Discussion about this post

User's avatar
PC's avatar

We did correspond over the Szasz paper I wrote a few years ago, - just to clear up any ambiguity over the PC monicker- I sign up for so many things these days, it’s easier just to abbreviate my initials. I haven’t written anything since, although almost got another critical psychiatry paper published if it wasn’t for one of the reviewers.

Due to work, I unfortunately had to delve quite deep into the ND literature, which of course, shouldn’t really exist as it is not a model or theory just a neologism. Based on a phrase coined by Judy Singer, in my opinion, the “continually evolving movement” as its proponents like to refer to it as, continues to be rhetorical mush with the terms “neurodivergent” ostensibly not being the same as “neurodiversity” and self-proclaimed layman experts deciding what term should be used as they consider themselves ND and therefore are suddenly an expert on everything about “it.”

However, it has entered the mainstream enough to be considered in the same series in which you were interviewed by Awais Aftab https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/neurodiversity-paradigm-psychiatry Indeed, companies now ask people if they have a “neurodiversity.”

Whilst the interview seems to read as unassailable mush mostly, there are some valid criticisms in there of Szasz (which I think would align with your own) and attempts to move away from the biological paradigm of mental illness using an “ecological model that rejects the assumption that humans have enough neurocognitive uniformity across the species that legitimizes the notions of normal neurological functioning.” Where this model is stated explicitly in the interview is not exactly clear to me.

Whilst ND is in my opinion a myth, it seems, in the UK at least, to try and make society (against your 2nd point about production and businesses) more tolerant of diversity and through implication of its promulgation, succeeding somewhat. At its heart, its message seems to be to accept human diversity as normal, celebrate and encourage it (much like the other current social movements), but it arrives at this message without a serious model of mental functioning or anything else and whilst some of its proponents have made good and valid criticism of current psychiatric practices, the movement cannot drag itself away from them entirely as it relies on these being legitimate conditions with a neurological referent. It all ends up being rather narcissistic in my opinion.

Ready for more?