This week's Mad in America, Bob Whitaker's weekly newsletter, carries an article on the ghastly lives endured by the Genain quadruplets, who were born in 1930. They have long been used as examples of the hereditary basis of mental disorder but, in view of what they endured, that would have been the least factor. It also shows how academic psychiatry picks and chooses the evidence to support their case (that mental disorder is genetic/biological) to such an extent that the expression "evidence-based" has no scientific validity.
While on the topic of abuse, I came across this video, on the tragic life of Rosemary Kennedy, JFK's sister, who was subjected to "lobotomy" to cure the mood swings and convulsions caused by perinatal brain damage. And one more article, by Richard Eskow, a social/financial commentator, on drug company profits and how they manipulate the legislature to get what they want. He has his regular Substack blog, which has lots of insider information on how Big Pharma schemes and cheats to get its own way.
* * *
"PC" left a well-considered comment on last week's post on conspiracies, looking at the concept of what is now labelled "neurodiversity." I'd intended to bring that up but ran out of space. This is a new word (a neologism) which has been around for 20 years or so. It means that people show diverse behaviour because of their different brains, so they should not be penalised or stigmatised in any way because of it. It makes sense only in the context of the explosion of "neuropsychiatric diagnoses" brought about by the expansion of diagnoses in the various editions of the DSM project, the goal being to turn everybody in the world into a patient (I think we're up to about 580 in the DSM-5). The justification behind it is that if a person shows some sort of difference, then it is (a) brain-based, and therefore (b) genetic and (c) an illness for which (d) drugs are necessary. When you set it out like this, the inherent stupidity of the whole thing is clear.
It is built on a stupid assumption: If there are "neurodiverse" people, then there must be "neurotypical" people to compare them with. But what's that? Is the compulsive liar and womaniser, Boris Johnson, neurotypical? What about his good friend, Donald Trump, liar, thief, misogynist and general scoundrel? Or our own ScoMo, former PM and, by his evidence in the Royal Commission into Robodebt, an inveterate schemer and liar. Straight away, we see the problem: there is no such "thing" as normal. Human behaviour varies dimensionally, not categorically. This means that whatever factor we choose to look at, everybody will get a score (say Courtesy/Rudeness, Tidy/Untidy, Honesty/Dishonesty, Cautious/Thrill-seeking, and so on), but the scores don't divide into two groups, the "typical" and the "diverse." All scores are like heights, or weights: they vary on a dimension or single line, not as separate categories of "normal" and "abnormal." And the other thing is that people go back and forth along the dimension; sometimes I'm suspicious and sometimes I'm not.
So we're off to a bad start: there's no such thing as normal. For years, I've said to people ...
I eat my peas with honey, I've done it all my life.
It makes the peas taste funny, but it keeps them on the knife.
However, if we think of normality as a huge splodge spread across the landscape, rather than a point on a graph, then we should all be tolerant of diversity. It used to be said "Don't judge, keep your opinions to yourself," at the same time as children were told "Don't speak with your mouth full, sit up straight, tidy your room, clean your teeth, don't be late, what will people think of you?" Endlessly. So what does this say? It says "Human behaviour is infinitely variable but if we want society to survive, then there have to be rules." We have to find a balance between the two poles of individual self-expression, and conformity for the sake of consideration of others. For those old enough to remember, the 1950s were very repressive, conformity was the name of the game. Look at the early photos of the Beatles and the Rolling Stones in their suits and ties, or any of the Doo-Wop groups (what?) from the 1950s, such as Frankie Lymon and The Teenagers. Uncool hair maybe, but they could sing.
Then it all changed. In the 1960s, the message became "Tune in, Turn on, Drop out." Grow your hair if you want to, sleep around, get stoned, rebel, overthrow the Man. Difference was celebrated, convention and conformism were out. In different countries, there were rights movements to correct centuries of repression, black civil rights, women's liberation, gay liberation, children's rights, animal rights, land rights and so on. But if that's true, why are we now promoting human diversity as a form of brain disease? Money. That's all. Cherchez l'argent, follow the money trail.
There are certain facts to be aware of:
1. Humans are behaviorally diverse. People like to do their own thing in their own time and place and resent being told that "their own thing" is immoral or disgusting or queer or dangerous or addictive or fattening or unpatriotic or all of the above.
2. Modern productive society is not tolerant of diversity. It wants workers to work and buyers to buy. Big Business grudgingly accepts it has to be nice to sick or disabled people but hates "people who like to do their own thing in their own time and place" because they mess with the production line. And the bottom line. Its goal is to get all "diverse" people out of the work force and on to government benefits, as long as the companies don't have to pay tax to support them. Most big companies and rich people in Australia do not pay tax.
3. Drug companies exist to make money. If they thought they could make more money breeding blowflies, that's what they would do.
4. Academics need to get ahead. This is just the normal human urge to be top of the hierarchy, to look down on everybody else.
5. Academic psychiatrists need money to get ahead. They also need to do something so the rest of the medical profession doesn't scorn them.
6. Drug companies have heaps of money (see the article above by Richard Eskow) but they want to know they can keep bringing it in, i.e. they need to sell more drugs to more people for longer.
7. They can't leave free samples in the letterbox as drugs must be prescribed. They have to convince doctors to prescribe their drugs, especially as drugs are pretty unpleasant, like massive weight gain or no sex life, etc.
8. Doctors are stick-in-the-muds, they prefer to keep doing what they learned 30 years ago because they know it works for them. However, they also have to keep up to date in a fast-changing field.
9. Doctors don't like sudden, dramatic change but they are happy with a steady drip of refinements to what they knew.
10. Most doctors don't like dealing with mental trouble. They don't understand it, it takes too much time, the patients are difficult and are often ungrateful. If they can write a script which promises to fix the patient's whining, they will.
11. There is no advancement for academic psychiatrists who simply find fault with everybody else's ideas, especially when the faults are real and obvious and belong to a Big Name. The only way to get ahead is to find a new treatment or find a new disease. The last "new treatment" in psychiatry was psychosurgery in about 1938 (recall that Anton Mesmer tried magnetic stimulation, in about 1785).
12. New diseases aren't difficult to find, all you need is a data base and a statistics package on a reasonably powerful computer; yes, a mobile phone can easily handle that sort of package. New biological diseases also help psychiatry's image with the rest of the profession.
So it all falls together. There are lots of people who are, in some sense, "different," who don't want to/can't change but who don't like being labelled "queer." They've tried a few far-out churches and hot yoga bowel washouts but it didn't help, they still don't get on with people at work. Meantime, the drug companies are prowling the fringes of academia, wondering where they should plant their seed money to get the best return. They're getting worried because, after fifty years of promising salvation from mental disorder, it's still hanging around, if not getting worse, but their patents are running out with no new drugs in the pipeline and no bright new ideas in the groves of academia.
Over in the academic groves, there is a growing awareness that fifty years of pushing hard on the biology button has produced very little in the way of results. Like, none. How many times can they ring their favourite reporters to promise that yes, they're on the cusp of a major breakthrough in the genetics/biochemistry/treatment of mental disorder without actually producing any such breakthrough? And will the funding agencies one day wake up and point to fifty years of broken promises and ask to see some results from all the money that's been blown, sorry, wisely invested, in the past?
The problem resolves when a bright young academic psychiatrist, who has been soundly trained in the belief that all mental disorder is biological, sees a couple of patients who are a bit different and decides they must be biologically different. Don't worry about their family background (see the article on the Genain quads in MIA, above), and it helps if the patients are keen on some label that gets their relatives and everybody off their backs, yes, a label that says "Sick, not queer," will do nicely, especially if it comes with government benefits. "You need to research that," says the professor, who wants more publications on his department's annual report to the university, "you could try some of the drug companies, they'd be interested." Yes, the drug companies are interested, here's some money, does the psychiatrist need assistance with statistical analysis as they have an entire department who are very good at that but who aren't busy this week, they'd love to help design the study to get the best results. Just sign this contract giving us the right of refusal of publication, thanks and here's the loot. I mean your grant.
Before long, the excited psychiatrists are ringing their favourite reporters to shout Yes yes, this time is for real, we're on the cusp of a major breakthrough, we just need some publicity to get more people to come into our study. In no time, there's a community group (funded by the drug company) to support this ground-breaking research; a while later, the psychiatrists give a presentation to a capacity crowd at an international conference, then they get their own conference and finally, they pull off the gold medal of having their diagnosis accepted into the diagnostic manuals. Meanwhile, back at the factory, or the school or the shop, nothing has changed except the "neurodiverse" person is now on drugs for life and still isn't selected for the footy team or school play. But that's so typical of neurotypicals, no consideration.
Sixty years after the start of the hippie movement, when the Beatles were shocking with their "English sheepdog" haircuts, we're back to where we started: conformity is the name of the game. Human diversity is not accepted as normal, it is not celebrated or encouraged, everybody has to conform even if it means being drugged for life according to the same model of mental disorder that pushed Rosemary Kennedy into the clutches of the lobotomists. Except people are slowly starting to realise that there is no "biomedical model" of mental disorder. It's all propaganda, supported by a steady flow of neologisms like "neurodiversity."

We did correspond over the Szasz paper I wrote a few years ago, - just to clear up any ambiguity over the PC monicker- I sign up for so many things these days, it’s easier just to abbreviate my initials. I haven’t written anything since, although almost got another critical psychiatry paper published if it wasn’t for one of the reviewers.
Due to work, I unfortunately had to delve quite deep into the ND literature, which of course, shouldn’t really exist as it is not a model or theory just a neologism. Based on a phrase coined by Judy Singer, in my opinion, the “continually evolving movement” as its proponents like to refer to it as, continues to be rhetorical mush with the terms “neurodivergent” ostensibly not being the same as “neurodiversity” and self-proclaimed layman experts deciding what term should be used as they consider themselves ND and therefore are suddenly an expert on everything about “it.”
However, it has entered the mainstream enough to be considered in the same series in which you were interviewed by Awais Aftab https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/neurodiversity-paradigm-psychiatry Indeed, companies now ask people if they have a “neurodiversity.”
Whilst the interview seems to read as unassailable mush mostly, there are some valid criticisms in there of Szasz (which I think would align with your own) and attempts to move away from the biological paradigm of mental illness using an “ecological model that rejects the assumption that humans have enough neurocognitive uniformity across the species that legitimizes the notions of normal neurological functioning.” Where this model is stated explicitly in the interview is not exactly clear to me.
Whilst ND is in my opinion a myth, it seems, in the UK at least, to try and make society (against your 2nd point about production and businesses) more tolerant of diversity and through implication of its promulgation, succeeding somewhat. At its heart, its message seems to be to accept human diversity as normal, celebrate and encourage it (much like the other current social movements), but it arrives at this message without a serious model of mental functioning or anything else and whilst some of its proponents have made good and valid criticism of current psychiatric practices, the movement cannot drag itself away from them entirely as it relies on these being legitimate conditions with a neurological referent. It all ends up being rather narcissistic in my opinion.
😓