In case you don’t know, the German expression Kulturkampf translates as … Culture War. In 19th Century Prussia, there was a struggle between the Catholic Church, which wanted to run its hierarchy and its schools to suit itself, and the new state, which had other ideas. These days, it means a long-running dispute between essentially irreconcilable value-based opinions on how society should be run. Culture wars consume vast amounts of time and energy but as soon as one looks as though it may settle, somebody opens a new front and away it goes. The purpose is not to resolve the matter but to distract people, away from real issues on to something inflammatory that makes practically no difference whether it is resolved or not.
We saw it with the huge drama in the 1960s and 70s as to whether (shudder) homosexuality should be decriminalised. At the time, there was great agitation over whether letting gays out of their closets would reduce society to smoking ruins overnight. In time, of course, it came to pass and nothing happened. The sky did not fall in, horses in the street did not stampede in terror. It was, indeed, a classic moral panic , where a small group of excitable busybodies cast another small group with different values as an apocalyptic threat to society. The busybodies rush around, trying to convince the normally somnolent masses they should rise up and tear the moral cancer from their collective breast. These people, known as moral entrepreneurs, seek to change the moral basis of society in some way, either by reinforcing existing social norms or by introducing new ones. All too often, however, moral entrepreneurs have well-concealed ulterior motives and use fear to force changes that favour them.
The classic examples of moral panic are witchcraft and communism but there have been thousands over the years. For several centuries, moral entrepreneurs in the southern states of the US beat up the evils of miscegenation (inter-racial relations) or the ultimate terror, a slave rebellion. Their purpose was to maintain the wealth they had built out of the crime of slavery. Further north, fears centred on the dread doctrine of socialism sneaking in via southern and eastern European immigrants, threatening fortunes during the gilded age and leading to “anti-Red” riots in Boston and New York in the 1880s. Both of these fears persist to the present, hidden from view except when flaunted openly in the Murdoch press. Compared with the US, Australia’s moral panics have generally been rather insipid affairs: the Yellow Peril, or Reds Under the Bed, morphing into the Orange Peril (before China became our biggest trading partner). Despite the frequent panics, their godless hordes stayed well north of the equator, forcing us to go to all the trouble of travelling to their countries to attack them.
Since the scientific endeavour has nothing to say about morality, we would like to keep moral panics right out of it. Morality is a human pursuit; the natural world has no such concept. This isn’t always easy as, unlike religion, which stays the same, and politics, which goes backwards, science is constantly developing and expanding its territory. Unfortunately, all too often, there is a suppressed sexual element to moral panics as, apart from money and power, there isn’t much else that can work people up to join demonstrations or distribute pamphlets on chilly street corners.
The history of science shows many examples where a society has happily believed something for centuries, then a bunch of interfering scientists come along and upend the whole system. Generally, when science bumps into a set of incompatible beliefs, there is a bit of genteel skirmishing until the old guard retires and a new generation, familiar with the novel idea, takes over. With time and education, the world fits in with the new model of science. The change from the Ptolemaic or geocentric model of the universe to Copernicus’ heliocentric model in the 17th Century has been studied closely. That met opposition from the church, which felt that the new model would lead to serious social unrest, which is why they put Galileo on trial. They didn’t say he was wrong, only that he shouldn’t broadcast it but, in fairly short order, the telescope won the argument. In the 19th Century, Louis Pasteur’s novel germ theory had an even more dramatic effect as it directly impacted people’s lives, but it made sense and, in this case, the microscope won.
However, when science and a moral panic collide, matters aren’t quite so polite. Science is never so exciting as sex, and moral entrepreneurs aren’t deterred by a few measly facts; their minds are made up and facts get in the way. They know the truth and the world has to fit in with them, not the other way around. All too often, what happens is that the morally pure agents of panic coopt the science and twist it to suit themselves. Anybody who opposes them is labelled irreligious, or satanic, or a traitor to the nation or the race, and can expect to be in real trouble. The hatred of homosexuality goes back forever as its opponents were convinced queers had superhuman powers of seduction and were lusting to destroy the very fabric of society. Victorian Britain passed laws that turned gay sex into a crime but that didn’t stamp it out so, mainly in the US, it was turned into an abhorrent mental disease. In California in the 1960s and 70s, gay prisoners were segregated and injected with fluphenazine, a powerfully numbing antipsychotic drug. In 1980, and only after huge arguments, the “disease” of homosexuality was finally removed from DSM-III.
More ominously, the 1920s and 30s were the heyday of eugenics, the notion that selective breeding of human populations would lead to an improvement in the nation’s genetic stock, just as it does in farm animals. In fact, the real fear was that uncontrolled breeding by inferior people and inferior races would lead to the nice, superior people being swamped and losing their exalted, God-given place in society. In reality, eugenics was all about power, which helps explain why it fascinated the powerful and opened their wallets. As with most science at the time, the study of human genetics was most advanced in Germany. When the Nazis took power in 1933, they turned it into state policy and threw money and resources at it. In place of the objective or morally neutral science of genetics, eugenics was taken over by fanatical racists, notably including many physicians, psychiatrists and lawyers. It was used to justify the murderous “racial hygiene” programs which started with the enforced sterilisation and murder of hundreds of thousands of mental patients, and soon led to the death camps. It should not be forgotten, as a lot of powerful people would like us to forget, that the Rockefeller Foundation was heavily involved in financial and political support of the Nazi “racial hygiene” program.
Similarly, in the US in the 1950s, the entirely artificial fear of socialism/communism was whipped to a frenzy in the movement known as McCarthyism, named after the seriously paranoid (and probably alcoholic) Sen. Joseph McCarthy, who chaired Senate investigations of “communist penetration” of the country. It met the criteria for a moral panic because the tiny US Communist Party was no danger to anybody, even the wealthy industrialists who had set up the conditions that made socialism attractive to their workers. Even though socialism does not mean Stalinism, McCarthy and the right wing convinced the general public that they were one and the same thing. This is an example of how vested interests can take over a legitimate social or political movement and use it for their own ends.
And so we come to the Cass Report, from the UK, titled the Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People (GIDS). Its focus is transsexualism and, over 388 pages, it details the state of GIDS in England and how the NHS is dealing with it. As part of their investigation, the committee, under Dr Hilary Cass, a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, linked with the University of York to review the scientific basis of gender identity studies. With long experience in government, administration, medical research and politics, both medical and the other kind, Dr Cass is eminently qualified to lead this sort of study. I don’t envy her one little bit.
It's my impression that the UK Government would have been happier for the problem to go away but it was under pressure to “do something,” so it appointed a committee to investigate. Most of the impetus seems to have come from the availability of drugs used to suppress puberty, on the basis that they would give the individual time to think about the consequences of sex change, and to delay or prevent the appearance of secondary sexual characteristics, e.g. beards in teenage boys, etc. The drugs have been touted as essential to reduce mental disturbance and/or suicide in this group, leading to the social pressure to be seen to be proactive.
Unless you have a particular need to read this report, I wouldn’t bother. Even for a reader as deeply skeptical of government committees as your scribe, it seems the Committee has investigated the matter properly and issued a fair and balanced report. It can be summarised in five points:
Until 2014, what is called “gender identity disorder,” aka transsexualism, was rare and largely confined to adult males. Since 2014, the profile has changed to be a problem of teenage girls, and the incidence of referrals in this particular group has increased one hundred times in about six years: “Since biological factors have not changed in the last 10 years, it is necessary to look at other possible reasons for the increase in referrals and the disproportionate representation of birth-registered females” (p117, pt 8.23).
Gender identity services for children and young people in the UK are seriously disorganised, or worse. There are no standard procedures or processes for what is potentially a life-changing matter, and precious little good will. For example, at one stage, the review committee wanted the different clinics to cooperate with compiling their figures but they refused (Appendix 12, p1).
The science is equally a mess. There is no reliable scientific basis to explain either the condition itself (we don’t yet know how gender identity develops normally) or to explain the massive increase in referrals over the past ten years. For example, p153, pt11.21: “Only ten studies met the inclusion criteria. Study quality was assessed as low in nine of the studies and moderate in one study.”
Cases referred to GIDS clinics show high to very high levels of personality problems and other, generally vaguely-defined, psychiatric conditions, all of which overlap in symptoms and presentation.
There is no evidence to suggest that “gender affirmation” helps the individuals adjust to life, or that it reduces suicides in this group. At p5 and p7 of Appendix 2, the summary of the University of York studies, the almost complete lack of any reliable scientific basis to the whole issue is set out in blunt terms.
I am deeply suspicious of the regular drives to get some sort of behaviour recognised as “mental illness,” such that people, especially parents, are thrown into panic and rush their sprogs off for treatment. All too often, drug companies or some other vested interest, especially the private psychiatry industry, are assiduously stirring them from behind the scenes. The massive increases in referral rates found by the Cass Committee (e.g. p85-87) are not consistent with any possible biological cause for teenage girls to want to change their sex. The figures are, however, entirely consistent with a moral panic although this time, the roles are reversed. Society is not being asked to isolate or punish a wayward group but to act urgently and decisively to save the lives of a small group of victims.
In fact, there is no evidence of urgency, and none to suggest their lives are any different from many other groups, such as neglected or abused children. In particular, psychological profiles do not distinguish between ordinary personality disorder and the self-selected group who seek identity change. They are essentially the same in every respect except for the decision to change sex, or, as we used to say, “lumpy, dumpy and grumpy.” Lumpy, as in rather overweight, clumsy, graceless in their frayed and baggy jeans, cut down camos and bovver boots; dumpy as in down in the ~; and grumpy, as in surly, mistrustful and resentful of the tedious processes of institutional care: “I know what I am, why can’ I get cut now, ‘steada goin’ frough all this borin’ shit?”
So what has this to do with psychiatry? In the cold light of day, nothing. If people want to cover themselves with tattoos, go right ahead. If they want a nose job and a tummy tuck, feel free, not my business (even for fat men who want a “six pack” abdo delivered by plastic surgery; truly gross). It may become a matter for psychiatry if it becomes clear that this is a fad affecting a specific group of the community, teenage girls who feel they are misfits who have been “discovered” or “rescued” by groups of activists prowling around where misfit teenage girls are likely to hang out. As extremist churches and other whacko religious groups do. The last thing we want is for this burgeoning movement to turn into another cult, if it hasn’t already done so.
As the Cass Report makes clear, the whole thing is a mess, driven almost entirely by “activists” motivated by intense personal interest, with next to no valid, objective evidence to support their push. From the time an unhappy 15yo girl walks into a gender identity clinic to the point where a 23yo not-quite-man walks out, how much does it cost? We’re not told but it would not be less than half a million pounds (AU$1million), and it’s irreversible. Perhaps the UK government feels it has money to splash around on such matters but I think they would be better off waiting for the science to arrive so they can be sure this is not just a fad among isolated, miserable teenagers who feel they aren’t making it as girls. As they say, fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Because as one viewer of a YouTube video by the American Academy of Pediatrics commented: “When I was a kid, ‘expressing discomfort with your biological sex’ was called puberty.”
****
The whole of this work is copyright but can be quoted or retransmitted on condition the author is acknowledged.

It appears that we are in or have somehow moved into some kind of culture of numbness. Were we always this way? Or did we somehow get this way? Is this a new expression of an ancient problem within the soul? Is there such a thing as natural feelings? Something inside me feels so numb. I wonder if it has anything to do with the psych drugs I take.