A reader somewhere in the US, who has a long history of contact with psychiatry, asked:
… I want to know, what a psychiatrist is thinking when they put people on drugs … why do psychiatrists prescribe pharmaceutical drugs? What is going through their head when they do it? Does the average psychiatrist think to themselves “I want to drag this person through a prescription cascade until they’re dead?” A psych (nurse practitioner) once told me that she prescribes drugs and that is just what she does. Do most psychiatrists think that way? Do psychiatrists really have any idea what these drugs do before they prescribe them? Are psychiatrists living in a fantasy land? If they are, why are they? Is it the money that drives them? Is it fear of losing their license to practice or fear of looking like a quack that drives them? … Is it their schooling? Does it have anything to do with the key opinion leaders or the journals or the studies? Are there potential lawsuits that they are afraid of? Other than (pharmaceutical industry inducements), the problem can look very complex and mysterious …
It would take a large book to answer these questions properly as they go right to the heart of the psychiatric enterprise: “What is the nature of mental disorder? Is mental disorder the sort of thing that can be fixed with chemicals? Do psychiatrists actually know what they’re doing?” For mainstream psychiatry, answers to those questions are dead easy: “Mental disorder is brain disorder. Since brain disorders are physical, they can only be rectified by physical treatments,” meaning drugs and ECT.
However, those answers are based in a wrong answer to the logically prior question: “What is the nature of the mind itself?” Very clearly, psychiatrists don’t have an answer to that question as their entire approach is shaped by their medical training. Medicine is a technology, i.e. an applied science, but is not itself a science. You could say clinical medicine is the fairly artistic application of the basic sciences of anatomy, biochemistry, physiology, pathology, pharmacology, microbiology and so on. Medical school starts with these subjects so that, by the time they first see a patient, medical students are thoroughly soaked in a particular frame of mind. They don’t know this, of course, their understanding is that their perception of humans and our place in the universe is the only correct frame of mind. They believe there are only two viewpoints: “Our scientific point of view,” and “All that silly stuff,” including childish fables, fantasy, ideology, or (most heinous of all) religion. The historian and philosopher Richard Carrier summarised their worldview neatly:
… if anything exists in our universe, it is a part of nature, and has a natural cause or origin, and there is no need of any other explanation … more and more it appears that all of sociology can be reduced to psychology, all of psychology can be reduced to biology, all of biology can be reduced to chemistry, and all chemistry to physics, which is the study of matter and energy in space-time. Therefore, everything is matter-energy in space-time [1, S. III.5.4.2].
Very early, students learn that the mind doesn’t fit with their new vision of science. All talk of minds is seen as primitive and pre-scientific and must be expelled. Lecturers don’t use the expression “mumbo-jumbo,” but medical students are usually fairly sharp and they soon learn that this is what is meant. The Oxford philosopher, David Oderberg, put all this together when describing the attitude of philosophers to the idea of separate minds, or what is called dualism:
Dualism... persists in being more the object of ridicule than of serious rational engagement. It is held by the vast majority of philosophers be anything from (and not mutually exclusively) false, mysterious, and bizarre, to obscurantist, unintelligible, and/or dangerous to morals. Its adherents are assumed to be biased, scientifically ill-informed, motivated by prior theological dogma, cursed by metaphysical anachronism, and/or to have taken leave of their senses … [2]
And that, in a few sentences, summarises what young physicians believe of the mind when they start their training in psychiatry (residents in the US, trainees elsewhere). Of course, they’re not so silly as to say it out loud but that’s what they believe. They’ve just spent about ten years being indoctrinated in the point of view called physicalism (aka materialism), that there is nothing in the universe beyond matter and energy interacting in the time-space matrix. As Carrier said, anything that exists is matter and energy because that’s all there is. Every higher order entity that exists can be fully explained as the predictable outcome of the lower order entities of which it is composed, i.e. by a process of reduction. The scientific method therefore consists of the disciplined application of the reductionist method. Properly applied, it will eventually give us the truth of any matter just because there is no other conceivable explanation.
What they don’t realise is that their understanding of the nature of the universe, and the role of science in explaining it, is just another ideological position. As the Carrier-Oderberg debate shows, you either believe that physics will tell us everything we need to know, or you think it won’t. Either way, nobody can prove that the other side is wrong. Arguing across that intellectual divide is a waste of time because, for each side, the truth is self-evident and can’t be questioned. For the physicalist or reductionist materialist, it is self-evident that there can be no rational explanation of minds apart from reduction to “matter and energy in space-time.” For the dualist, this is manifest nonsense because the properties of the mind are not properties of mass-energy so the laws of mass-energy can never apply. To explain what all humans knows goes on in their heads, different laws are needed, except we haven’t got those laws yet (I say we have, they just expand the field of rational science[3]).
The physicalist tradition that medical students and trainee psychiatrists are taught is called positivism. Essentially, it means that all science has to be based on positive observations, not just surmise. In Natural Dualism and Mental Disorder [3], I’ve given lists of quotes to show this is what they believe, and there’ll be more in the forthcoming book on theories in psychiatry [4]. There’s no question that positivism has been spectacularly successful – within its proper territory. The arguments start when people trained in the positivist tradition claim that it and it alone can explain the whole human experience. As good positivists, but with no understanding of why that doctrine was adopted or of its limits, psychiatrists are convinced beyond any argument that their view, that “All mental disorder is ultimately a brain disorder,” is correct and anybody who disagrees is an idiot. But as Oderberg described, you can’t debate with people who think you’re an idiot.
This is where psychiatry breaks down, this is how the questions the reader sent in arise: yes, all psychiatrists fervently believe the biological “model” but can they prove it? Asking a committed biological psychiatrist to prove his point just invites a contemptuous dismissal. It’s like asking devout religious people, or Marxists, or neoliberals, or people who believe the QAnon conspiracies [5] to prove their point. To them, the idea of demanding proof is ridiculous, the evidence is straight in front of you, all you have to do is open your eyes (and mind) to The Truth, etc. Most psychiatrists firmly believe mental disorder is biological, it’s in their heads when they arrive at work each morning and it never goes away. All doubts meet the same reflex response: More of the same.
Given this starting point, let’s see if we can answer some of those questions, except I’m probably the last person to explain what psychiatrists think because I hardly know any. Several times throughout my career, I went two years without speaking to another psychiatrist, just because there weren’t any around and those I tried to ring didn’t call back so I gave up. The few times I have mentioned this to other psychiatrists, they were amazed: “Two years? You’re kidding, I never speak to anybody else,” which leads to that well-known effect called the echo chamber. And so to the first question:
Q1: “What are psychiatrists thinking when they put people on drugs?”
A1: I don’t know, you’d have to ask them, but most have the view: “Complaints of misery, irritability and poor sleep means depression; depression means chemical imbalance of the brain; chemical imbalance means balance restorers, aka antidepressants.” For far too many psychiatrists, the “thinking” starts and ends at this very crude, mechanical level, just because their doctrine says “That’s all there is to psychiatry.” They don’t ask why the person is miserable because to them, the answer is self-evident: “He’s miserable and his life is going badly because his brain enzymes are playing up.” We saw this in the interview earlier this year by one of the most influential psychiatrists in the country, who said in effect: “People aren’t depressed because they’ve had bad life events, they have bad life events because they’re depressed.” Later, he explicitly said: “And for most people, (childhood) is not the cause (of depression).” That sterilises the human experience, turning the infinite complexity of a human life into a boring recitation of unconnected facts.
Compare this with general medicine. We can look at a man and say “Yes, he’s got a broken leg. He’ll need surgery and then he’ll be fine.” The cause, be it car accident, fall at work or at home, sport, fighting etc., isn’t going to affect the treatment. The attitude in biological psychiatry is much the same: “Yes, he’s depressed. He’ll need antidepressants and then he’ll be fine.” For them, the cause is a matter not of life events but of unseen brain chemistry, about which, in fact, they know precisely nothing. So what are they thinking when they prescribe drugs? Not much. Certainly, they are not thinking: “Oh boy, this chap is not going to be easy. He’s doesn’t trust psychiatrists and I think he’s concealing a lot of trouble in the past. Why is this job so important, and what’s all that business about his father’s death? I’ll have to take this one very carefully.”
Q2: “Why do psychiatrists prescribe pharmaceutical drugs?”
A2: Since they don’t have a theory of mind that allows them to engage with the patient as a sentient being, that’s all they’ve got. Their entire theoretical approach is the same as a vet approaching a sick cow. If the cow plays up, it will be locked in the bails so it can be injected. If the mental patient plays up, she will be wrestled to the ground, injected, stripped and locked in a room where she may even die. There’s no difference, it’s just chemistry after all.
Q3: “What is going through their head when they do it?”
A3: Again, I’ve never asked any but I’m sure a survey would give the answer “Nothing much.” We can, however, be sure of what is not going through their heads: the potential risks of prescribing drugs such as sedation and confusion, manic-type reactions, obesity, loss of sexual function, emotional numbing, addiction, and major shortening of life span. Some years ago, the then president of the RANZCP issued a press release saying:
The prescription of antidepressant or antipsychotic medications is something that a psychiatrist only ever does in partnership with the patient and after due consideration of the risks and benefits.
This, of course, was a complete lie and the president knew it, as did all the people involved in suppressing my complaints. If there is anything going through the psychiatrist’s heads when they prescribe drugs, it’s probably some fluffy, self-protective fantasy of that type: “Here I am, doing the Good Work, helping these unfortunates. And earning a very comfortable living in the process.”
Q4: “Does the average psychiatrist think to themselves ‘I want to drag this person through a prescription cascade until they’re dead?’”
A4: Good heavens, no. Haven’t you heard? Psychiatrists are nice people, they wouldn’t do that sort of thing. But if it happens that after 25 years of a vast range of very powerful drugs, in and out of hospital, detention and involuntary treatment, obesity, unemployment, wrecked relationships, probably ECT, the patient’s heart gives out or she jumps off a bridge, well, that’s the nature of mental illness, isn’t it. So sad but after all, it was her bad genes, we did our best but we can’t fight nature. That’s what George Washington’s physicians said after they’d bled him to death trying to control the fever of malaria because they believed that fevers were caused by an excess of hot blood, so bleeding a feverish patient made perfect sense to them.
Q5: “A psych (nurse practitioner) once told me that she prescribes drugs and that is just what she does. Do most psychiatrists think that way?”
A5: Yes, and that’s why, now that it’s becoming clear that mainstream drugs really don’t resolve the problem, that psychiatrists are making a grab for psychotomimetic drugs (hallucinogens) such as MDMA, ketamine, psilocybin etc. It’s called “scraping the bottom of the barrel.” But they won’t give up their beliefs.
Q6: “Do psychiatrists really have any idea what these drugs do before they prescribe them?”
A6: No. They do not. They are taught “These drugs are disease-specific. While they aren’t perfect, the alternative, no treatment, is very, very much worse. Patients are insightless as part of their disease. If they object to the drugs, that is their disease talking and it is wrong to allow the disease to control treatment.” Implied but not stated: “So anybody who complains too much of drug side effects is an ungrateful shit and needs more drugs to eradicate her bad thinking, not less.”
Q7: “Are psychiatrists living in a fantasy land?”
A7: Oh boy, you really put your finger on it this time (see last sentence of Answer 6, above). See Answer 1, where the eminent psychiatrist, Prof. Ian Hickie, clearly stated several falsehoods (that more antidepressants = less suicides, and depression causes bad life events, not the other way around). Also see Answer 3, the lie put about by the RANZCP that no patient was ever injected without the nice psychiatrist sitting down and earnestly explaining all the pros and cons of treatment. There have been plenty of other lies over the years, such as the claim that there is a “biomedical model” in psychiatry ([6]. There isn’t, nobody has ever written one because they can’t [7]) or that there is a “biopsychosocial model” ([8]. There isn’t, it was never written but they can’t write it as they don’t have a theory of mind), on and on. The overwhelming majority of psychiatrists throughout the world do indeed live in a fantasy land, where they believe what they’re told, that mental disorder is brain disorder and drugs are the cure. And that patients who object aren’t rational so nobody should listen to them.
Q8: “If they are, why are they?”
A8: Because that’s what they were taught and most of them enjoy the sense of power and/or the income it gives them and/or are too insecure emotionally to challenge a professor and/or too insecure intellectually to try to think for themselves and/or they never read anything but propaganda from drug companies or all of the above subject to change without notice.
Running out of space so we’ll have to stop there for today. As for intellectual satisfaction, way back in the Medieval era, when I started my training and was going to the lectures and working through the reading list, this song kept going through my head.
References:
1. Carrier, R. (2005). Sense and Goodness Without a God: a defence of metaphysical naturalism. Bloomington, IN: AuthorHouse.
2.. Oderberg DS (2005). Hylemorphic Dualism, in Ellen Frankel Paul, Fred D. Miller FD, Paul J: Personal Identity. Cambridge: University Press.
3. McLaren N (2021): Natural Dualism and Mental Disorder: The biocognitive model for psychiatry. London, Routledge.
4. McLaren N (due 2024). Theories in Psychiatry: Toward a post-positivist psychiatry. Ann Arbor, MI: Future Psychiatry Press.
5. Bloom M, Moskalenko S (2021). Pastels and Pedophiles. Inside the Mind of QAnon. Stanford, CA: Redwood Press.
6. Menkes, D, Dharmawardene, V, (2019). Anti-psychiatry in 2019, and why it matters. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 53: 921-922. https://doi.org/10.1177/0004867419868791
7. McLaren N (2013). Psychiatry as Ideology. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 15: 7-18. doi: 10.1891/1559-4343.15.1.7
8. McLaren N (2023). The Biopsychosocial Model and Scientific Deception. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry, 25: 106-118.doi:10.1891/EHPP-2023-0008

yes, for sure! if we look at ABS stats the number of atheists hasn’t changed that much. But the questions are biased re religious beliefs and they were even trying to get rid of the question totally so religious affiliation would not be measured. I think they should include the option of “spiritual but not religious” as that is where most people are going, they are leaving mainstream religions but still believe in a supernatural force. The scientific american magazine had an interesting article about the mysterious nature of consciousness come up on my feed - if you can find it will add to your thinking. I’m loving Peggy Lee’s album from 1969 - my new go to on Spotify for now. and good to dance to!
https://theconversation.com/how-medical-schools-can-be-more-accountable-to-society-through-community-connections-231658
Given that most psychiatrists are taught a pure materialist approach and deny the mysterious nature of the mind are we (medical educators) failing in accountability to society where only about 10% of eg australian society are atheists?