things down will do the job, but skeptics would be even better. However, to kill ECT, simply adopt the Norwegian approach: "Yes, doctor, you can certainly order ECT for your patient but it won't be this week and you won't get paid for it."
At this, the shock-jockeys will start whining: "ECT is absolutely necessary to save lives, if we can't give ECT, the suicide rate will go through the roof. Think of the little old grannie who is so depressed she can't eat, she'll fade away without ECT." First point: It's rubbish, as the review at [1] shows. There are plenty of places in the world where ECT is severely restricted or even banned, and their suicide rates are the same or less than ours: look at New Zealand. "In the 2022/23 financial year, the rate of suspected self-inflicted deaths ... was 15.2 per 100,000 males, and ... 6.0 per 100,000 females," meaning practically the same as Australia. Even though the poor Kiwis are deprived of ECT, their suicide rates are slowly trending down while ours are going up again.
After the recent incident in Sydney where six people were murdered by a man with a long record of mental disorder, Prof. Patrick McGorry predictably called for more money: "The only way to reduce the risk to the public is to fund the mental health system in a substantially increased way ..." That's simply not true. There is no evidence that spending more on mental health, e.g. giving more ECT, has any effect on that type of incident, or on mental health in general, although providing more public housing probably would help. The problem is not lack of money, it's misallocation of money, paying the wrong people for the wrong things. And the worst money-burners of all are those constitutionally inefficient places, hospitals. Private hospitals need to have all their beds occupied all the time so their shareholders can make lots of money, so that's what they do, fill 'em up. Public hospitals are simply inefficient so the only way to deal with them is to keep patients out of them. This is not so difficult but it runs into the implacable resistance of ... the staff.
In 1987, I moved from Perth to the Kimberley Region of West Australia to start a psychiatric service where there had been none. Some 2,300km from Perth, the Kimberley is one of the most isolated parts of the Anglophone world (London to Moscow is 2,500km). The region is very hot, very humid, either very dusty or under water depending on the season, and magnificent wilderness country. My parish was 420,000 km2 (New York state is 141,000 km2) with a population of about 25,000, a little under half being Aboriginal people leading a fairly traditional life style, e.g. most of them spoke their own languages at home. While there are hospitals in each of the six towns, there were no staff or facilities for psychiatry, and "mental patients" were not welcome in the hospitals.
The purpose of putting a psychiatrist in the region was to stop the steady flow of Aboriginal people being sent to Perth as involuntary patients. For them, Perth may as well have been a suburb of Moscow. They hated the weather, nobody could understand them and they didn't like being locked inside buildings. In my first year, the numbers sent away dropped by over 95%, meaning I was earning my salary twice over in just the savings for the Flying Doctor Service. It wasn't magic, all I did was drive and fly around the place and see people in their local areas or in their homes. Previously, anything to do with psychiatry meant being locked away but once people could see that the shrink had only one head, and none on his belt, they were happy to come forward.
After moving to Brisbane, I had an office in a busy general practice in a big shopping centre in a working class area about 33km from the CBD. This was an area with a lot of Aboriginal and immigrant families, high unemployment, family breakdown, drugs and alcohol, generally poor health, crime and imprisonment, you name it. The same thing happened. When people realised they could be seen quickly and with no fuss or additional cost in familiar surroundings, the floodgates opened.
The point is this: Take the service to the people. Don't build expensive units with elaborate security and swarms of staff who need lots of time-consuming meetings and training sessions to coordinate their evidence-based practice and so on, the goal is to get the staff out of the offices onto the road. It's like Willie Sutton, the bank robber, who was asked why he robbed banks. "Because that's where the money is," he replied, and psychiatry needs to be the same. The psychiatrist has to go to where the madness is, but most psychiatrists don't like it. They prefer the sense of security that comes from having their own empire in a big hospital, or the muted luxury of a city tower with room for the Porsche downstairs. Dirt and sweat and smelly patients who don't own a toothbrush? No, that's not what they did five years post-grad for.
What's this got to do with reports of over-charging and over-servicing and malpractice in the pain industry? A lot, but the "over-charging and over-servicing and malpractice" in psychiatry is pretty well invisible as it is built into the system, time-honoured and accepted without question by the larger society. How do we know that detaining people and treating them against their will is better than not doing anything? Well, we don't. That's the point: "the system" makes sure that nobody looks too closely. Psychiatric research is focused on what the psychiatrists want to research, not what society needs. And the one thing they don't want anybody looking at is a cut-down, almost "barefoot" service that gets the same or better results for a quarter of the cost.
How do I know they don't? Because for the six years I was in the Kimberley as the world's most isolated psychiatrist, not one person from the Health Dept. of West Australia, or the College of Psychiatrists, or my former medical school in Perth, or the psychiatry training program, contacted me to see what I was doing (or to check I hadn't been eaten by a croc). That's not an accident. I don't think it was a conspiracy to silence me, it's just what in Freud-talk they call "unconscious deadening." Yogi Berra put his finger on it: "It's amazing what you don't see when you don't look." They didn't want to know that somebody could do things quicker and cheaper than they were, or could manage without ECT or compulsion, so they didn't look. It was all too threatening to their precious system. Nothing has changed.
****
After the gloomy conclusion of Part I of Theories in Psychiatry: Building a Post-Positivist Psychiatry (due in July), Part II asks whether we can use an available theory of mind to build a model of mental disorder. After five renowned philosophers (Chomsky, Dennett, Searle, Chalmers and Davidson) haven't mentioned the subject, it's not looking encouraging but in Chapter 11, we turn to the person often described as the most influential philosopher of the twentieth century. Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951) was born in Vienna to one of the richest families in the world. Ludwig's father was fearsomely oppressive and while the boy was still in his early teens, two of his older brothers committed suicide. Young Ludwig was prodigiously intelligent but he was also desperately unhappy, as the equally intelligent physicist and mathematician, Freeman Dyson, observed: "He was a tortured soul, the last survivor of a family with a tragic history, living a lonely life among strangers, trying until the end to express the inexpressible." He gave away his fortune so he could concentrate on philosophy, but he died quite young, painfully aware that he had not succeeded in his goals.
Wittgenstein had many peculiarities, one of them being the way he wrote. Rather than setting out a carefully-argued philosophical case, step-by-difficult-step, his main works consist of long series of aphorisms which his many devotees are still trying to decipher. That definitely isn't easy, as the logician and philosopher, Herbert Feigl (1902-1988), said (probably in 1924) after he read Wittgenstein's early work: "I dismissed Wittgenstein as a most curious mixture of intuitive genius and schizophrenia." Having met many highly intelligent people who have acquired that diagnosis, I think it's fair comment. People who try to express the inexpressible tend to write in a particular style, surprisingly similar to Wittgenstein's, although few show his intense discipline.
However, I think the real problem was he took as his starting point the brute fact of the mind as a real, causally-effective thing, and went forward, trying to work out what it does, when he should have gone back, trying to work out how it comes into existence. But at the time he was working on his philosophy, he couldn't do that because the basic work (neuroscience, computer sciences etc) hadn't been done. Wittgenstein himself said his work was a failure and while it was definitely significant, he has nothing to say about models of mind or of mental disorder. We press on to Chapter 13, on the British philosopher, Gilbert Ryle.
Very few people outside formal philosophy would have heard of Ryle yet he had a huge effect on philosophy of mind in the latter half of the last century. Ryle was a linguist first and philosopher of mind second; a large part of his legacy is his influence over what was called 'ordinary language' philosophy, later analytic philosophy, and his hostility to unobservables. He was largely, if not entirely, responsible for that disparaging term for the mind as "the ghost in the machine." Among many other major figures, Ryle taught Daniel Dennett and John Searle, who soaked up his contempt and delivered it to their students, and so ad infinitum. Did I quote the socialist Cambridge economist, Joan Robinson, on higher education?
Progress is slow partly from mere intellectual inertia. In a subject where there is no agreed procedure for knocking out errors, doctrines have a long life. A professor teaches what he was taught, and his pupils, with a proper respect and reverence for teachers, set up a resistance against his critics for no other reason than that it was he whose pupils they were.
Ryle's major work, The Concept of Mind, published in 1949, is not a book about the mind at all. It is a book-length linguistic analysis on what the mind is not. At the end, he still hasn't explained the phenomena of getting a joke, mental arithmetic, hearing a song running through your head or imagining a scene from the past. All he said was: It's not what you think it is. OK, there was once a place for this sort of analysis but 75 years later, it has dated badly. My conclusion? Ghosts one, philosophers nil.
****
Reference:
1. McLaren N (2017). Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Critical Perspective. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 19: 91-104.
****
The whole of this material is copyright but can be quoted or retransmitted provided the author is acknowledged.
